新疆农业科学 ›› 2024, Vol. 61 ›› Issue (12): 2902-2912.DOI: 10.6048/j.issn.1001-4330.2024.12.005
• 种质资源·分子遗传学·耕作栽培·生理生化·微生物 • 上一篇 下一篇
郝曦煜1,2(), 刘婷婷3, 王辉3, 冷静文3, 宫世航3, 刘伟3(
), 梁杰1(
)
收稿日期:
2024-05-11
出版日期:
2024-12-20
发布日期:
2025-01-16
通信作者:
刘伟(1974-),男,吉林白城人,研究员,研究方向为蓖麻育种与栽培,(E-mail)jlhyliuwei@126.com;作者简介:
郝曦煜(1990-),男,辽宁铁岭人,副研究员,硕士,研究方向为食用豆育种与栽培,(E-mail)haoxiyu1990@foxmail.com
基金资助:
HAO Xiyu1,2(), LIU Tingting3, WANG Hui3, LENG Jingwen3, GONG Shihang3, LIU Wei3(
), LIANG Jie1(
)
Received:
2024-05-11
Published:
2024-12-20
Online:
2025-01-16
Supported by:
摘要:
【目的】 筛选不同选择目标下最适宜的谷子品种,综合评价适宜不同选择目标的最佳谷子品种。【方法】 2021~2022年分析对比20份谷子新品种的25个农艺性状、产量和品质指标,利用熵权法对各指标赋权,采用DTOPSIS法、灰色关联度分析法评价对不同品种的农艺性状及产量与品质。【结果】 除千粒重外,其余24个指标的谷子品种间差异均达极显著水平。2种分析方法的排序结果与产量排序结果的吻合程度更高,即灰色关联度分析较DTOPSIS法更注重评价产量。Ci最大差异值为30.01%,ri最大差异值为7.71%,γ最大差异值为11.85%,DTOPSIS法更能体现出各谷子品种的差异性。【结论】 DTOPSIS法和熵权法赋权的加权灰色关联度分析法适用于综合评价谷子品种。半干旱生产区应选择张杂谷16号;各性状更平衡的品种应选择金苗K2;兼顾产量和各性状平衡的品种应选择济谷22号。
中图分类号:
郝曦煜, 刘婷婷, 王辉, 冷静文, 宫世航, 刘伟, 梁杰. 基于熵权法和灰色关联度分析法综合评价谷子品种的农艺性状及产量与品质[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(12): 2902-2912.
HAO Xiyu, LIU Tingting, WANG Hui, LENG Jingwen, GONG Shihang, LIU Wei, LIANG Jie. Comprehensive evaluation of foxtail millet varieties based on entropy weight method and grey relational analysis[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(12): 2902-2912.
图1 2021~2022年谷子生育期内各月份平均温度、降雨量与日照时数
Fig.1 Average temperature, rainfall, and sunshine hours per month during the foxtail millet growing period in 2021-2022
品种编号 Varieties No. | 名称 Names | 来源 Source |
---|---|---|
V1 | 公谷88号 | 吉林省农科院作物资源研究所 |
V2 | 黄金苗 | 赤峰市农牧科学研究所 |
V3 | 山西红谷 | 赤峰市农牧科学研究所 |
V4 | 金苗K2 | 赤峰市农牧科学研究所 |
V5 | 赤优金苗1号 | 赤峰市农牧科学研究所 |
V6 | 陇谷13号 | 甘肃省农业科学院作物所 |
V7 | 冀谷168 | 河北省农林科学院谷子研究所 |
V8 | 冀谷39号 | 河北省农林科学院谷子研究所 |
V9 | 张杂谷16号 | 河北省张家口市农业科学院 |
V10 | 豫谷18号 | 河南省安阳市农业科学院 |
V11 | 豫谷35号 | 河南省安阳市农业科学院 |
V12 | 嫩选18号 | 黑龙江省农科院齐齐哈尔分院 |
V13 | 嫩选15号 | 黑龙江省农科院齐齐哈尔分院 |
V14 | 龙谷38号 | 黑龙江省农科院作物资源研究所 |
V15 | 九谷23号 | 吉林省吉林市农业科学院 |
V16 | 朝谷58号 | 辽宁省旱地农林研究所 |
V17 | 济谷22号 | 山东省农业科学院作物研究所 |
V18 | 大同29号 | 山西省农业科学院高寒作物所 |
V19 | 中谷9号 | 中国农业科学院作物科学研究所 |
V20 | 中谷2号 | 中国农业科学院作物科学研究所 |
表1 参试品种
Tab.1 Test cultivars
品种编号 Varieties No. | 名称 Names | 来源 Source |
---|---|---|
V1 | 公谷88号 | 吉林省农科院作物资源研究所 |
V2 | 黄金苗 | 赤峰市农牧科学研究所 |
V3 | 山西红谷 | 赤峰市农牧科学研究所 |
V4 | 金苗K2 | 赤峰市农牧科学研究所 |
V5 | 赤优金苗1号 | 赤峰市农牧科学研究所 |
V6 | 陇谷13号 | 甘肃省农业科学院作物所 |
V7 | 冀谷168 | 河北省农林科学院谷子研究所 |
V8 | 冀谷39号 | 河北省农林科学院谷子研究所 |
V9 | 张杂谷16号 | 河北省张家口市农业科学院 |
V10 | 豫谷18号 | 河南省安阳市农业科学院 |
V11 | 豫谷35号 | 河南省安阳市农业科学院 |
V12 | 嫩选18号 | 黑龙江省农科院齐齐哈尔分院 |
V13 | 嫩选15号 | 黑龙江省农科院齐齐哈尔分院 |
V14 | 龙谷38号 | 黑龙江省农科院作物资源研究所 |
V15 | 九谷23号 | 吉林省吉林市农业科学院 |
V16 | 朝谷58号 | 辽宁省旱地农林研究所 |
V17 | 济谷22号 | 山东省农业科学院作物研究所 |
V18 | 大同29号 | 山西省农业科学院高寒作物所 |
V19 | 中谷9号 | 中国农业科学院作物科学研究所 |
V20 | 中谷2号 | 中国农业科学院作物科学研究所 |
指标 Indexes | 平方和Sum of squares | 自由度Degree of freedom | 均方Mean square | F | 显著性 signifi- cance | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
品种间 Intra- cultivars | 品种内 Inter- cultivars | 总变异 Total | 品种间 Intra- cultivars | 品种内 Inter- cultivars | 总变异 Total | 品种间 Intra- cultivars | 品种内 Inter- cultivars | |||
M1 | 2 636.100 | 53.333 | 2 689.433 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 138.742 | 1.333 | 104.057 | 0.000 |
M2 | 11.250 | 0.533 | 11.783 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.592 | 0.013 | 44.408 | 0.000 |
M3 | 134.850 | 13.333 | 148.183 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 7.097 | 0.333 | 21.292 | 0.000 |
M4 | 105.000 | 13.333 | 118.333 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 5.526 | 0.333 | 16.579 | 0.000 |
M5 | 0.556 | 0.533 | 1.090 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.029 | 0.013 | 2.196 | 0.018 |
M6 | 0.757 | 0.533 | 1.290 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.040 | 0.013 | 2.989 | 0.002 |
M7 | 1.409 | 0.533 | 1.942 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.074 | 0.013 | 5.562 | 0.000 |
M8 | 18.600 | 13.333 | 31.933 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.979 | 0.333 | 2.937 | 0.002 |
M9 | 107.250 | 13.333 | 120.583 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 5.645 | 0.333 | 16.934 | 0.000 |
M10 | 99.000 | 13.333 | 112.333 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 5.211 | 0.333 | 15.632 | 0.000 |
M11 | 2 204.119 | 53.333 | 2257.452 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 116.006 | 1.333 | 87.005 | 0.000 |
M12 | 959.753 | 160.000 | 1 119.753 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 50.513 | 4.000 | 12.628 | 0.000 |
M13 | 979.912 | 53.333 | 1 033.245 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 51.574 | 1.333 | 38.681 | 0.000 |
M14 | 2.070 | 2.133 | 4.203 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.109 | 0.053 | 2.042 | 0.029 |
M15 | 2.513 | 2.133 | 4.646 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.132 | 0.053 | 2.480 | 0.008 |
