Comprehensive evaluation of drought tolerance for soybean germplasm at germination stage

doi:10.6048/j.issn.1001-4330.2025.07.011

Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences ›› 2025, Vol. 62 ›› Issue (7): 1658-1669.DOI: 10.6048/j.issn.1001-4330.2025.07.011

• Food and cash crops column • Previous Articles Next Articles

Comprehensive evaluation of drought tolerance for soybean germplasm at germination stage

WU Yucheng¹^,²(), TIAN Rui¹^,², SHI Xiaolei¹^,², Shanqimike ¹^,², DING Sunlei¹^,², ZHANG Hengbin³, ZHAO Jing³, ZHAN Yong³, YAN Yongliang¹^,²()

1. Institute of Crop Germplasm Resources, Xinjiang Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Urumqi 830091, China
2. National Central Asian Characteristic Crop Germplasm Resources Medium-term Gene Bank (Urumqi), Urumqi 830091, China
3. Institute of Crops Research, Xinjiang Academy of Agricultural and Reclamation Sciences, Shihezi Xinjiang 832000, China

Received:2024-12-22 Online:2025-07-20 Published:2025-09-05
Correspondence author: YAN Yongliang
Supported by:
"Young Doctor" Project of "Tianchi Talents" Introduction Program;Agricultural S & T Innovation Stability Support Special Project of Xinjiang Academy of Agricultural Sciences(xjnkywdzc-2023001-26);“Agriculture, Rural Areas and Farmers” Backbone Talent Training Project of "Tianshan Talents" Training Program;China Agriculture Research System(CARS-04-CES31);Xinjiang Agriculture Research System(XJARS-04);"High-Yield and Reverse Resistance Breeding and Ultra-High-Yield Cultivation Innovation Team" of Tianshan Innovation Team

大豆萌发期耐旱性鉴定与优异种质筛选

吴玉成¹^,²(), 田蕊¹^,², 时晓磊¹^,², 山其米克¹^,², 丁孙磊¹^,², 张恒斌³, 赵靓³, 战勇³, 严勇亮¹^,²()

1.新疆维吾尔自治区农业科学院作物研究所, 乌鲁木齐 830091
2.国家中亚特色作物种质资源中期库(乌鲁木齐), 乌鲁木齐 830091
3.新疆农垦科学院作物研究所, 新疆石河子 832000

通讯作者: 严勇亮
作者简介:吴玉成(1997-),男,硕士,研究方向为大豆抗逆育种,(E-mail)710526272@qq.com
基金资助:
“天池英才”引进计划“青年博士”项目;新疆农业科学院农业科技创新稳定支持专项(xjnkywdzc-2023001-26);“天山英才”培养计划“三农”骨干人才培养项目;国家现代农业产业技术体系(CARS-04-CES31);新疆大豆产业技术体系(XJARS-04);天山创新团队“大豆高产抗逆育种与超高产栽培创新团队”

Abstract

Abstract:

【Objective】 Soybean (Glycine max L.) originated from China, which was an important crop for grain, oil and forage. Drought stress inhibits soybean germination potential, germination rate, and germination index, leading to missing seedlings in the field. The elite soybean germplasms were screened in the hope of providing material basis for drought-tolerant breeding and molecular mechanism analysis. 【Methods】 218 soybean accessions, provided by National Central Asian Characteristic Crop Germplasm Resources Medium-term Gene Bank (Urumqi), were employed and five drought tolerance index, including relative germination potential, relative germination rate, relative germination index, promptness index, and damage rate were identified under 15% PEG stress. Furthermore, soybean drought tolerance was evaluated by membership function method and clustering analysis. 【Results】 The soybean germination rate, germination potential, and germination index declined to different degrees under 15% PEG stress. The ranges of the relative germination potential, relative germination rate, relative germination index, promptness index, and damage rate were 0.04-1.00, 0.41-1.00, 0.09-0.63, 0.03-1.92, and 0-58.63%, respectively. Correlation analysis showed that the relative germination potential, relative germination rate, relative germination index, and promptness index were positively correlated with each other and negatively correlated with damage rate. Furthermore, based on membership function values, 218 soybean accessions were classified into four groups: Group I, Group II, Group III and Group IV. From Group I, ten drought-tolerant germplasm were selected including No.10294, Dongnong 60, PI475810, No.3226 and FtC039. Moreover, a mathematical model (D=0.382-0.429DR+0.209RGP+0.106PI+0.238RGI) was established by stepwise regression analysis, which might be used to quickly evaluate and predict the drought tolerance of soybean germplasm during germination. 【Conclusion】 From 218 soybean accessions, ten drought-resistant varieties are screened, including No.10294, Dongnong60, PI475810, No.3226, FtC039, JiangJinQingPiDou, FtC005, Uzbekskaja-2, Union and FtC054.

