Variety Comparison Test of Silage Corn in Aral Area

doi:10.6048/j.issn.1001-4330.2022.12.010

Abstract

Abstract:

【Objective】 To select silage maize varieties suitable for planting in Aral region of Xinjiang.【Methods】 The nutritional components were determined in lab and the nine silage maize varieties and their nutritional quality was evaluated by RFV and grey correlation degree.【Results】 The results showed that there were significant differences in hay yield, CP (Crude protein), EE (Crude fat), ADF (Acid detergent fiber), NDF (Neutral detergent fiber), ash (Crude ash) and str (Starch) contents among nine silage maize varieties (P< 0.05); The fresh yield of Xinsiyu 12 was the highest up to 1.19×10⁵ kg/hm², the lowest NDF content was 51.87%. CP content of Xinwo No. 1 was the highest up to 7.60%, and the lowest ADF content was 28.53%. EE content of Jiyu 336 was the highest up to 3.16%, the lowest Ash content was to 6.06 %, and Str content was the highest up to 30.87%.【Conclusion】 According to the comprehensive evaluation of field performance and gray analysis, Huamu 3, Jiyu 336, Xinsiyu 11 and Tunyu 168 are suitable for cultivation and planting in Aral area.

Key words: silage maize; yield; nutrition

摘要： 【目的】 筛选并综合评价适合新疆阿拉尔地区栽培的青贮玉米品种。【方法】 采用小区试验,测定9个青贮玉米品种的农艺性状、生产性能和营养成分,对其营养品质进行相对饲用价值RFV评价和灰色关联度综合评价。【结果】 9个青贮玉米品种干草产量、粗蛋白(CP)、粗脂肪(EE)、酸性洗涤纤维(ADF)、中性洗涤纤维(NDF)、粗灰分(Ash)及淀粉(Str)含量均差异显著(P<0.05);其中新饲玉12号鲜草产量最高为1.19×10⁵kg/hm²,NDF含量最低为51.87%;新沃1号CP含量最高为7.60%,ADF含量最低为28.53%;机玉336EE含量最高为3.16%,Ash最低为6.06%,Str含量最高为30.87%。【结论】 华牧3号、机玉336、新饲玉11号和屯玉168适宜在新疆阿拉尔地区种植。

关键词: 青贮玉米, 产量, 营养品质

CLC Number:

S513

HE Wanrong, SUN Qiang, XI Linqiao, DUAN Zhenyu. Variety Comparison Test of Silage Corn in Aral Area[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2022, 59(12): 2948-2956.

何万荣, 孙强, 席琳乔, 段震宇. 9个青贮玉米品种灰色关联综合评价[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2022, 59(12): 2948-2956.