M16 | 5.849 | 2.133 | 7.982 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.308 | 0.053 | 5.772 | 0.000 |
M17 | 28 471.697 | 1 333.333 | 29 805.030 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 1 498.510 | 33.333 | 44.955 | 0.000 |
M18 | 486.184 | 53.333 | 539.517 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 25.589 | 1.333 | 19.191 | 0.000 |
M19 | 5.408 | 4.800 | 10.208 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.285 | 0.120 | 2.372 | 0.011 |
M20 | 538.794 | 120.000 | 658.794 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 28.358 | 3.000 | 9.453 | 0.000 |
M21 | 444.431 | 120.000 | 564.431 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 23.391 | 3.000 | 7.797 | 0.000 |
M22 | 2.184 | 3.333 | 5.517 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.115 | 0.083 | 1.379 | 0.192 |
M23 | 71 241.616 | 1 333.333 | 72 574.950 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 3 749.559 | 33.333 | 112.487 | 0.000 |
M24 | 67.075 | 13.333 | 80.409 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 3.530 | 0.333 | 10.591 | 0.000 |
M25 | 18.625 | 3.333 | 21.959 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.980 | 0.083 | 11.763 | 0.000 |
表2 参试品种各指标方差变化
Tab.2 Comparisons of variance of each indicator for the tested varieties
指标 Indexes | 平方和Sum of squares | 自由度Degree of freedom | 均方Mean square | F | 显著性 signifi- cance | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
品种间 Intra- cultivars | 品种内 Inter- cultivars | 总变异 Total | 品种间 Intra- cultivars | 品种内 Inter- cultivars | 总变异 Total | 品种间 Intra- cultivars | 品种内 Inter- cultivars | |||
M1 | 2 636.100 | 53.333 | 2 689.433 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 138.742 | 1.333 | 104.057 | 0.000 |
M2 | 11.250 | 0.533 | 11.783 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.592 | 0.013 | 44.408 | 0.000 |
M3 | 134.850 | 13.333 | 148.183 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 7.097 | 0.333 | 21.292 | 0.000 |
M4 | 105.000 | 13.333 | 118.333 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 5.526 | 0.333 | 16.579 | 0.000 |
M5 | 0.556 | 0.533 | 1.090 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.029 | 0.013 | 2.196 | 0.018 |
M6 | 0.757 | 0.533 | 1.290 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.040 | 0.013 | 2.989 | 0.002 |
M7 | 1.409 | 0.533 | 1.942 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.074 | 0.013 | 5.562 | 0.000 |
M8 | 18.600 | 13.333 | 31.933 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.979 | 0.333 | 2.937 | 0.002 |
M9 | 107.250 | 13.333 | 120.583 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 5.645 | 0.333 | 16.934 | 0.000 |
M10 | 99.000 | 13.333 | 112.333 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 5.211 | 0.333 | 15.632 | 0.000 |
M11 | 2 204.119 | 53.333 | 2257.452 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 116.006 | 1.333 | 87.005 | 0.000 |
M12 | 959.753 | 160.000 | 1 119.753 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 50.513 | 4.000 | 12.628 | 0.000 |
M13 | 979.912 | 53.333 | 1 033.245 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 51.574 | 1.333 | 38.681 | 0.000 |
M14 | 2.070 | 2.133 | 4.203 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.109 | 0.053 | 2.042 | 0.029 |
M15 | 2.513 | 2.133 | 4.646 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.132 | 0.053 | 2.480 | 0.008 |
M16 | 5.849 | 2.133 | 7.982 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.308 | 0.053 | 5.772 | 0.000 |
M17 | 28 471.697 | 1 333.333 | 29 805.030 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 1 498.510 | 33.333 | 44.955 | 0.000 |
M18 | 486.184 | 53.333 | 539.517 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 25.589 | 1.333 | 19.191 | 0.000 |
M19 | 5.408 | 4.800 | 10.208 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.285 | 0.120 | 2.372 | 0.011 |
M20 | 538.794 | 120.000 | 658.794 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 28.358 | 3.000 | 9.453 | 0.000 |
M21 | 444.431 | 120.000 | 564.431 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 23.391 | 3.000 | 7.797 | 0.000 |
M22 | 2.184 | 3.333 | 5.517 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.115 | 0.083 | 1.379 | 0.192 |
M23 | 71 241.616 | 1 333.333 | 72 574.950 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 3 749.559 | 33.333 | 112.487 | 0.000 |
M24 | 67.075 | 13.333 | 80.409 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 3.530 | 0.333 | 10.591 | 0.000 |
M25 | 18.625 | 3.333 | 21.959 | 19 | 40 | 59 | 0.980 | 0.083 | 11.763 | 0.000 |
品种编号 Varieties number | M1 | M2 | M3 | M4 | M5 | M6 | M7 | M8 | M9 | M10 | M11 | M12 | M13 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
V1 | 111.7fF | 4.1bB | 11.3cdCD | 14.3cdCD | 1.1abcdeAB | 1.1bcdeABC | 1.1bcdeABC | 10.3aA | 12.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 58.9bBC | 58.9bBC | 63.4abABC |