Key words: soybean; germination stage; drought tolerance; germplasm screening; regression analysis

摘要：

【目的】筛选发芽阶段耐旱大豆优异种质,为耐旱新品种选育及机制解析提供材料基础。【方法】以中亚特色作物种质资源中期库(乌鲁木齐)提供的218份大豆种质为材料,利用15% PEG高渗溶液模拟干旱胁迫,鉴定其相对发芽势、相对发芽率、相对发芽指数、萌发耐旱指数和伤害率等5个指标,采用模糊隶属函数法和聚类分析等方法评价供试材料萌发期耐旱性。【结果】在15% PEG高渗溶液胁迫下,218份大豆种质发芽率、发芽势和发芽指数等指标呈现不同程度的降低;其相对发芽势、相对发芽率、相对发芽指数、萌发耐旱指数及伤害率变化范围分别为0.04~1.00、0.41~1.00、0.09~0.63、0.03~1.92和0~58.63%;相对发芽势、相对发芽率、相对发芽指数和萌发耐旱指数间均呈极显著正相关关系,而伤害率与上述性状呈极显著负相关;可将供试材料分为类群Ⅰ、类群Ⅱ、类群Ⅲ、类群Ⅳ共4类,在类群Ⅰ中筛选到No.10294、东农60、PI475810、No.3226和FtC039等发芽阶段耐旱种质10份;此外,逐步回归建立了大豆萌发期耐旱性评价数学模型(D=0.382-0.429DR+0.209RGP+0.106PI+0.238RGI),利用该模型可快速评价和预测大豆种质萌发期耐旱性。【结论】从供试的218份大豆种质中筛选出10份耐旱种质,分别为No.10294、东农60、PI475810、No.3226、FtC039、JiangJinQingPiDou、FtC005、Uzbekskaja-2、Union和FtC054。

关键词: 大豆, 萌发期, 耐旱性, 种质筛选, 回归分析

CLC Number:

S643.7

WU Yucheng, TIAN Rui, SHI Xiaolei, Shanqimike , DING Sunlei, ZHANG Hengbin, ZHAO Jing, ZHAN Yong, YAN Yongliang. Comprehensive evaluation of drought tolerance for soybean germplasm at germination stage[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 62(7): 1658-1669.

吴玉成, 田蕊, 时晓磊, 山其米克, 丁孙磊, 张恒斌, 赵靓, 战勇, 严勇亮. 大豆萌发期耐旱性鉴定与优异种质筛选[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2025, 62(7): 1658-1669.