Figures/Tables 5

References 25

[1]	范锦胜, 张李香, 高巍. 青贮玉米育种初探[J]. 种子, 2009, 28(3):60-63.
	FAN Jinsheng, ZHANG Lixiang, GAO Wei. Preliminary on Breeding of Silage Maize[J]. Seed, 2009, 28(3):60-63.
[2]	孟令聪, 路明, 张志军, 等. 我国青贮玉米育种研究进展[J]. 北方农业学报, 2016, 44(4):99-104.
	MENG Lingcong, LU Ming, ZHANG Zhijun, et al. Research progress of breeding silage maize in China[J]. Northern Agricultural Journal, 2016, 44(4):99-104.
[3]	丁光省. 美国青贮玉米种植情况的调研报告[J]. 中国乳业, 2019,(1):17-22.
	DING Guangsheng. Research Report on Silage Corn Cultivation in the United States[J]. China Dairy Industry, 2019,(1):17-22.
[4]	张林, 周羽, 袁兆慧, 等. 我国青贮玉米生产现状及对策[J]. 河南农业, 2020,(35):58-59.
	ZHANG Lin, ZHOU Yu, YUAN Zhaohui, et al. Present Situation and Countermeasures of Silage Maize Production in China[J]. Henan Agriculture, 2020,(35):58-59.
[5]	周鹏, 曹清杰, 董寿周. 青贮玉米的开发价值及应用[J]. 养殖与饲料, 2020, 19(11):73-74.
	ZHOU Peng, CAO Qingjie, DONG Shouzhou. Development Value and Application of Silage Maiz[J]. Breeding and Feed, 2020, 19(11):73-74.
[6]	刘谊瑶. 发展青贮玉米促进农业增收[J]. 农家参谋, 2020,(21):105-108.
	LIU Yiyao. Developing silage corn to increase agricultural income[J]. The Farmers Consultant, 2020,(21):105-108.
[7]	王丽. 发展青贮玉米促进农业增收[J]. 中国饲料, 2020,(14):126-129.
	LI WANG. Developing silage corn to increase agricultural income[J]. China Feed, 2020,(14):126-129.
[8]	周恪驰, 何长安, 纪春学, 等. 玉米精准种植技术的未来发展方向[J]. 现代农业研究, 2020, 26(10):32-33.
	ZHOU Kechi, HE Zhang’an, JI Chunxue, et al. The Future Development Direction Of Corn Precision Planting Technology[J]. Modern Agricultural Research, 2020, 26(10):32-33.
[9]	焦金龙, 张艳茹, 王伟, 等. 西南地区20个青贮玉米品种(系)比较试验[J]. 湖北农业科学, 2020, 59(20):134-138.
	JIAO Jinlong, ZHANG Yanru, WANG Wei, et al. Comparison of silage yield and quality among 20 maize varieties in southwest China[J]. Hubei Agricultural Sciences, 2020, 59(20):134-138.
[11]	杨云贵, 林艳艳, 陈志飞, 等. 西北地区青贮玉米的生产现状、问题及对策[C]. 2016.
	YANG Yungui, LIN Yanyan, CHEN Zhifei, et al. Production status, problems and Countermeasures of Silage Maize in Northwest China[C]. The 18th Annual Meeting of China Association for Science and Technology, 2016.
[12]	娄芬, 李小冬, 尚以顺, 等. 毕节地区适宜青贮玉米品种(系)筛选及营养价值评价[J]. 草业学报, 2020, 29(6):214-224.
	LOU Fen, LI Xiaodong, SHANG Yishun, et al. Selection of suitable silage maize varieties in the Bijie region based on yield,agronomic and nutritional evaluation[J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2020, 29(6):214-224.
[13]	杨雪萍, 陈菲, 倪奎奎, 等. 近红外光谱分析技术在青贮饲料营养品质检测评价上的研究进展[J]. 饲料工业, 2020, 41(10):19-23.
	YANG Xueping, CHEN Fei, NI Kuikui, et al. Research progress of Near Infrared Reflectance Spectroscopy (NIRS) on silage[J]. Feed Industry, 2020, 41(10):19-23.
[14]	张本瑜, 师尚礼. 73份俄罗斯百脉根的营养价值和相对饲喂价值的评价[J]. 草原与草坪, 2017, 37(1):67-78.
	ZHANG Benyu, SHI Shangli. Evaluation of nutritive value and RFV of 73 Lotuscorniculatus germplasms of Russia[J]. Grasslands and Lawns, 2017, 37(1):67-78.
[15]	孙玉刚. 灰色关联分析及其应用的研究[D]. 南京: 南京航空航天大学, 2007.
	SUN Yugang. Research on Grey Correlation Analysis and Its Application[D], Nanjing: Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 2007.
[16]	曹明霞. 灰色关联分析模型及其应用的研究[D]. 南京: 南京航空航天大学, 2007.
	CAO Mingxia. Research on Grey Correlation Analysis Model and Its Application[D]. Nanjing: Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 2007.
[17]	阿布都艾尼·尤诺斯, 魏林, 阿布力克木·艾山, 等. 喀什地区青贮玉米和粮饲兼用玉米新品种引种试验[J]. 草业与畜牧, 2010,(9):44-45.
	Abudaini, Unus, WEI Lin, Abulikemu, Aishan, et al. Introduction Test of Silage Maize and Grain-Feed Maize in Kashi Region[J]. Grass and Livestock, 2010,(9):44-45.
[18]	程宏伟. 高产优质青贮玉米引种示范观察[J]. 中国畜禽种业, 2014, 10(6):28.
	CHENG Hongwei. Demonstration observation on high yield and high quality silage maize introduction[J]. China Livestock and Poultry in China, 2014, 10(6):28.
[19]	于刚, 高志建, 吕宁. 新疆兵团青贮玉米生产现状及覆膜滴灌栽培技术研究[J]. 新疆农垦科技, 2019, 42(5):3-6.
	YU Gang, GAO Zhijian, LU Ning. Study on the Production Status of Silage Maize in Xinjiang Bingtuan and the Cultivation Technique of Film-coated Drip Irrigation[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Reclamation Technology, 2019, 42(5):3-6.
[20]	刘焕鲜. 达坂城区青贮玉米新品种种植试验[J]. 新疆农垦科技, 2020, 43(9):7-8.
	LIU Huanxian. Xinjiang Farm Research of Science and Technology[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Reclamation Technology, 2020, 43(9):7-8.
[21]	韩兵兵, 魏旭明, 马春强, 等. 青贮玉米引种示范试验[J]. 新疆畜牧业, 2017,(2):43-45.
	HAN Bingbing, WEI Xuming, MA Chunqiang, et al. Demonstration experiment on introduction of silage maize[J]. Xinjiang Animal Husbandry, 2017,(2):43-45.
[22]	Liang S H, Zhang X Y, Lu Y, et al. Performance of double cropping silage maize with plastic mulch in the North China Plain[J]. Agronomy Journal, 2020, 112(5).
[23]	庄克章, 吴荣华, 张春艳, 等. 种植密度对不同类型玉米青贮产量和营养价值的影响[J]. 作物杂志, 2019,(6):140-144.
	ZHUANG Kezhang, WU Ronghua, ZHANG Chunyan, et al. Effects of Density on Yield and Nutritional Value of Different Types of Silage Maize[J]. Crops, 2019,(6):140-144.
[24]	徐翠, 陈梅, 秦源源, 等. 云南永德县南亚热带地区“粮改饲”青贮玉米品种筛选[J]. 草学, 2020,(1):26-32.
	XU Cui, CHEN Mei, QIN Yuanyuan, et al. Screening of Silage Maize Varieties of“Grain eformed Feeding”in South Subtropical egion of Yongde County,Yunnan Province[J]. Grassland Science, 2020,(1):26-32.
[25]	刘建宁, 石永红, 吴欣明, 等. 晋中盆地15个青贮玉米品种生产性能及营养价值评价[J]. 草地学报, 2020, 28(4):1043-1049. DOI
	LIU Jianning, SHI Yonghong Shi, WU Xinming, et al. Comprehensive Evaluation and Analysis of the Performahce and NutritionalValue of 15 Silage Maize Varieties in Jinzhong Basin[J]. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2020, 28(4):1043-1049.