V2 | 107.7gG | 5.1aA | 10.3deDE | 13.3deDE | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.1cdeBC | 1.1cdeBC | 10.3aA | 12.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 53.7eEFG | 53.7eEFG | 64.9aA |
V3 | 117.7cdDE | 5.1aA | 11.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.1cdeBC | 1.1cdeBC | 10.3aA | 12.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 53.4eFG | 53.4eFG | 61.9bcBCD |
V4 | 115.2eE | 4.1bB | 11.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 0.9cdeB | 1.0cdeC | 1.0cdeC | 9.3abAB | 12.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 44.3ijJK | 44.3ijJK | 51.7fgG |
V5 | 115.2eE | 4.1bB | 13.3abAB | 12.3abAB | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.1bcdeABC | 1.1bcdeABC | 9.3abAB | 12.3cdCD | 15.3abAB | 50.1fH | 50.1fH | 62.7bcABC |
V6 | 119.7bcCD | 4.1bB | 11.3cdCD | 12.3cdCD | 1.1abcdAB | 1.2bcdABC | 1.2bcdABC | 9.3abAB | 10.3eE | 11.3eE | 55.9cdDEF | 55.9cdDEF | 62.7bcABC |
V7 | 111.7fF | 5.1aA | 12.3bcBC | 12.3bcBC | 1.1bcdeAB | 1.1cdeBC | 1.1cdeBC | 10.3aA | 14.3bAB | 15.3abAB | 53.0eG | 53.0eG | 59.3deDEF |
V8 | 117.2deDE | 5.1aA | 12.3bcBC | 12.3bcBC | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.1bcdeABC | 1.1bcdeABC | 9.3abcAB | 11.3deDE | 13.3cdCD | 52.7eG | 52.7eG | 59.7deDEF |
V9 | 112.2fF | 4.1bB | 12.3bcBC | 12.3bcBC | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.0cdeBC | 1.0cdeBC | 10.3aA | 10.3eE | 13.3cdCD | 59.7bAB | 59.7bAB | 58.4eEF |
V10 | 100.7hH | 4.1bB | 9.3fE | 12.3fE | 0.9deB | 1.0deC | 1.0deC | 9.3abAB | 10.3eE | 11.3eE | 54.7deEFG | 54.7deEFG | 53.2fG |
V11 | 117.2deDE | 4.1bB | 13.3abAB | 12.3abAB | 1.1bcdeAB | 1.1cdeBC | 1.1cdeBC | 9.3abAB | 11.3deDE | 15.3abAB | 53.7eEFG | 53.7eEFG | 60.7cdCDE |
V12 | 97.2iI | 4.1bB | 13.3abAB | 11.3abAB | 0.9abcAB | 0.9eC | 0.9eC | 10.3aA | 13.3bcBC | 13.3cdCD | 48.7fgH | 48.7fgH | 61.9bcBCD |
V13 | 123.2aAB | 4.1bB | 7.3gF | 11.3gF | 1.0bcdeB | 1.0cdeBC | 1.0cdeBC | 9.3abAB | 10.3eE | 12.3deDE | 37.7kL | 37.7kL | 52.9fG |
V14 | 118.2cdCD | 4.1bB | 12.3bcBC | 11.3bcBC | 1.1bcdeAB | 1.1bcdeABC | 1.1bcdeABC | 9.3abAB | 12.3cdCD | 14.3bcBC | 56.4cdCDE | 56.4cdCDE | 60.7cdCDE |
V15 | 120.7bBC | 4.1bB | 11.3cdCD | 11.3cdCD | 1.1abcAB | 1.3abAB | 1.3abAB | 10.3aA | 13.3bcBC | 14.3bcBC | 57.7bcBCD | 57.7bcBCD | 63.8abAB |
V16 | 124.7aA | 5.1aA | 12.3bcBC | 11.3bcBC | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.1bcdeABC | 1.1bcdeABC | 9.3abAB | 11.3deDE | 16.3aA | 45.7hiIJ | 45.7hiIJ | 60.7cdCDE |
V17 | 115.2eE | 4.1bB | 12.3bcBC | 11.3bcBC | 0.9eB | 1.1cdeBC | 1.1cdeBC | 9.3abAB | 11.3deDE | 14.3bcBC | 47.7ghHI | 47.7ghHI | 57.7eF |
V18 | 118.2cdCD | 4.1bB | 14.3aA | 10.3aA | 1.3aA | 1.4aA | 1.4aA | 9.3abAB | 15.3aA | 15.3abAB | 47.7ghHI | 47.7ghHI | 59.7deDEF |
V19 | 117.7cdDE | 4.1bB | 11.3cdCD | 9.3cdCD | 1.2abAB | 1.3abAB | 1.3abAB | 8.3bdB | 13.3bcBC | 14.3bcBC | 62.2aA | 62.2aA | 60.7cdCDE |
V20 | 118.7bcdCD | 4.1bB | 12.3bcBC | 7.3bcBC | 1.1abcdeAB | 1.2abcABC | 1.2abcABC | 9.3abAB | 11.3deDE | 13.3cdCD | 42.7jK | 42.7jK | 50.7gG |
品种编号 Varieties number | M14 | M15 | M16 | M17 | M18 | M19 | M20 | M21 | M22 | M23 | M24 | M25 | |
V1 | 2.9abcAB | 3.1bcdeABC | 3.1defgBCDEF | 175.5cBC | 21.8efEFG | 2.7eC | 18.0gH | 14.6iF | 3.2abcA | 318.9nN | 11.5cdefBCD | 11.5cdefBCD | |
V2 | 2.8abcAB | 2.8cdeBC | 2.9fgEF | 186.8bB | 22.0efEFG | 2.8deABC | 19.2fgFGH | 15.5ghiDEF | 2.9abcA | 324.1mnMN | 11.1defgBCDE | 11.7cdeBC | |
V3 | 2.9abcAB | 3.0bcdeABC | 3.2defgBCDEF | 177.3bcBC | 24.1cdCDE | 3.0abcdeABC | 19.1fgFGH | 15.6ghiDEF | 3.3abA | 331.9lmLMN | 10.6efghijCDEF | 12.3bcAB | |
V4 | 2.6cdAB | 2.8deBC | 3.0efgCDEF | 152.3efEF | 25.2cBCD | 3.3abcdeABC | 23.6cdeBCDE | 19.8bcdeBCD | 2.8bcA | 382.8fFG | 11.8cdBC | 13.2abA | |
V5 | 2.7bcdAB | 2.9cdeBC | 2.9fgDEF | 169.3cdCD | 25.5cBCD | 3.3abcdeABC | 23.5cdeBCDEF | 19.5cdeBCDE | 3.0abcA | 372.6gGH | 9.56jF | 12.4bcAB | |
V6 | 2.7bcdAB | 2.8cdeBC | 3.0efgDEF | 137.4hG | 23.1deDE | 2.9cdeABC | 23.5cdeBCDEF | 19.5cdeBCDE | 3.3abA | 372.0gGH | 10.6efghiCDEF | 10.4fghijCDEF | |
V7 | 2.4dB | 2.7eC | 2.8gF | 200.3aA | 25.5cBCD | 3.2abcdeABC | 25.1bcdABCD | 20.7bcdeBC | 2.9abcA | 387.5efEF | 13.5aA | 10.1ghijDEF | |
V8 | 2.8abcAB | 3.1abcdeABC | 3.2bcdefBCDEF | 146.3fghEFG | 18.8hH | 3.5abcABC | 19.0fgGH | 15.2hiEF | 3.1abcA | 328.7lmnMN | 10.0hijEF | 10.6efghiCDEF | |
V9 | 2.9abcAB | 2.9bcdeABC | 3.2bcdefBCDEF | 159.3deDE | 28.0abAB | 3.7aA | 29.08aA | 25.0aA | 3.3abA | 432.0aA | 11.5cdefBCD | 10.7efghiCDEF | |
V10 | 3.1abcA | 3.1abcdABC | 4.1aA | 150.1efEFG | 29.1aA | 3.5abcABC | 23.2cdeBCDEFG | 19.2cdefBCDE | 3.4aA | 367.3ghH | 11.7cdeBC | 9.88ijEF | |
V11 | 2.9abcAB | 3.1abcdeABC | 3.4bcdeBCDE | 159.2deDE | 20.0fghFGH | 2.7deBC | 22.3deCDEFGH | 18.5defgBCDEF | 3.2abcA | 343.5jkJKL | 12.3bcAB | 11.1defghBCDE | |