Figures/Tables 9

References 47

[1]	Pei R L, Zhang J Y, Tian L, et al. Identification of novel QTL associated with soybean isoflavone content[J]. The Crop Journal, 2018, 6(3): 244-252.
[2]	Seo J H, Kim K S, Ko J M, et al. Quantitative trait locus analysis for soybean (Glycine max) seed protein and oil concentrations using selected breeding populations[J]. Plant Breeding, 2019, 138(1): 95-104.
[3]	Liu J Q, Jiang A H, Ma R H, et al. QTL mapping for seed quality traits under multiple environments in soybean (Glycine max L.)[J]. Agronomy, 2023, 13(9): 2382.
[4]	樊瑀, 董淑琦, 原向阳, 等. 谷子种质资源萌发期抗旱性综合评价及抗旱指标筛选[J]. 中国农业大学学报, 2022, 27(6): 42-54.
	FAN Yu, DONG Shuqi, YUAN Xiangyang, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of drought resistance of foxtail millet germplasm resources during germination period and drought resistance index screening[J]. Journal of China Agricultural University, 2022, 27(6): 42-54.
[5]	岳艳琳. 气候变化下长江流域未来径流与旱涝变化特征研究[D]. 上海: 华东师范大学, 2022.
	YUE Yanlin. The changes of future runoff and drought and flood in the Yangtze River Basin under climate change[D]. Shanghai: East China Normal University, 2022.
[6]	张海燕, 李贵全. 大豆抗旱性与生理生态指标关系的研究[J]. 中国农学通报, 2005, 21(8): 140-142.
	ZHANG Haiyan, LI Guiquan. Study on the relationships between soybean drought-resistance and physiological and ecological indicators[J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2005, 21(8): 140-142.
[7]	刘文夫. 干旱胁迫对大豆养分吸收及碳水化合物形成影响的研究[D]. 哈尔滨: 东北农业大学, 2014.
	LIU Wenfu. Effects of drought stress on soybean nutrients absorption and carbohydrate formation[D]. Harbin:Northeast Agricultural University, 2014.
[8]	张海平, 张俊峰, 陈妍, 等. 大豆种质资源萌发期耐旱性评价[J]. 植物遗传资源学报, 2021, 22(1): 130-138. DOI
	ZHANG Haiping, ZHANG Junfeng, CHEN Yan, et al. Identification and evaluation of soybean germplasm resources for drought tolerance during germination stage[J]. Journal of Plant Genetic Resources, 2021, 22(1): 130-138. DOI
[9]	赵宏伟, 李秋祝, 魏永霞. 不同生育时期干旱对大豆主要生理参数及产量的影响[J]. 大豆科学, 2006, 25(3): 329-332.
	ZHAO Hongwei, LI Qiuzhu, WEI Yongxia. Effect of drought at different growth stages on main physiological parameters and yield in soybean[J]. Soybean Science, 2006, 25(3): 329-332.
[10]	闫春娟, 王文斌, 涂晓杰, 等. 不同生育时期干旱胁迫对大豆根系特性及产量的影响[J]. 大豆科学, 2013, 32(1): 59-62, 67.
	YAN Chunjuan, WANG Wenbin, TU Xiaojie, et al. Effect of drought stress at different growth stage on yield and root characteristics of soybean[J]. Soybean Science, 2013, 32(1): 59-62, 67.
[11]	曹秀清, 蒋尚明. 干旱胁迫对大豆品质及产量的影响[J]. 现代农业科技, 2017(16): 3-4, 7.
	CAO Xiuqing, JIANG Shangming. Effect of drought stress on yield and quality of soybean[J]. Modern Agricultural Science and Technology, 2017(16): 3-4, 7.
[12]	原小燕, 符明联, 何柳, 等. 芥菜型油菜资源品质与萌发期模拟干旱抗性的评价及其相关性分析[J]. 干旱地区农业研究, 2023, 41(5): 1-11, 21.
	YUAN Xiaoyan, FU Minglian, HE Liu, et al. Correlation analysis of quality characteristics and evaluation of simulated drought resistance at germination stage of Brassica juncea[J]. Agricultural Research in the Arid Areas, 2023, 41(5): 1-11, 21.
[13]	高利英, 邓永胜, 王晓歌, 等. 不同棉花品种种子萌发期耐旱性综合评价[J]. 山东农业科学, 2023, 55(4): 34-41.
