Effect of hydroponic culture on amino acid composition of whole plant barley and wheat seedlings and comparative analysis

doi:10.6048/j.issn.1001-4330.2023.07.004

Abstract

Abstract:

【Objective】 To clarify the effect of hydroponic culture on the amino acid composition of whole plant barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) and wheat (Triticum aestivum) seedlings, and compare the difference of their nutritional value, so as to provide a basis for the development and utilization of hydroponic green fodder and crop screening.【Methods】 Taking common barley (Ganpi 8) and wheat (Xindong 18) varieties in Xinjiang as the research object, after 3 days of germination and 5 days of hydroponics treatment in a controlled environment, the amino acid content of the stem and root parts of the whole plant of hydroponics barley and wheat were determined respectively. At the same time, the amino acid composition and nutritional value of barley and wheat seeds without germination and hydroponics were analyzed as the control.【Results】 The results showed that compared with the seed, after 5 days of hydroponic culture, the total amino acid content of barley and wheat in the stem and leaf increased by 129% and 102%. The content of other 16 amino acids increased significantly (P<0.05), otherwise the glutamic acid content decreased. The content of lysine increased 3-4 times, and the contents of delicious, sweet, aromatic and effective amino acids increased also; The contents of essential amino acids, total amino acids and special functional amino acids in wheat roots decreased slightly, the content of nonessential amino acids in barley roots decreased by 10%, and the contents of sweet and effective amino acids increased slightly. Compared with the two crops after hydroponics, the contents of 12 kinds of amino acids in the stems and leaves of wheat were the highest(P<0.05), such as lysine, aspartic acid and alanine. The contents of flavor amino acids and effective amino acids were significantly higher than those of barley; The contents of leucine, proline and other five amino acids in barley stem and leaf were the highest (P<0.05). 【Conclusion】 To sum up, after 5 days of hydroponic cultivation, the seeds and seedlings have enriched the amino acid nutrition of the stems and leaves, and the amino acid nutrition value of hydroponic wheat is higher than that of barley.

Key words: hydroponic forage; barley; wheat; amino acid composition

摘要：

【目的】研究水培对全株大麦(Hordeum vulgare L.)、小麦(Triticum aestivum)苗氨基酸组成的影响,对比二者营养价值的差异,为水培青饲料开发利用及作物筛选提供依据。【方法】以新疆主栽大麦(甘啤8号)、小麦(新冬18号)品种为研究对象,经萌发3 d、在可控环境水培5 d后,分别测定全株水培大麦和小麦苗的茎叶、根系部分的氨基酸含量,以未进行萌发、水培的大麦、小麦籽实为对照,对比分析水培前后氨基酸组成,以及大麦和小麦苗的差异。【结果】与籽实相比,水培5 d大麦茎叶、小麦茎叶的总氨基酸含量增加了129%、102%,除谷氨酸的含量降低外,其余16种氨基酸含量均显著增加(P<0.05),赖氨酸含量提高3~4倍,鲜味、甜味、芳香及药效氨基酸含量提高;小麦根系的必需氨基酸、总氨基酸含量、特殊功能氨基酸略有减少,大麦根系的非必需氨基酸含量减少10%,甜味和药效氨基酸含量略有增加。2种作物水培后相比:小麦茎叶的赖氨酸、天冬氨酸、丙氨酸等12种氨基酸含量最高(P<0.05),呈味氨基酸和药效氨基酸含量明显高于大麦;大麦茎叶的亮氨酸、脯氨酸等5种氨基酸含量最高(P<0.05)。【结论】水培5 d籽实成苗后,丰富了茎叶部分的氨基酸营养成分,且水培小麦的氨基酸营养价值高于大麦。

关键词: 水培饲草, 大麦, 小麦, 氨基酸组成

CLC Number:

S512.3

YANG Jinyu, WANG Xihe, SUN Jiusheng. Effect of hydroponic culture on amino acid composition of whole plant barley and wheat seedlings and comparative analysis[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 60(7): 1589-1595.

杨金钰, 王西和, 孙九胜. 水培对全株大麦和小麦苗氨基酸组成的影响及对比分析[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2023, 60(7): 1589-1595.