V12 | 2.9abcAB | 3.0bcdeABC | 3.2bcdefBCDEF | 168.3cdCD | 21.4efgEFGH | 3.2abcdeABC | 23.2cdeBCDEFG | 19.0defBCDE | 2.9abcA | 361.2hiHI | 13.2abA | 11.1defgBCDE | |
V13 | 3.0abcA | 3.2abcABC | 3.7bAB | 91.5iH | 19.4ghGH | 3.2abcdeABC | 24.4bcdeBCD | 20.9bcdeABC | 3.2abcA | 396.9deDE | 12.4bcAB | 11.0defghBCDEF | |
V14 | 2.9abcAB | 2.9bcdeABC | 3.4bcdeBCDE | 144.9fghEFG | 25.4cBCD | 3.4abcdABC | 22.9cdeBCDEFG | 19.0cdefBCDE | 2.7cA | 352.4ijIJ | 10.4fghijCDEF | 10.6efghijCDEF | |
V15 | 2.9abcAB | 3.0bcdeABC | 3.2bcdefBCDEF | 151.3efEFG | 26.2bcBC | 3.6aAB | 26.8abAB | 22.3abcABC | 3.1abcA | 415.3bBC | 10.1ghijDEF | 11.8cdBC | |
V16 | 2.7bcdAB | 3.0bcdeABC | 3.2cdefBCDEF | 139.2ghFG | 26.2bcBC | 3.6aAB | 26.0abcABC | 21.8bcdABC | 2.8abcA | 411.7bcC | 10.6efghiCDEF | 9.56jF | |
V17 | 2.7bcdAB | 2.9bcdeBC | 3.5bcdBCD | 149.5efgEFG | 25.4cBCD | 3.6abABC | 25.3bcdABCD | 21.1bcdeABC | 2.9abcA | 404.2cdCD | 10.7efghiCDEF | 10.6efghiCDEF | |
V18 | 3.2abA | 3.5aA | 3.6bcABC | 151.3efEFG | 22.4deEF | 3.1abcdeABC | 19.2fgEFGH | 16.1fghiDEF | 3.2abcA | 346.8jkJK | 9.88ijEF | 13.5aA | |
V19 | 3.2aA | 3.3abAB | 3.5bcdBCD | 148.2fgEFG | 25.8cBCD | 2.9bcdeABC | 27.3abAB | 22.8abAB | 3.2abcA | 426.4aAB | 11.1defghBCDE | 10.0hijEF | |
V20 | 2.9abcAB | 3.3abAB | 3.4bcdeBCDE | 141.3fghFG | 20.2fghFGH | 3.1abcdeABC | 21.5efDEFGH | 18.0efghCDEF | 3.1abcA | 337.5klKLM | 11.0defghBCDEF | 11.5cdefBCD |
表3 参试品种各指标差异比较
Tab.3 Comparisons of differences in each indicator among the tested varieties
品种编号 Varieties number | M1 | M2 | M3 | M4 | M5 | M6 | M7 | M8 | M9 | M10 | M11 | M12 | M13 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
V1 | 111.7fF | 4.1bB | 11.3cdCD | 14.3cdCD | 1.1abcdeAB | 1.1bcdeABC | 1.1bcdeABC | 10.3aA | 12.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 58.9bBC | 58.9bBC | 63.4abABC |
V2 | 107.7gG | 5.1aA | 10.3deDE | 13.3deDE | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.1cdeBC | 1.1cdeBC | 10.3aA | 12.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 53.7eEFG | 53.7eEFG | 64.9aA |
V3 | 117.7cdDE | 5.1aA | 11.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.1cdeBC | 1.1cdeBC | 10.3aA | 12.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 53.4eFG | 53.4eFG | 61.9bcBCD |
V4 | 115.2eE | 4.1bB | 11.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 0.9cdeB | 1.0cdeC | 1.0cdeC | 9.3abAB | 12.3cdCD | 13.3cdCD | 44.3ijJK | 44.3ijJK | 51.7fgG |
V5 | 115.2eE | 4.1bB | 13.3abAB | 12.3abAB | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.1bcdeABC | 1.1bcdeABC | 9.3abAB | 12.3cdCD | 15.3abAB | 50.1fH | 50.1fH | 62.7bcABC |
V6 | 119.7bcCD | 4.1bB | 11.3cdCD | 12.3cdCD | 1.1abcdAB | 1.2bcdABC | 1.2bcdABC | 9.3abAB | 10.3eE | 11.3eE | 55.9cdDEF | 55.9cdDEF | 62.7bcABC |
V7 | 111.7fF | 5.1aA | 12.3bcBC | 12.3bcBC | 1.1bcdeAB | 1.1cdeBC | 1.1cdeBC | 10.3aA | 14.3bAB | 15.3abAB | 53.0eG | 53.0eG | 59.3deDEF |
V8 | 117.2deDE | 5.1aA | 12.3bcBC | 12.3bcBC | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.1bcdeABC | 1.1bcdeABC | 9.3abcAB | 11.3deDE | 13.3cdCD | 52.7eG | 52.7eG | 59.7deDEF |
V9 | 112.2fF | 4.1bB | 12.3bcBC | 12.3bcBC | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.0cdeBC | 1.0cdeBC | 10.3aA | 10.3eE | 13.3cdCD | 59.7bAB | 59.7bAB | 58.4eEF |
V10 | 100.7hH | 4.1bB | 9.3fE | 12.3fE | 0.9deB | 1.0deC | 1.0deC | 9.3abAB | 10.3eE | 11.3eE | 54.7deEFG | 54.7deEFG | 53.2fG |
V11 | 117.2deDE | 4.1bB | 13.3abAB | 12.3abAB | 1.1bcdeAB | 1.1cdeBC | 1.1cdeBC | 9.3abAB | 11.3deDE | 15.3abAB | 53.7eEFG | 53.7eEFG | 60.7cdCDE |
V12 | 97.2iI | 4.1bB | 13.3abAB | 11.3abAB | 0.9abcAB | 0.9eC | 0.9eC | 10.3aA | 13.3bcBC | 13.3cdCD | 48.7fgH | 48.7fgH | 61.9bcBCD |
V13 | 123.2aAB | 4.1bB | 7.3gF | 11.3gF | 1.0bcdeB | 1.0cdeBC | 1.0cdeBC | 9.3abAB | 10.3eE | 12.3deDE | 37.7kL | 37.7kL | 52.9fG |
V14 | 118.2cdCD | 4.1bB | 12.3bcBC | 11.3bcBC | 1.1bcdeAB | 1.1bcdeABC | 1.1bcdeABC | 9.3abAB | 12.3cdCD | 14.3bcBC | 56.4cdCDE | 56.4cdCDE | 60.7cdCDE |
V15 | 120.7bBC | 4.1bB | 11.3cdCD | 11.3cdCD | 1.1abcAB | 1.3abAB | 1.3abAB | 10.3aA | 13.3bcBC | 14.3bcBC | 57.7bcBCD | 57.7bcBCD | 63.8abAB |
V16 | 124.7aA | 5.1aA | 12.3bcBC | 11.3bcBC | 1.0bcdeAB | 1.1bcdeABC | 1.1bcdeABC | 9.3abAB | 11.3deDE | 16.3aA | 45.7hiIJ | 45.7hiIJ | 60.7cdCDE |
V17 | 115.2eE | 4.1bB | 12.3bcBC | 11.3bcBC | 0.9eB | 1.1cdeBC | 1.1cdeBC | 9.3abAB | 11.3deDE | 14.3bcBC | 47.7ghHI | 47.7ghHI | 57.7eF |
V18 | 118.2cdCD | 4.1bB | 14.3aA | 10.3aA | 1.3aA | 1.4aA | 1.4aA | 9.3abAB | 15.3aA | 15.3abAB | 47.7ghHI | 47.7ghHI | 59.7deDEF |
V19 | 117.7cdDE | 4.1bB | 11.3cdCD | 9.3cdCD | 1.2abAB | 1.3abAB | 1.3abAB | 8.3bdB | 13.3bcBC | 14.3bcBC | 62.2aA | 62.2aA | 60.7cdCDE |
V20 | 118.7bcdCD | 4.1bB | 12.3bcBC | 7.3bcBC | 1.1abcdeAB | 1.2abcABC | 1.2abcABC | 9.3abAB | 11.3deDE | 13.3cdCD | 42.7jK | 42.7jK | 50.7gG |