	GAO Liying, DENG Yongsheng, WANG Xiaoge, et al. Evaluation on drought resistance of different cotton varieties at germination stage[J]. Shandong Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 55(4): 34-41.
[14]	张娟伟, 石亚飞, 路旭平, 等. 种子萌发期粳稻种质资源耐旱性综合评价[J]. 核农学报, 2022, 36(11): 2093-2103. DOI
	ZHANG Juanwei, SHI Yafei, LU Xuping, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of drought tolerance of Japonica rice germplasm resources at seed germination stage[J]. Journal of Nuclear Agricultural Sciences, 2022, 36(11): 2093-2103. DOI
[15]	李云, 杨梦涵, 王健, 等. PEG胁迫下谷子品种(系)萌发期耐旱性鉴定及评价[J]. 种子, 2022, 41(4): 29-35, 43.
	LI Yun, YANG Menghan, WANG Jian, et al. Identification and evaluation of drought tolerance of millet varieties (lines) at germination stage under PEG stress[J]. Seed, 2022, 41(4): 29-35, 43.
[16]	王永刚, 张胜军, 刘亚丽, 等. 新疆冬小麦品种资源萌发期耐旱性鉴定与筛选[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2021, 58(11): 2024-2034. DOI
	WANG Yonggang, ZHANG Shengjun, LIU Yali, et al. Identification and screening of drought tolerance in winter wheat cultivars in Xinjiang during germination period[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 58(11): 2024-2034. DOI
[17]	王婷婷, 贾晓艳, 赵永锋. 不同玉米种子萌发期耐旱性分析[J]. 种子, 2020, 39(4): 55-59.
	WANG Tingting, JIA Xiaoyan, ZHAO Yongfeng. Analysis on drought tolerance of different maize seeds at germination stage[J]. Seed, 2020, 39(4): 55-59.
[18]	杜艳丽, 张兆宁, 李思琪, 等. 黑龙江地区主栽大豆品种萌发期耐旱性综合鉴定及评价[J]. 黑龙江八一农垦大学学报, 2022, 34(4): 1-8, 22.
	DU Yanli, ZHANG Zhaoning, LI Siqi, et al. Tolerance comprehensive identification and evaluation of different soybean cultivars under drought stress at germination stage in Heilongjiang Province[J]. Journal of Heilongjiang Bayi Agricultural University, 2022, 34(4): 1-8, 22.
[19]	陈亚光, 昝凯, 杨雨阳, 等. 不同大豆品种(系)萌发期抗旱性综合评价[J]. 天津农业科学, 2023, 29(10): 13-17, 24.
	CHEN Yaguang, ZAN Kai, YANG Yuyang, et al. Evaluation on drought resistance of different soybean varietes(lines) at germination stage[J]. Tianjin Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 29(10): 13-17, 24.
[20]	赵振宁, 赵宝勰. 不同大豆品种在萌发期对干旱胁迫的生理响应及抗旱性评价[J]. 干旱地区农业研究, 2018, 36(2): 131-136.
	ZHAO Zhenning, ZHAO Baoxie. Physiological response and drought resistance evaluation of different soybean varieties to drought stress at germination stage[J]. Agricultural Research in the Arid Areas, 2018, 36(2): 131-136.
[21]	李健平, 谢路, 韩德志, 等. 早熟大豆种质资源萌发期耐旱性评价[J]. 黑龙江农业科学, 2022(5): 1-6.
	LI Jianping, XIE Lu, HAN Dezhi, et al. Evaluation of drought tolerance during germination of early-maturing soybean germplasm resources[J]. Heilongjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2022(5): 1-6.
[22]	李江, 龙爱华. 近60年新疆水资源变化及可持续发展利用思考[J]. 水利规划与设计, 2021, (7): 1-5, 72.
	LI Jiang, LONG Aihua. Changes in water resources and the idea of sustainable development utilization in Xinjiang over the past 60 years[J]. Water Resources Planning and Design, 2021, (7): 1-5, 72.
[23]	黄程琪. 新疆农业水资源利用效率及影响因素分析[D]. 石河子: 石河子大学, 2019.
	HUANG Chengqi. Analysis on utilization efficiency and influencing factors of agricultural water resources in Xinjiang[D]. Shihezi: Shihezi University, 2019.
[24]	李云霞, 范军亮, 关新元, 等. 新疆灌区农业节水发展现状与对策建议[J]. 华中农业大学学报, 2024, 43(2): 93-98.