Figures/Tables 2

References 13

[1]	Naik P K, Swain B K, Singh N P. Production and utilisation of hydroponics fodder[J]. India Journal of Animal Nutrition, 2015, 32(1):1-9.
[2]	Gebremedhin WK. Nutritional benefit and economic value of feeding hydroponically grown maize and barley fodder for Konkan Kanyal goats[J]. Journal of Veterinary Science. 2015, 8:24-30.
[3]	Ata M. Effect of hydroponic barley fodder on Awassi Lambs performance[J]. Journal of Biology Agriculture & Healthcare. 2016, 6:60-64.
[4]	Zahera R, Permana IG, Despal. Utilization of Mungbean’ s green house fodder and silage in the ration for lactating dairy cows[J]. Media Peternak. 2015; 38:123-31. DOI URL
[5]	Francis JM, Apgar G, Crandell KG, et al. The effects of hydroponic wheat fodder on fecal metabolites in equines[J]. Journal of Equine Veterinary Science. 2018, doi:10.1016/j.jevs.2018.05.212. DOI
[6]	ZHAO Juan, FENG Lin, LIU Yang, et al. Effect of dietary isoleucine on the immunity, antioxidant status, tight junctions and microflora in the intestine of juvenile Jian carp[J]. Fish & Shellfish Immunology, 2014, 41(2):663- 673.
[7]	LIU Yingying, KONG Xiangfeng, JIANG Guoli, et al. Effects of dietary protein/energy ratio on growth performance,carcass trait,meat quality,and plasma metabolites in pigs of different genotypes[J]. Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology. 2015: 6(4):435-444.
[8]	黄杰, 马婷婷, 陈志远, 等. N-羟甲基蛋氨酸钙水平对泌乳奶牛生产性能、瘤胃发酵和营养物质消化的影响[J]. 草业科学, 2020, 37(8):1598-1607.
	HUANG Jie, MA Tingting, CHEN Zhiyuan, et al. Effects of N-hydroxymethyl methionine calcium on production performance and rumen fermentation of lactating dairy cows[J]. Pratacultural Science, 2020, 37(8):1598-1607.
[9]	杨金钰. 水培大麦苗生长及饲用营养物质代谢对不同光配方和氮素的响应[J]. 乌鲁木齐:新疆农业大学博士学位论文, 2022.
	YANG Jinyu. Responses of seedling growth and feed nutrient metabolism of hydroponic barley in different light formulas and nitrogen Level[D]. PhD Thesis. Urumqi: Xinjiang Agricultural University, 2022.
[10]	彭真汾, 王威, 叶清华, 等. 高效液相色谱-串联质谱法定量分析橄榄果实氨基酸组分[J]. 食品科学, 2018, 39(24):231-238. DOI
	PENG Zhenfen, WANG Wei, YE Qinghua, et al. Quantitative analysis of amino acids in Chinese olive using high performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry[J]. Food Science, 2018, 39(24):231-238. DOI
[11]	张端莉, 桂余, 方国珊, 等. 大麦在发芽过程中营养物质的变化及其营养评价[J]. 食品科学, 2014, 35(1):229-233. DOI
	ZHANG Duanli, GUI Yu, FANG Guoshan, et al. Nutrient change and nutritional evaluation of barley during germination[J]. Science of food, 2014, 35(1):229-233. DOI URL
[12]	刘慧, 王朝辉, 李福翠, 等. 不同麦区小麦籽粒蛋白质与氨基酸含量及评价[J]. 作物学报, 2016, 42(5):768-777.
	LIU Hui, WANG Zhaohui, LI Fucui, et al. Contents of protein and amino acids of wheat grain in different wheat production regions and their evaluation[J]. Acta Agronomicascinica, 2016, 42(5):768-777.
[13]	蒋芮, 李雅婷, 欧阳鹏凌, 等. 发芽大麦对黑大麦游离氨基酸及其其他营养成分的影响[J]. 食品工业科技, 2018, 39(6):38-42.
	JIANG Rui, LI Yating, OU YANG Pengling, et al. Effects of germination on free amino acidsand other nutrients in black barley[J]. Science and technology of food industry, 2018, 39(6):38-42.