品种编号 Varieties number | M14 | M15 | M16 | M17 | M18 | M19 | M20 | M21 | M22 | M23 | M24 | M25 | |
V1 | 2.9abcAB | 3.1bcdeABC | 3.1defgBCDEF | 175.5cBC | 21.8efEFG | 2.7eC | 18.0gH | 14.6iF | 3.2abcA | 318.9nN | 11.5cdefBCD | 11.5cdefBCD | |
V2 | 2.8abcAB | 2.8cdeBC | 2.9fgEF | 186.8bB | 22.0efEFG | 2.8deABC | 19.2fgFGH | 15.5ghiDEF | 2.9abcA | 324.1mnMN | 11.1defgBCDE | 11.7cdeBC | |
V3 | 2.9abcAB | 3.0bcdeABC | 3.2defgBCDEF | 177.3bcBC | 24.1cdCDE | 3.0abcdeABC | 19.1fgFGH | 15.6ghiDEF | 3.3abA | 331.9lmLMN | 10.6efghijCDEF | 12.3bcAB | |
V4 | 2.6cdAB | 2.8deBC | 3.0efgCDEF | 152.3efEF | 25.2cBCD | 3.3abcdeABC | 23.6cdeBCDE | 19.8bcdeBCD | 2.8bcA | 382.8fFG | 11.8cdBC | 13.2abA | |
V5 | 2.7bcdAB | 2.9cdeBC | 2.9fgDEF | 169.3cdCD | 25.5cBCD | 3.3abcdeABC | 23.5cdeBCDEF | 19.5cdeBCDE | 3.0abcA | 372.6gGH | 9.56jF | 12.4bcAB | |
V6 | 2.7bcdAB | 2.8cdeBC | 3.0efgDEF | 137.4hG | 23.1deDE | 2.9cdeABC | 23.5cdeBCDEF | 19.5cdeBCDE | 3.3abA | 372.0gGH | 10.6efghiCDEF | 10.4fghijCDEF | |
V7 | 2.4dB | 2.7eC | 2.8gF | 200.3aA | 25.5cBCD | 3.2abcdeABC | 25.1bcdABCD | 20.7bcdeBC | 2.9abcA | 387.5efEF | 13.5aA | 10.1ghijDEF | |
V8 | 2.8abcAB | 3.1abcdeABC | 3.2bcdefBCDEF | 146.3fghEFG | 18.8hH | 3.5abcABC | 19.0fgGH | 15.2hiEF | 3.1abcA | 328.7lmnMN | 10.0hijEF | 10.6efghiCDEF | |
V9 | 2.9abcAB | 2.9bcdeABC | 3.2bcdefBCDEF | 159.3deDE | 28.0abAB | 3.7aA | 29.08aA | 25.0aA | 3.3abA | 432.0aA | 11.5cdefBCD | 10.7efghiCDEF | |
V10 | 3.1abcA | 3.1abcdABC | 4.1aA | 150.1efEFG | 29.1aA | 3.5abcABC | 23.2cdeBCDEFG | 19.2cdefBCDE | 3.4aA | 367.3ghH | 11.7cdeBC | 9.88ijEF | |
V11 | 2.9abcAB | 3.1abcdeABC | 3.4bcdeBCDE | 159.2deDE | 20.0fghFGH | 2.7deBC | 22.3deCDEFGH | 18.5defgBCDEF | 3.2abcA | 343.5jkJKL | 12.3bcAB | 11.1defghBCDE | |
V12 | 2.9abcAB | 3.0bcdeABC | 3.2bcdefBCDEF | 168.3cdCD | 21.4efgEFGH | 3.2abcdeABC | 23.2cdeBCDEFG | 19.0defBCDE | 2.9abcA | 361.2hiHI | 13.2abA | 11.1defgBCDE | |
V13 | 3.0abcA | 3.2abcABC | 3.7bAB | 91.5iH | 19.4ghGH | 3.2abcdeABC | 24.4bcdeBCD | 20.9bcdeABC | 3.2abcA | 396.9deDE | 12.4bcAB | 11.0defghBCDEF | |
V14 | 2.9abcAB | 2.9bcdeABC | 3.4bcdeBCDE | 144.9fghEFG | 25.4cBCD | 3.4abcdABC | 22.9cdeBCDEFG | 19.0cdefBCDE | 2.7cA | 352.4ijIJ | 10.4fghijCDEF | 10.6efghijCDEF | |
V15 | 2.9abcAB | 3.0bcdeABC | 3.2bcdefBCDEF | 151.3efEFG | 26.2bcBC | 3.6aAB | 26.8abAB | 22.3abcABC | 3.1abcA | 415.3bBC | 10.1ghijDEF | 11.8cdBC | |
V16 | 2.7bcdAB | 3.0bcdeABC | 3.2cdefBCDEF | 139.2ghFG | 26.2bcBC | 3.6aAB | 26.0abcABC | 21.8bcdABC | 2.8abcA | 411.7bcC | 10.6efghiCDEF | 9.56jF | |
V17 | 2.7bcdAB | 2.9bcdeBC | 3.5bcdBCD | 149.5efgEFG | 25.4cBCD | 3.6abABC | 25.3bcdABCD | 21.1bcdeABC | 2.9abcA | 404.2cdCD | 10.7efghiCDEF | 10.6efghiCDEF | |
V18 | 3.2abA | 3.5aA | 3.6bcABC | 151.3efEFG | 22.4deEF | 3.1abcdeABC | 19.2fgEFGH | 16.1fghiDEF | 3.2abcA | 346.8jkJK | 9.88ijEF | 13.5aA | |
V19 | 3.2aA | 3.3abAB | 3.5bcdBCD | 148.2fgEFG | 25.8cBCD | 2.9bcdeABC | 27.3abAB | 22.8abAB | 3.2abcA | 426.4aAB | 11.1defghBCDE | 10.0hijEF | |
V20 | 2.9abcAB | 3.3abAB | 3.4bcdeBCDE | 141.3fghFG | 20.2fghFGH | 3.1abcdeABC | 21.5efDEFGH | 18.0efghCDEF | 3.1abcA | 337.5klKLM | 11.0defghBCDEF | 11.5cdefBCD |
指标 Indexes | 熵值 Entropy | 效用值 Utility value | 权重系数 Weight coeffecient(%) |
---|---|---|---|
M1 | 0.999 4 | 0.000 6 | 1.22 |
M2 | 0.998 3 | 0.001 7 | 3.54 |
M3 | 0.996 9 | 0.003 1 | 6.48 |
M4 | 0.998 1 | 0.001 9 | 4.13 |
M5 | 0.998 4 | 0.001 6 | 3.39 |
M6 | 0.998 1 | 0.001 9 | 4.01 |
M7 | 0.997 0 | 0.003 0 | 6.32 |
M8 | 0.999 4 | 0.000 6 | 1.27 |
M9 | 0.997 9 | 0.002 1 | 4.51 |
M10 | 0.998 5 | 0.001 5 | 3.23 |
M11 | 0.997 6 | 0.002 4 | 5.10 |
M12 | 0.999 1 | 0.000 9 | 1.80 |
M13 | 0.999 2 | 0.000 8 | 1.72 |
M14 | 0.999 2 | 0.000 8 | 1.66 |
M15 | 0.999 2 | 0.000 8 | 1.74 |
M16 | 0.998 4 | 0.001 6 | 3.41 |
M17 | 0.996 4 | 0.003 6 | 7.65 |
M18 | 0.997 4 | 0.002 6 | 5.42 |
M19 | 0.998 3 | 0.001 7 | 3.60 |
M20 | 0.996 9 | 0.003 1 | 6.56 |
M21 | 0.996 2 | 0.003 8 | 7.97 |
M22 | 0.999 3 | 0.000 7 | 1.50 |
M23 | 0.998 5 | 0.001 5 | 3.10 |
M24 | 0.998 5 | 0.001 5 | 3.28 |
M25 | 0.996 5 | 0.003 5 | 7.39 |
表4 各指标熵值和权重的变化
Tab.4 Changes of entropy values and weights of each indicator
指标 Indexes | 熵值 Entropy | 效用值 Utility value | 权重系数 Weight coeffecient(%) |
---|---|---|---|
M1 | 0.999 4 | 0.000 6 | 1.22 |
M2 | 0.998 3 | 0.001 7 | 3.54 |
M3 | 0.996 9 | 0.003 1 | 6.48 |
M4 | 0.998 1 | 0.001 9 | 4.13 |
M5 | 0.998 4 | 0.001 6 | 3.39 |
M6 | 0.998 1 | 0.001 9 | 4.01 |
M7 | 0.997 0 | 0.003 0 | 6.32 |
M8 | 0.999 4 | 0.000 6 | 1.27 |
M9 | 0.997 9 | 0.002 1 | 4.51 |
M10 | 0.998 5 | 0.001 5 | 3.23 |
M11 | 0.997 6 | 0.002 4 | 5.10 |
M12 | 0.999 1 | 0.000 9 | 1.80 |
M13 | 0.999 2 | 0.000 8 | 1.72 |
M14 | 0.999 2 | 0.000 8 | 1.66 |
M15 | 0.999 2 | 0.000 8 | 1.74 |
M16 | 0.998 4 | 0.001 6 | 3.41 |
M17 | 0.996 4 | 0.003 6 | 7.65 |
M18 | 0.997 4 | 0.002 6 | 5.42 |
M19 | 0.998 3 | 0.001 7 | 3.60 |
M20 | 0.996 9 | 0.003 1 | 6.56 |