	LI Yunxia, FAN Junliang, GUAN Xinyuan, et al. Status and countermeasures of agricultural water saving development in irrigation areas of Xinjiang[J]. Journal of Huazhong Agricultural University, 2024, 43(2): 93-98.
[25]	轩俊伟, 郑江华, 刘志辉. 基于SPEI的新疆干旱时空变化特征[J]. 干旱区研究, 2016, 33(2): 338-344.
	XUAN Junwei, ZHENG Jianghua, LIU Zhihui. SPEI-based spatiotemporal variation of drought in Xinjiang[J]. Arid Zone Research, 2016, 33(2): 338-344.
[26]	任海红, 刘学义, 李文强, 等. 大豆不同时期抗旱鉴定研究进展[J]. 农业科技通讯, 2016, (8): 111-114.
	REN Haihong, LIU Xueyi, LI Wenqiang, et al. Research progress on drought resistance identification of soybean at different stages[J]. Bulletin of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2016, (8): 111-114.
[27]	孙鹏宇, 裴双康, 周永刚, 等. 大豆萌发期和全生育期抗旱性评价及优异种质筛选[J]. 分子植物育种, 2024, 22(2): 490-502.
	SUN Pengyu, PEI Shuangkang, ZHOU Yonggang, et al. Evaluation and screening of soybean drought resistance during germination and whole growth period[J]. Molecular Plant Breeding, 2024, 22(2): 490-502.
[28]	刘建生, 邵晓梅, 韩冬, 等. 干旱对苗期大豆影响的研究概况[J]. 现代化农业, 2019, (6): 10-11.
	LIU Jiansheng, SHAO Xiaomei, HAN Dong, et al. General situation of research on the effect of drought on soybean at seedling stage[J]. Modernizing Agriculture, 2019, (6): 10-11.
[29]	刘粤阳, 闫海燕, 张琦, 等. 13个玉米品种萌发期耐旱性鉴定与筛选[J]. 现代农业科技, 2024, (7): 21-23, 27.
	LIU Yueyang, YAN Haiyan, ZHANG Qi, et al. Identification and screening of 13 maize varieties with drought resistance during germination period[J]. Modern Agricultural Science and Technology, 2024, (7): 21-23, 27.
[30]	曹勇, 姬虎太, 裴雪霞, 等. PEG模拟干旱胁迫下6份冬小麦种子抗旱性评价[J]. 山西农业科学, 2016, 44(6): 723-725.
	CAO Yong, JI Hutai, PEI Xuexia, et al. Evaluation of drought resistance of six winter wheat seeds under PEG simulated drought stress[J]. Journal of Shanxi Agricultural Sciences, 2016, 44(6): 723-725.
[31]	彭玉琳, 崔晓漫, 张沥曼玲, 等. 不同生育期大麦抗旱性鉴定及抗旱指标筛选[J/OL]. 西北农林科技大学学报(自然科学版), 2024, (8), (2024-01-30).
	PENG Yuling, CUI Xiaoman, ZHANG Limanling, et al. Identification of drought resistance and selection of drought resistance indicators in barley at different growth periods[J/OL]. Journal of Northwest A&F University(Natural Science Ed.), 2024, (8), (2024-01-30)
[32]	赵少迪, 胡传伟, 张玉莲, 等. 苦荞种质资源萌发期抗旱性综合评价[J/OL]. 干旱地区农业研究, (2024-05-10)[2024-05-20].
	ZHAO Shaodi, HU Chuanwei, ZHANG Yuliang, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of drought resistance of Tartary buckwheat(Fagopyrum tataricum)germplasm resources at germination stage[J/OL]. Agricultural Research in the Arid Areas (2024-05-10) [2024-05-20].
[33]	杨秀丽, 宁东贤, 赵玉坤, 等. PEG渗透胁迫条件下26份花生品种萌发期抗旱性评价[J]. 上海农业学报, 2021, 37(6): 35-42.
	YANG Xiuli, NING Dongxian, ZHAO Yukun, et al. Evaluation of 26 peanuts drought resistance under PEG osmotic treatment at germination stage[J]. Acta Agriculturae Shanghai, 2021, 37(6): 35-42.
[34]	胡玉璐, 冯慧, 任江陵, 等. PEG模拟干旱胁迫对不同糜子品种萌发的影响[J]. 北方农业学报, 2023, 51(6): 18-27. DOI
	HU Yulu, FENG Hui, REN Jiangling, et al. Effects of PEG simulated drought stress on the germination of different Panicum miliaceum L. varieties[J]. Journal of Northern Agriculture, 2023, 51(6): 18-27. DOI
[35]	王敏, 杨万明, 侯燕平, 等. 不同类型大豆花荚期抗旱性形态指标及其综合评价[J]. 核农学报, 2010, 24(1): 154-159. DOI