氨基酸 Amino acid	大麦Barley			小麦Wheat
氨基酸 Amino acid	籽实 Seed	茎叶 Stem and leaf	根系 Root	籽实 Seed	茎叶 Stem and leaf	根系 Root
苏氨酸(Thr)	0.33±0.00^f	0.84±0.01^b	0.42±0.01^c	0.36±0.01^e	0.95±0.01^a	0.4±0.01^d
缬氨酸(Val)	0.56±0.01^e	1.36±0.05^a	0.76±0.01^c	0.60±0.01^d	1.24±0.02^b	0.54±0.00^e
甲硫氨酸(Met)	0.13±0.00^d	0.26±0.01^b	0.13±0.00^d	0.21±0.00^c	0.40±0.01^a	0.21±0.02^c
异亮氨酸(Ile)	0.43±0.00^e	1.06±0.03^a	0.64±0.01^c	0.50±0.01^d	0.93±0.01^b	0.42±0.03^e
亮氨酸(Leu)	0.86±0.01^e	1.76±0.03^a	0.96±0.01^c	0.93±0.00^d	1.58±0.02^b	0.76±0.01^f
苯丙氨酸(Phe)	0.66±0.02^e	1.16±0.01^b	0.56±0.01^f	0.78±0.00^c	1.38±0.01^a	0.68±0.01^d
赖氨酸(Lys)	0.44±0.01^d	1.46±0.01^b	0.61±0.00^c	0.44±0.01^d	1.76±0.03^a	0.60±0.02^c
必需氨基酸(EAA)	3.40±0.02^f	7.90±0.12^b	4.08±0.01^c	3.81±0.01^d	8.24±0.10^a	3.62±0.09^e
天冬氨酸(Asp)	0.72±0.01^d	5.86±0.08^b	1.42±0.02^c	0.78±0.02^d	6.51±0.02^a	1.38±0.02^c
丝氨酸(Ser)	0.44±0.00^f	1.01±0.00^b	0.48±0.01^e	0.56±0.02^c	1.18±0.02^a	0.54±0.01^d
谷氨酸(Glu)	2.7±0.07^c	2.54±0.04^d	1.28±0.03^f	3.88±0.04^a	3.07±0.04^b	2.03±0.02^e
甘氨酸(Gly)	0.46±0.01^e	1.10±0.01^b	0.60±0.01^c	0.58±0.01^c	1.20±0.02^a	0.54±0.04^d
丙氨酸(Ala)	0.46±0.01^f	1.40±0.01^b	0.77±0.00^c	0.51±0.01^e	1.46±0.02^a	0.60±0.04^d
胱氨酸(Cys)	0.17±0.00^d	0.22±0.01^c	0.08±0.00^e	0.29±0.00^b	0.42±0.01^a	0.17±0.01^d
酪氨酸(Tyr)	0.26±0.01^e	0.62±0.01^b	0.36±0.01^d	0.43±0.00^c	0.84±0.01^a	0.36±0.04^d
组氨酸(His)	0.27±0.00^e	0.76±0.01^a	0.39±0.00^d	0.46±0.01^b	0.75±0.00^a	0.44±0.01^c
精氨酸(Arg)	0.60±0.02^d	1.08±0.01^b	0.60±0.01^d	0.67±0.01^c	1.36±0.02^a	0.58±0.01^d
脯氨酸(Pro)	1.06±0.01^d	1.72±0.01^a	0.46±0.01^f	1.16±0.00^c	1.44±0.01^b	0.76±0.03^e
非必需氨基酸(NEAA)	7.13±0.09^e	16.30±0.07^b	6.44±0.03^f	9.31±0.06^c	18.24±0.13^a	9.39±0.05^d
氨基酸总量(TAA)	10.54±0.10^e	24.20±0.15^b	10.52±0.04^e	13.13±0.01^c	26.47±0.22^a	11.01±0.14^d
必需氨基酸/总氨基酸 (EAA/TAA)	32.30±0.17^c	32.63±0.31^bc	38.81±0.11^a	29.05±0.02^e	31.11±0.10^d	32.87±0.37^b