M21 | 0.996 2 | 0.003 8 | 7.97 |
M22 | 0.999 3 | 0.000 7 | 1.50 |
M23 | 0.998 5 | 0.001 5 | 3.10 |
M24 | 0.998 5 | 0.001 5 | 3.28 |
M25 | 0.996 5 | 0.003 5 | 7.39 |
品种编号 Varieties number | D+ | D- | Ci | Ci排序 Ci Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|
V1 | 0.310 | 0.246 | 0.442 | 18 |
V2 | 0.281 | 0.269 | 0.489 | 10 |
V3 | 0.265 | 0.270 | 0.505 | 8 |
V4 | 0.224 | 0.293 | 0.567 | 2 |
V5 | 0.243 | 0.282 | 0.537 | 4 |
V6 | 0.289 | 0.237 | 0.450 | 17 |
V7 | 0.245 | 0.339 | 0.581 | 1 |
V8 | 0.289 | 0.255 | 0.468 | 12 |
V9 | 0.265 | 0.296 | 0.528 | 5 |
V10 | 0.275 | 0.280 | 0.505 | 7 |
V11 | 0.330 | 0.226 | 0.406 | 20 |
V12 | 0.252 | 0.300 | 0.543 | 3 |
V13 | 0.317 | 0.275 | 0.465 | 14 |
V14 | 0.272 | 0.245 | 0.474 | 11 |
V15 | 0.301 | 0.249 | 0.453 | 16 |
V16 | 0.274 | 0.262 | 0.489 | 9 |
V17 | 0.261 | 0.268 | 0.507 | 6 |
V18 | 0.323 | 0.254 | 0.440 | 19 |
V19 | 0.300 | 0.261 | 0.465 | 13 |
V20 | 0.283 | 0.241 | 0.460 | 15 |
表5 DTOPSIS分析结果
Tab.5 DTOPSIS analysis results
品种编号 Varieties number | D+ | D- | Ci | Ci排序 Ci Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|
V1 | 0.310 | 0.246 | 0.442 | 18 |
V2 | 0.281 | 0.269 | 0.489 | 10 |
V3 | 0.265 | 0.270 | 0.505 | 8 |
V4 | 0.224 | 0.293 | 0.567 | 2 |
V5 | 0.243 | 0.282 | 0.537 | 4 |
V6 | 0.289 | 0.237 | 0.450 | 17 |
V7 | 0.245 | 0.339 | 0.581 | 1 |
V8 | 0.289 | 0.255 | 0.468 | 12 |
V9 | 0.265 | 0.296 | 0.528 | 5 |
V10 | 0.275 | 0.280 | 0.505 | 7 |
V11 | 0.330 | 0.226 | 0.406 | 20 |
V12 | 0.252 | 0.300 | 0.543 | 3 |
V13 | 0.317 | 0.275 | 0.465 | 14 |
V14 | 0.272 | 0.245 | 0.474 | 11 |
V15 | 0.301 | 0.249 | 0.453 | 16 |
V16 | 0.274 | 0.262 | 0.489 | 9 |
V17 | 0.261 | 0.268 | 0.507 | 6 |
V18 | 0.323 | 0.254 | 0.440 | 19 |
V19 | 0.300 | 0.261 | 0.465 | 13 |
V20 | 0.283 | 0.241 | 0.460 | 15 |
品种编号 Varieties number | ri | ri排序 ri Rank | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
V1 | 0.914 4 | 2 | 0.866 7 | 1 |
V2 | 0.915 5 | 4 | 0.886 9 | 2 |
V3 | 0.929 3 | 5 | 0.896 7 | 5 |
V4 | 0.949 0 | 17 | 0.983 2 | 20 |
V5 | 0.956 3 | 20 | 0.953 8 | 13 |
V6 | 0.946 4 | 16 | 0.950 1 | 12 |
V7 | 0.931 6 | 8 | 0.935 4 | 10 |
V8 | 0.934 6 | 9 | 0.895 7 | 3 |
V9 | 0.915 0 | 3 | 0.965 8 | 16 |
V10 | 0.942 0 | 13 | 0.948 4 | 11 |
V12 | 0.941 3 | 12 | 0.909 6 | 6 |
V12 | 0.939 5 | 11 | 0.930 3 | 9 |
V13 | 0.882 6 | 1 | 0.969 1 | 17 |
V14 | 0.950 6 | 19 | 0.910 7 | 7 |
V15 | 0.949 7 | 18 | 0.970 2 | 18 |
V16 | 0.931 5 | 7 | 0.959 5 | 14 |
V17 | 0.944 6 | 15 | 0.977 6 | 19 |
V18 | 0.938 7 | 10 | 0.896 5 | 4 |
V19 | 0.931 3 | 6 | 0.961 0 | 15 |
V20 | 0.943 5 | 14 | 0.915 7 | 8 |
表6 灰色关联分析法计算结果
Tab.6 Calculation results of gray correlation analysis
品种编号 Varieties number | ri | ri排序 ri Rank | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
V1 | 0.914 4 | 2 | 0.866 7 | 1 |
V2 | 0.915 5 | 4 | 0.886 9 | 2 |
V3 | 0.929 3 | 5 | 0.896 7 | 5 |
V4 | 0.949 0 | 17 | 0.983 2 | 20 |
V5 | 0.956 3 | 20 | 0.953 8 | 13 |
V6 | 0.946 4 | 16 | 0.950 1 | 12 |
V7 | 0.931 6 | 8 | 0.935 4 | 10 |
V8 | 0.934 6 | 9 | 0.895 7 | 3 |
V9 | 0.915 0 | 3 | 0.965 8 | 16 |
V10 | 0.942 0 | 13 | 0.948 4 | 11 |
V12 | 0.941 3 | 12 | 0.909 6 | 6 |
V12 | 0.939 5 | 11 | 0.930 3 | 9 |
V13 | 0.882 6 | 1 | 0.969 1 | 17 |
V14 | 0.950 6 | 19 | 0.910 7 | 7 |
V15 | 0.949 7 | 18 | 0.970 2 | 18 |
V16 | 0.931 5 | 7 | 0.959 5 | 14 |
V17 | 0.944 6 | 15 | 0.977 6 | 19 |
V18 | 0.938 7 | 10 | 0.896 5 | 4 |
V19 | 0.931 3 | 6 | 0.961 0 | 15 |
V20 | 0.943 5 | 14 | 0.915 7 | 8 |
项目 Items | 产量排序 Yield rank | Ci值排序 Ci rank | ri值排序 ri rank | |
---|---|---|---|---|
产量排序 Yield rank | 1 | |||
Ci值排序 Ci rank | 0.33 | 1 | ||
ri值排序 ri rank | 0.10 | 0.10 | 1 | |
0.89** | 0.37 | 0.29 | 1 |
表7 不同分析方法的相关性
Tab.7 Correlations analysis of different analysis methods
项目 Items | 产量排序 Yield rank | Ci值排序 Ci rank | ri值排序 ri rank | |
---|---|---|---|---|
产量排序 Yield rank | 1 | |||
Ci值排序 Ci rank | 0.33 | 1 | ||
ri值排序 ri rank | 0.10 | 0.10 | 1 | |
0.89** | 0.37 | 0.29 | 1 |
品种编号 Varieties number | 产量 Yield | DTOPSIS法 DTOPSIS methods | 灰色关联分析 Grey correlation analysis | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
排序 Rank | 显著性 Significance | 排序 Rank | Ci差异值 Difference value of Ci(%) | 排序 Rank | ri差异值 Difference value of ri(%) | 排序 Rank | Difference value of | |
V1 | 20 | 318.9nN | 18 | 23.81 | 19 | 4.38 | 20 | 11.85 |
V2 | 19 | 324.1mnMN | 10 | 15.71 | 17 | 4.27 | 19 | 9.79 |
V3 | 17 | 331.9lmLMN | 8 | 13.04 | 16 | 2.82 | 16 | 8.80 |
V4 | 8 | 382.8fFG | 2 | 2.34 | 4 | 0.76 | 1 | 0.00 |
V5 | 9 | 372.6gGH | 4 | 7.46 | 1 | 0.00 | 8 | 2.99 |
V6 | 10 | 372.0gGH | 17 | 22.46 | 5 | 1.04 | 9 | 3.36 |
V7 | 7 | 387.5efEF | 1 | 0.00 | 13 | 2.58 | 11 | 4.86 |
V8 | 18 | 328.7lmnMN | 12 | 19.33 | 12 | 2.26 | 18 | 8.90 |
V9 | 1 | 432.0aA | 5 | 8.98 | 18 | 4.31 | 5 | 1.77 |
V10 | 11 | 367.3ghH | 7 | 13.01 | 8 | 1.49 | 10 | 3.54 |
V11 | 15 | 343.5jkJKL | 20 | 30.01 | 9 | 1.56 | 15 | 7.49 |