品种编号 Code	播种期 Sowing date (month. day)	出苗期 Seeding stage (month. day)	抽雄期 Tasseling stage (month. day)	吐丝期 Silking stage (month. day)	收获期 Harvest time (month. day)
新饲玉12号 Xinsiyu 12	04-21	05-03	07-05	07-06	07-25
新饲玉10号 Xinsiyu 10	04-21	05-02	07-05	07-07	07-25
新饲玉11号 Xinsiyu 11	04-21	05-02	07-06	07-07	07-25
京科932 Jinke 932	04-21	05-03	06-30	07-03	07-25
机玉336 Jiyu 336	04-21	05-02	07-01	07-02	07-25
华牧3号 Hua mu 3	04-21	05-02	07-05	07-05	07-25
屯玉168 Tunyu168	04-21	05-05	07-06	07-08	07-25
禾玉9566 Heyu 9566	04-21	05-02	07-02	07-05	07-25
新沃1号 Xinwo 1	04-21	05-02	07-09	07-11	07-25

品种编号 Code	播种期 Sowing date (month. day)	出苗期 Seeding stage (month. day)	抽雄期 Tasseling stage (month. day)	吐丝期 Silking stage (month. day)	收获期 Harvest time (month. day)
新饲玉12号 Xinsiyu 12	04-21	05-03	07-05	07-06	07-25
新饲玉10号 Xinsiyu 10	04-21	05-02	07-05	07-07	07-25
新饲玉11号 Xinsiyu 11	04-21	05-02	07-06	07-07	07-25
京科932 Jinke 932	04-21	05-03	06-30	07-03	07-25
机玉336 Jiyu 336	04-21	05-02	07-01	07-02	07-25
华牧3号 Hua mu 3	04-21	05-02	07-05	07-05	07-25
屯玉168 Tunyu168	04-21	05-05	07-06	07-08	07-25
禾玉9566 Heyu 9566	04-21	05-02	07-02	07-05	07-25
新沃1号 Xinwo 1	04-21	05-02	07-09	07-11	07-25