氨基酸 Amino acid	大麦Barley			小麦Wheat
氨基酸 Amino acid	籽实 Seed	茎叶 Stem and leaf	根系 Root	籽实 Seed	茎叶 Stem and leaf	根系 Root
苏氨酸(Thr)	0.33±0.00^f	0.84±0.01^b	0.42±0.01^c	0.36±0.01^e	0.95±0.01^a	0.4±0.01^d
缬氨酸(Val)	0.56±0.01^e	1.36±0.05^a	0.76±0.01^c	0.60±0.01^d	1.24±0.02^b	0.54±0.00^e
甲硫氨酸(Met)	0.13±0.00^d	0.26±0.01^b	0.13±0.00^d	0.21±0.00^c	0.40±0.01^a	0.21±0.02^c
异亮氨酸(Ile)	0.43±0.00^e	1.06±0.03^a	0.64±0.01^c	0.50±0.01^d	0.93±0.01^b	0.42±0.03^e
亮氨酸(Leu)	0.86±0.01^e	1.76±0.03^a	0.96±0.01^c	0.93±0.00^d	1.58±0.02^b	0.76±0.01^f
苯丙氨酸(Phe)	0.66±0.02^e	1.16±0.01^b	0.56±0.01^f	0.78±0.00^c	1.38±0.01^a	0.68±0.01^d
赖氨酸(Lys)	0.44±0.01^d	1.46±0.01^b	0.61±0.00^c	0.44±0.01^d	1.76±0.03^a	0.60±0.02^c
必需氨基酸(EAA)	3.40±0.02^f	7.90±0.12^b	4.08±0.01^c	3.81±0.01^d	8.24±0.10^a	3.62±0.09^e
天冬氨酸(Asp)	0.72±0.01^d	5.86±0.08^b	1.42±0.02^c	0.78±0.02^d	6.51±0.02^a	1.38±0.02^c
丝氨酸(Ser)	0.44±0.00^f	1.01±0.00^b	0.48±0.01^e	0.56±0.02^c	1.18±0.02^a	0.54±0.01^d
谷氨酸(Glu)	2.7±0.07^c	2.54±0.04^d	1.28±0.03^f	3.88±0.04^a	3.07±0.04^b	2.03±0.02^e
甘氨酸(Gly)	0.46±0.01^e	1.10±0.01^b	0.60±0.01^c	0.58±0.01^c	1.20±0.02^a	0.54±0.04^d
丙氨酸(Ala)	0.46±0.01^f	1.40±0.01^b	0.77±0.00^c	0.51±0.01^e	1.46±0.02^a	0.60±0.04^d
胱氨酸(Cys)	0.17±0.00^d	0.22±0.01^c	0.08±0.00^e	0.29±0.00^b	0.42±0.01^a	0.17±0.01^d
酪氨酸(Tyr)	0.26±0.01^e	0.62±0.01^b	0.36±0.01^d	0.43±0.00^c	0.84±0.01^a	0.36±0.04^d
组氨酸(His)	0.27±0.00^e	0.76±0.01^a	0.39±0.00^d	0.46±0.01^b	0.75±0.00^a	0.44±0.01^c
精氨酸(Arg)	0.60±0.02^d	1.08±0.01^b	0.60±0.01^d	0.67±0.01^c	1.36±0.02^a	0.58±0.01^d
脯氨酸(Pro)	1.06±0.01^d	1.72±0.01^a	0.46±0.01^f	1.16±0.00^c	1.44±0.01^b	0.76±0.03^e
非必需氨基酸(NEAA)	7.13±0.09^e	16.30±0.07^b	6.44±0.03^f	9.31±0.06^c	18.24±0.13^a	9.39±0.05^d
氨基酸总量(TAA)	10.54±0.10^e	24.20±0.15^b	10.52±0.04^e	13.13±0.01^c	26.47±0.22^a	11.01±0.14^d
必需氨基酸/总氨基酸 (EAA/TAA)	32.30±0.17^c	32.63±0.31^bc	38.81±0.11^a	29.05±0.02^e	31.11±0.10^d	32.87±0.37^b

项目 Items	大麦Barley			小麦Wheat
	籽实 Seed	茎叶 Stem and leaf	根系 Root	籽实 Seed	茎叶 Stem and leaf	根系 Root
	鲜味氨基酸 Fresh aminoacid	4.93±0.09^e	11.97±0.06^b	4.67±0.03^f	6.41±0.01^c	13.61±0.10^a	5.12±0.11^d
甜味氨基酸 Sweet amino acid	3.01±0.02^f	6.82±0.03^b	3.12±0.01^e	3.62±0.01^e	6.98±0.07^a	3.28±0.07^d
芳香氨基酸 Aromatic amino acid	0.92±0.01^e	1.78±0.01^b	0.92±0.02^e	1.21±0.00^c	2.22±0.01^a	1.04±0.03^d
药效氨基酸 Pharmacodynamic amino acid	3.41±0.03^f	7.35±0.06^b	3.81±0.02^d	4.03±0.01^c	8.26±0.08^a	3.58±0.02^e

项目 Items	大麦Barley			小麦Wheat
	籽实 Seed	茎叶 Stem and leaf	根系 Root	籽实 Seed	茎叶 Stem and leaf	根系 Root
	鲜味氨基酸 Fresh aminoacid	4.93±0.09^e	11.97±0.06^b	4.67±0.03^f	6.41±0.01^c	13.61±0.10^a	5.12±0.11^d
甜味氨基酸 Sweet amino acid	3.01±0.02^f	6.82±0.03^b	3.12±0.01^e	3.62±0.01^e	6.98±0.07^a	3.28±0.07^d
芳香氨基酸 Aromatic amino acid	0.92±0.01^e	1.78±0.01^b	0.92±0.02^e	1.21±0.00^c	2.22±0.01^a	1.04±0.03^d
药效氨基酸 Pharmacodynamic amino acid	3.41±0.03^f	7.35±0.06^b	3.81±0.02^d	4.03±0.01^c	8.26±0.08^a	3.58±0.02^e