V12 | 12 | 361.2hiHI | 3 | 6.43 | 10 | 1.75 | 12 | 5.39 |
V13 | 6 | 396.9deDE | 14 | 19.97 | 20 | 7.71 | 4 | 1.43 |
V14 | 13 | 352.4ijIJ | 11 | 18.33 | 2 | 0.59 | 14 | 7.38 |
V15 | 3 | 415.3bBC | 16 | 21.93 | 3 | 0.69 | 3 | 1.33 |
V16 | 4 | 411.7bcC | 9 | 15.71 | 14 | 2.59 | 7 | 2.41 |
V17 | 5 | 404.2cdCD | 6 | 12.68 | 6 | 1.22 | 2 | 0.57 |
V18 | 14 | 346.8jkJK | 19 | 24.17 | 11 | 1.84 | 17 | 8.82 |
V19 | 2 | 426.4aAB | 13 | 19.91 | 15 | 2.61 | 6 | 2.26 |
V20 | 16 | 337.5klKLM | 15 | 20.71 | 7 | 1.34 | 13 | 6.87 |
表8 不同分析方法结果比较
Tab.8 Comparisons of results from different analysis methods
品种编号 Varieties number | 产量 Yield | DTOPSIS法 DTOPSIS methods | 灰色关联分析 Grey correlation analysis | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
排序 Rank | 显著性 Significance | 排序 Rank | Ci差异值 Difference value of Ci(%) | 排序 Rank | ri差异值 Difference value of ri(%) | 排序 Rank | Difference value of | |
V1 | 20 | 318.9nN | 18 | 23.81 | 19 | 4.38 | 20 | 11.85 |
V2 | 19 | 324.1mnMN | 10 | 15.71 | 17 | 4.27 | 19 | 9.79 |
V3 | 17 | 331.9lmLMN | 8 | 13.04 | 16 | 2.82 | 16 | 8.80 |
V4 | 8 | 382.8fFG | 2 | 2.34 | 4 | 0.76 | 1 | 0.00 |
V5 | 9 | 372.6gGH | 4 | 7.46 | 1 | 0.00 | 8 | 2.99 |
V6 | 10 | 372.0gGH | 17 | 22.46 | 5 | 1.04 | 9 | 3.36 |
V7 | 7 | 387.5efEF | 1 | 0.00 | 13 | 2.58 | 11 | 4.86 |
V8 | 18 | 328.7lmnMN | 12 | 19.33 | 12 | 2.26 | 18 | 8.90 |
V9 | 1 | 432.0aA | 5 | 8.98 | 18 | 4.31 | 5 | 1.77 |
V10 | 11 | 367.3ghH | 7 | 13.01 | 8 | 1.49 | 10 | 3.54 |
V11 | 15 | 343.5jkJKL | 20 | 30.01 | 9 | 1.56 | 15 | 7.49 |
V12 | 12 | 361.2hiHI | 3 | 6.43 | 10 | 1.75 | 12 | 5.39 |
V13 | 6 | 396.9deDE | 14 | 19.97 | 20 | 7.71 | 4 | 1.43 |
V14 | 13 | 352.4ijIJ | 11 | 18.33 | 2 | 0.59 | 14 | 7.38 |
V15 | 3 | 415.3bBC | 16 | 21.93 | 3 | 0.69 | 3 | 1.33 |
V16 | 4 | 411.7bcC | 9 | 15.71 | 14 | 2.59 | 7 | 2.41 |
V17 | 5 | 404.2cdCD | 6 | 12.68 | 6 | 1.22 | 2 | 0.57 |
V18 | 14 | 346.8jkJK | 19 | 24.17 | 11 | 1.84 | 17 | 8.82 |
V19 | 2 | 426.4aAB | 13 | 19.91 | 15 | 2.61 | 6 | 2.26 |
V20 | 16 | 337.5klKLM | 15 | 20.71 | 7 | 1.34 | 13 | 6.87 |
[1] | 陈卫军, 魏益民, 张国权, 等. 国内外谷子的研究现状[J]. 杂粮作物, 2000, (3): 27-29. |
CHEN Weijun, WEI Yimin, ZHANG Guoquan, et al. Current research status of domestic and foreign foxtail millet[J]. Journal of Coarse Cereal Crops, 2000, (3): 27-29. | |
[2] | 刁现民. 中国谷子产业与产业技术体系[M]. 北京: 中国农业科学技术出版社, 2011. |
DIAO Xianmin. Chinese foxtail millet industry and industry technology system[M]. Beijing: China Agricultural Science and Technology Press, 2011. | |
[3] | 赵平, 李学涛, 康振友, 等. 基于熵权的DTOPSIS法和灰色关联度分析法在西瓜品种综合评价中的应用[J]. 黑龙江农业科学, 2021,(1): 79-87. |
ZHAO Ping, LI Xuetao, KANG Zhenyou, et al. Application of DTOPSIS method and grey relational analysis based on entropy weight in comprehensive evaluation of watermelon varieties[J]. Heilongjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2021,(1): 79-87. | |
[4] | 洪德峰, 马俊峰, 卫晓轶, 等. 基于熵值赋权的DTOPSIS法与灰色关联度法综合评价黄淮海区夏玉米新品种[J]. 耕作与栽培, 2022, 42(5): 82-86. |
HONG Defeng, MA Junfeng, WEI Xiaoyi, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of new summer maize varieties in Huanghuaihai Region based on entropy weighting DTOPSIS method and grey relational degree method[J]. Tillage and Cultivation, 2022, 42(5): 82-86. | |
[5] | 黄婷, 张思亲, 王治中, 等. 基于灰色关联度、DTOPSIS与模糊概率法的玉米姊妹系综合评价[J]. 分子植物育种, 2023, 21(15): 5199-5212. |
HUANG Ting, ZHANG Siqin, WANG Zhizhong, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of maize sister lines based on grey relational degree, DTOPSIS and fuzzy probability method[J]. Molecular Plant Breeding, 2023, 21(15): 5199-5212. | |
[6] |
张春艳, 吴荣华, 庄克章, 等. 基于熵值赋权的DTOPSIS法对不同玉米品种在鲁南地区的综合评价研究[J]. 中国农学通报, 2021, 37(23): 8-14.
DOI |
ZHANG Chunyan, WU Ronghua, ZHUANG Kezhang, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of maize varieties in southern Shandong Province by DTOPSIS method based on entropy weight[J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2021, 37(23): 8-14.
DOI |
|
[7] | 齐建双, 夏来坤, 黄保, 等. 基于熵权的DTOPSIS法和灰色局势决策法在玉米品种区域试验中的应用探讨[J]. 作物杂志, 2021,(1): 60-67. |
QI Jianshuang, XIA Laikun, HUANG Bao, et al. Discussion on the application in the regional experiment of maize varieties by entropy DTOPSIS mode and grey situation decision methods[J]. Crops, 2021,(1): 60-67. | |
[8] | 宋秀丽, 吴玥, 杨锡朗, 等. 基于熵值赋权的DTOPSIS法与灰色关联度分析在玉米品种综合评价中的比较[J]. 玉米科学, 2020, 28(2): 41-46. |
SONG Xiuli, WU Yue, YANG Xilang, et al. Comparison of entropy weighted DTOPSIS method and grey relational degree analysis in comprehensive evaluation of maize varieties[J]. Journal of Maize Sciences, 2020, 28(2): 41-46. | |
[9] |
孙刚, 陈佳静, 姚明明, 等. 宁夏春麦区小麦资源株高、籽粒性状及抗病性分析[J]. 植物遗传资源学报, 2023, 24(4): 954-971.
DOI |
SUN Gang, CHEN Jiajing, YAO Mingming, et al. Analysis of wheat resources for plant height, grain traits, and diseases resistance cultivated in Ningxia spring wheat region[J]. Journal of Plant Genetic Resources, 2023, 24(4): 954-971.