编号	CP(%)	EE(%)	ADF(%)	NDF(%)	Ash(%)	Str(%)	RFV
新饲玉12号 Xinsiyu 12	7.56±0.02^abc	2.34±0.06^c	28.69±0.12^b	51.87±0.40^b	7.73±0.33^a	26.35±0.66^c	119.35
新饲玉10号 Xinsiyu 10	7.53±0.02^abc	2.74±0.11^abc	29.84±0.37^ab	52.74±0.20^ab	6.96±0.23^ab	28.28±0.60^abc	115.80
新饲玉11号 Xinsiyu 11	7.57±0.01^abc	2.95±0.19^ab	30.34±0.66^ab	53.78±0.23^a	6.30±0.23^b	29.99±0.63^ab	112.89
京科932 Jinke 932	7.56±0.02^abc	2.70±0.23^bc	29.40±0.59^ab	52.78±0.55^ab	6.73±0.42^ab	28.62±1.43^abc	116.31
机玉336 Jiyu 336	7.49±0.01^c	3.16±0.07^a	30.72±0.24^a	53.47±0.09^a	6.06±0.05^b	30.87±0.18^a	113.03
华牧3号 Huamu 3	7.59±0.02^ab	2.55±0.07^bc	29.09±0.25^ab	52.79±0.15^ab	7.13±0.08^ab	27.99±0.53^bc	116.72
屯玉168 Tunyu 168	7.50±0.04^bc	2.99±0.17^ab	30.71±1.15^a	53.08±0.25^a	6.73±0.43^ab	29.27±0.63^ab	113.88
禾玉9566 Heyu 9566	7.56±0.04^abc	2.77±0.09^abc	30.03±0.45^ab	53.14±0.34^a	7.00±0.57^ab	28.92±0.68^abc	114.67
新沃1号 Xinwo 1	7.60±0.00^a	2.48±0.06^c	28.53±0.15^b	52.71±0.36^ab	6.95±0.15^ab	28.01±0.71^bc	117.68

编号	CP(%)	EE(%)	ADF(%)	NDF(%)	Ash(%)	Str(%)	RFV
新饲玉12号 Xinsiyu 12	7.56±0.02^abc	2.34±0.06^c	28.69±0.12^b	51.87±0.40^b	7.73±0.33^a	26.35±0.66^c	119.35
新饲玉10号 Xinsiyu 10	7.53±0.02^abc	2.74±0.11^abc	29.84±0.37^ab	52.74±0.20^ab	6.96±0.23^ab	28.28±0.60^abc	115.80
新饲玉11号 Xinsiyu 11	7.57±0.01^abc	2.95±0.19^ab	30.34±0.66^ab	53.78±0.23^a	6.30±0.23^b	29.99±0.63^ab	112.89
京科932 Jinke 932	7.56±0.02^abc	2.70±0.23^bc	29.40±0.59^ab	52.78±0.55^ab	6.73±0.42^ab	28.62±1.43^abc	116.31
机玉336 Jiyu 336	7.49±0.01^c	3.16±0.07^a	30.72±0.24^a	53.47±0.09^a	6.06±0.05^b	30.87±0.18^a	113.03
华牧3号 Huamu 3	7.59±0.02^ab	2.55±0.07^bc	29.09±0.25^ab	52.79±0.15^ab	7.13±0.08^ab	27.99±0.53^bc	116.72
屯玉168 Tunyu 168	7.50±0.04^bc	2.99±0.17^ab	30.71±1.15^a	53.08±0.25^a	6.73±0.43^ab	29.27±0.63^ab	113.88
禾玉9566 Heyu 9566	7.56±0.04^abc	2.77±0.09^abc	30.03±0.45^ab	53.14±0.34^a	7.00±0.57^ab	28.92±0.68^abc	114.67
新沃1号 Xinwo 1	7.60±0.00^a	2.48±0.06^c	28.53±0.15^b	52.71±0.36^ab	6.95±0.15^ab	28.01±0.71^bc	117.68

品种 Variety	加权关联度 Weighted correlation degree	排序 Sorting
新饲玉12号 Xinsiyu 12	0.646 9	5
新饲玉10号 Xinsiyu 10	0.601 0	9
新饲玉11号 Xinsiyu 11	0.651 8	3
京科932 Jinke 932	0.611 4	7
机玉336 Jiyu 336	0.700 0	2
华牧3号 Huamu 3	0.720 9	1
屯玉168 Tunyu 168	0.650 3	4
禾玉9566 Heyu9566	0.646 8	6
新沃1号 Xinwo 1	0.603 5	8