[1]	LI Jin, SHEN Yuyang, DENG Feifei, CHEN Jianghua, SUN Jingjing, LI Guangkuo, GAO Haifeng. Analysis of Occurrence Status and Control Strategies of Wheat Harmful Organisms in Xinjiang [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(S1): 122-126.
[2]	FANG Hui, DING Yindeng, FAN Guiqiang, GAO Yonghong, HUANG Tianrong. Research report on the development status of wheat industry in southern Xinjiang [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(S1): 75-80.
[3]	WANG Chunsheng, LI Jianfeng, ZHANG Yueqiang, FAN Zheru, WANG Zhong, GAO Xin, SHI Jia, ZHANG Hongzhi, WANG Lihong, XIA Jianqiang, WANG Fangping, ZHAO Qi. Study on genotypic differences of anther culture ability in mainly cultivated spring wheat varieties in Xinjiang [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(9): 2081-2086.
[4]	CHANG Keqin, DU Yanping, MU Lanhai, YANG Chongqing, CHEN Yixin. Analysis of stable yield and adaptability of buckwheat varieties based on AMMI model and GGE double label graph [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(9): 2152-2159.
[5]	SHEN Yuyang, HONG Gaojie, FAN Guiqiang, CHEN Li, LEI Junjie, LI Guangkuo, GAO Haifeng. The control effect of reduced pesticides application and adjuvant addition on wheat aphids in jujube-wheat intercropping pattern [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(9): 2257-2268.
[6]	HOU Lili, WANG Wei, CUI Xinju, ZHOU Dawei. Effects of organic and inorganic combined application on yield, soil nutrients and enzyme activities of winter wheat [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(8): 1845-1852.
[7]	CHEN Fang, LI Zihui, WANG Bingyue, SUN Xiaogui, ZHANG Tingjun. Effects of microbial inoculants on growth and yield of winter wheat [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(8): 1853-1860.
[8]	YUAN Yingying, ZHAO Jinghua, Dilimulati Simayi, YANG Tingrui. Study on physiological indexes and yield analysis of spring wheat in pots based on apriori algorithm [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(8): 1861-1871.
[9]	YUAN Yilin, YAN An, ZUO Xiaoxiao, HOU Zhengqing, ZHANG Zhenfei, XIAO Shuting, SUN Zhe, MA Mengqian, ZHAO Yuhang. Impact of reduced nitrogen fertilization combined with bio-organic fertilizer on spring wheat yield enhancement and soil enrichment [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(8): 1872-1882.
[10]	LIU Xuhuan, YU Shan, LIU Yue, SHI Shubing. Comparative on the vigor differences of spring wheat seeds of different sizes [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(8): 1883-1887.
[11]	MIAO Yu, CHEN Cuixia, MA Yanming, XING Guofang, DONG Yusheng, CHEN Zhijun, WANG Xian, XIANG Li. Genetic diversity analysis of phenotypic traits of 276 Central Asian barley germplasm resources [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(8): 1888-1895.
[12]	YANG Mei, ZHAO Hongmei, Dilireba Xiamixiding, YANG Weijun, ZHANG Jinshan, HUI Chao. Effects of nitrogen fertilizer reduction and biochar application on population structure, photosynthetic characteristics and yield of spring wheat [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(7): 1582-1589.
[13]	DU Yun, ZHANG Jingjing, LEI Jiacheng, LI Bo, LI Yongfu. Forecasting method of water requirement of winter wheat [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(7): 1590-1596.
[14]	QIANG Lidong, FENG Kuan, ZHU Changan, ZHAO Yun, LI Zhaofeng, LI Weihua. Effect of high temperature stress at anthesis on seed vigor of wheat [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(6): 1345-1351.
[15]	WANG Yizhao, YANG Qizhi, LIU Yuxiu, Alayi Nurkamali, Vladimir Shvidchenko, ZHANG Zhengmao. Evaluation of drought resistance of different Kazakhstan spring wheat at seeding stage under PEG-6000 stress [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(6): 1352-1360.