DOI |
|
[10] | 金轻, 赵红, 林丽萍, 等. 基于灰色关联度分析和DTOPSIS法综合评价小麦新品系在云南省的适应性[J]. 南方农业学报, 2020, 51(10): 2440-2446. |
JIN Qing, ZHAO Hong, LIN Liping, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of adaptability of new wheat lines in Yunnan based on grey relevance analysis and DTOPSIS method[J]. Journal of Southern Agriculture, 2020, 51(10): 2440-2446. | |
[11] | 王春平, 张伟, 张改生, 等. 三种分析方法对小麦新品种的综合评判[J]. 麦类作物学报, 2006, 26(5): 45-48. |
WANG Chunping, ZHANG Wei, ZHANG Gaisheng, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of new wheat varieties by using three different analysis methods[J]. Journal of Triticeae Crops, 2006, 26(5): 45-48. | |
[12] | 刘丽娟, 刘延刚, 金桂秀. 用基于熵值赋权的DTOPSIS法综合评价水稻品种[J]. 山东农业科学, 2022, 54(7): 39-45. |
LIU Lijuan, LIU Yangang, JIN Guixiu. Comprehensive evaluation of rice varieties by DTOPSIS method based on entropy weight[J]. Shandong Agricultural Sciences, 2022, 54(7): 39-45. | |
[13] | 胡其明, 邓伟, 党筱兰. 用DTOPSIS法综合评价杂交水稻新品种在黔西南州的适应性[J]. 种子, 2013, 32(12): 95-97. |
HU Qiming, DENG Wei, DANG Xiaolan. Comprehensive evaluation of adaptability of new hybrid rice varieties in QianXiNan autonomous prefecture by DTOPSIS[J]. Seed, 2013, 32(12): 95-97. | |
[14] | 昝凯, 周青, 张志民, 等. 灰色关联度和DTOPSIS法综合分析河南区域试验中大豆新品种(系)的农艺性状表现[J]. 大豆科学, 2018, 37(5): 664-671. |
ZAN Kai, ZHOU Qing, ZHANG Zhimin, et al. Gray correlation analysis and DTOPSIS method for comprehensive agronomic performance analysis of new soybean varieties(lines) in Henan regional test[J]. Soybean Science, 2018, 37(5): 664-671. | |
[15] |
刘瑞显, 张国伟, 杨长琴. 基于熵权理论的灰色关联度法在棉花耐盐性评价中的应用[J]. 核农学报, 2017, 31(2): 402-409.
DOI |
LIU Ruixian, ZHANG Guowei, YANG Changqin. Using gray related degree method based on entropy weight theory to evaluate salt tolerance of cotton[J]. Journal of Nuclear Agricultural Sciences, 2017, 31(2): 402-409.
DOI |
|
[16] | 陆平. 谷子种质资源描述规范和数据标准[M]. 北京: 中国农业出版社, 2006. |
LU Ping. Descriptors and data standard for foxtail millet[Setaria italica (L.) beauv.][M]. Beijing: China Agriculture Press, 2006. | |
[17] | GB 5009.5-2016.食品安全国家标准食品中蛋白质的测定[S]. |
GB 5009.5-2016.National Food Safety Standard Determination of Protein in Food[S]. | |
[18] | 食品安全国家标准食品中脂肪的测定: GB 5009.6—2016[S]. |
National Food Safety Standard Determination of Fat in Food: GB 5009.6—2016[S]. | |
[19] | 张晓申, 韩燕丽, 樊永强, 等. 基于灰色关联度和DTOPSIS法对谷子区域试验的综合评价[J]. 种子, 2022, 41(9): 121-126, 133. |
ZHANG Xiaoshen, HAN Yanli, FAN Yongqiang, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of millet of regional test by grey relational degree analysis and DTOPSIS method[J]. Seed, 2022, 41(9): 121-126, 133. | |
[20] | 吕建珍, 马建萍, 赵凯, 等. 23个谷子育成品种的综合评价[J]. 种子, 2020, 39(11): 126-132. |
LYU Jianzhen, MA Jianping, ZHAO Kai, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of 23 millet cultivars[J]. Seed, 2020, 39(11): 126-132. | |
[21] | 贾小平, 袁玺垒, 陆平, 等. 中国71个谷子种质资源的灰色关联度分析及综合评价[J]. 种子, 2017, 36(9): 63-66. |
JIA Xiaoping, YUAN Xilei, LU Ping, et al. Grey incidence analysis and comprehensive evaluation of 71 millet germplasm resources in China[J]. Seed, 2017, 36(9): 63-66. |
[1] | 刘晶, 杜明川, 张文婷, 鲍海娟, 景美玲, 杜文华. 青海不同地区小黑麦种质的筛选[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(9): 2183-2190. |
[2] | 刘慧杰, 王俊豪, 龚照龙, 梁亚军, 王俊铎, 李雪源, 郑巨云, 王冀川. 197份陆地棉品种萌发期耐盐性鉴定[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(7): 1574-1581. |
[3] | 阿不都卡地尔·库尔班, 潘竟海, 陈友强, 刘华君, 董心久, 白晓山, 李思忠, 高卫时, 沙红, 李小惠. 基于产量相关性状综合评价晚播甜菜品种的适应性[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(6): 1368-1377. |
[4] | 赵云, 冯国郡, 古丽扎提·巴孜尔别克, 胡相伟, 苏比努尔·卡德尔, 李鹏兵, 邵疆, 刘杰. 钾肥用量对滴灌谷子生长发育及产量的影响[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(6): 1378-1385. |
[5] | 杨君妍, 闫淼, 吴海波, 杨文莉, 王豪杰, 毛建才, 翟文强, 李俊华. 高温对不同厚皮甜瓜品种种子萌发的影响及其耐热性综合评价[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(6): 1386-1396. |
[6] | 朱韬, 雷庆元, 马亮. 不同水氮用量对复播玉米生长发育、产量及利用效率的影响和选优模型验证[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(4): 835-844. |
[7] | 杨明花, 廖必勇, 刘强, 冯国瑞, 达吾来·杰克山, 布阿依夏木·那曼提, 刘琪, 艾尔居玛·吐卢汗, 彭云承. 基于主成分分析的玉米杂交组合脱水性综合评价[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(2): 318-325. |
[8] | 欧源, 罗莎莎, 王如月, 孙雅丽, 虎海防. 盐胁迫对美国黑核桃幼苗生长和生理特性的影响[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(2): 393-401. |
[9] | 于欣宇, 于静, 冯耐红, 岳忠孝, 侯东辉, 杨成元. 冬播对谷子品种晋汾107营养及风味的影响[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(12): 2913-2920. |
[10] | 杨祥波, 陈亮宇, 杨松楠, 陈喜凤, 邢伟明, 李雪莹, 丛炜轩, 臧振原, 臧远波, 张君. 东北春大豆种质资源表型分析及综合性评价[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(12): 2921-2933. |
[11] | 徐斌, 王征, 宋占腾, 玛尔哈巴·帕尔哈提, 朱靖蓉, 车凤斌, 李永海, 武凤艳, 苗福红. 11份野生沙棘种质资源果实品质分析与综合评价[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(12): 3020-3031. |
[12] | 崔豫疆, 龚照龙, 王俊铎, 郑巨云, 桑志伟, 阳妮, 梁亚军, 李雪源, 曲延英. 245份陆地棉品种农艺性状及产量构成因素综合评价[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(10): 2358-2365. |
[13] | 邵疆, 赵云, 胡相伟, 刘杰, 纳斯如拉·克热木, 石书兵, 冯国郡. 不同时期干旱胁迫对谷子产量及干物质积累的影响[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(10): 2388-2395. |
[14] | 麦合穆提·拜合提, 丁峰, 李彦, 党龙芯. 基于熵权-TOPSIS的浅埋式滴灌紫花苜蓿灌水定额的综合评价[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(10): 2537-2546. |
[15] | 田聪华, 苗红萍, 张利召, 戴健. 基于国际比较的我国新疆农业高质量发展评价指标体系构建[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2024, 61(10): 2583-2592. |
阅读次数 | ||||||
全文 30
|
|
|||||
摘要 |
|
|||||