	WANG Min, YANG Wanming, HOU Yanping, et al. Morphological indexes of drought resistance of soybean accessions and its comprehensive evaluation on flowering and podding stage[J]. Journal of Nuclear Agricultural Sciences, 2010, 24(1): 154-159. DOI
[36]	郑巨云, 曾辉, 王俊铎, 等. 陆地棉品种资源萌发期耐盐性的隶属函数法评价[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2018, 55(9): 1579-1592. DOI
	ZHENG Juyun, ZENG Hui, WANG Junduo, et al. Comprehensive assessment of salt tolerance of the upland cotton varities resources in seedling stage by membership function method[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2018, 55(9): 1579-1592. DOI
[37]	金杭霞, 郭丹丹, 杨清华, 等. 利用模糊隶属函数法综合评价大豆萌发期耐盐性[J]. 分子植物育种, 2021, 19(24): 8265-8271.
	JIN Hangxia, GUO Dandan, YANG Qinghua, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of salt tolerance in soybean germination period by fuzzy subordinate function method[J]. Molecular Plant Breeding, 2021, 19(24): 8265-8271.
[38]	朱丽丽, 张发玉, 安宁, 等. 116份藜麦种质资源萌发期抗旱性综合评价[J]. 干旱地区农业研究, 2024, 42(1): 23-31.
	ZHU Lili, ZHANG Fayu, AN Ning, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of drought resistance of 116 quinoa germplasm resources during germination[J]. Agricultural Research in the Arid Areas, 2024, 42(1): 23-31.
[39]	赵兴震. 大豆耐旱性评价及耐旱相关基因挖掘[D]. 北京: 中国农业科学院, 2020.
	ZHAO Xingzhen. Drought tolerance identification and gene discovery in soybean[D]. Beijing: Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, 2020.
[40]	邓思雪. 干旱胁迫下不同大豆品种萌发特性及其耐旱性评价[D]. 沈阳: 沈阳农业大学, 2018.
	DENG Sixue. Germination characteristic under drought stress and evaluation of drought tolerance of soybean varieties[D]. Shenyang: Shenyang Agricultural University, 2018.
[41]	任茂, 张文英. 棉花品种耐热性分析及鉴定指标筛选[J]. 核农学报, 2018, 32(4): 788-794. DOI
	REN Mao, ZHANG Wenying. Evaluation of heat tolerance and screening the index for the assessment of heat tolerance in upland cotton[J]. Journal of Nuclear Agricultural Sciences, 2018, 32(4): 788-794. DOI
[42]	胡雯媚, 王思宇, 樊高琼, 等. 西南麦区小麦品种苗期抗旱性鉴定及其指标筛选[J]. 麦类作物学报, 2016, 36(2): 182-189.
	HU Wenmei, WANG Siyu, FAN Gaoqiong, et al. Analysis on the drought resistance and screening of drought resistance appraisal indexes of wheat cultivars in seedling stage in southwest area[J]. Journal of Triticeae Crops, 2016, 36(2): 182-189.
[43]	牛丽, 刘源, 于康珂, 等. 玉米杂交种苗期耐热性评价[J]. 玉米科学, 2015, 23(1): 107-114.
	NIU Li, LIU Yuan, YU Kangke, et al. Evaluation of heat-tolerance of maize hybrids at seedling stage[J]. Journal of Maize Sciences, 2015, 23(1): 107-114.
[44]	姚佳睿, 吕金钊, 陈康, 等. 不同油麦菜品种萌发期耐热指标筛选及耐热性评价[J]. 西北农业学报, 2024, 33(3): 511-520.
	YAO Jiarui L? Jinzhao, CHEN Kang, et al. Screening and evaluation of heat resistance indexes in different lettuce varieties at germination stage[J]. Acta Agriculturae Boreali-occidentalis Sinica, 2024, 33(3): 511-520.
[45]	任毅, 王仙, 张金汕, 等. 中亚大麦品种萌发期抗旱性筛选与鉴定[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2019, 56(5): 882-889. DOI
	REN Yi, WANG Xian, ZHANG Jinshan, et al. Screening and identification of drought resistance of central Asian barley varieties at germination stage[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2019, 56(5): 882-889. DOI
[46]	白金顺, 王雪翠, 王艳秋. 箭筈豌豆种质资源萌发期抗旱指标筛选及抗旱性评价[J]. 植物营养与肥料学报, 2020, 26(12): 2253-2263.
	BAI Jinshun, WANG Xuecui, WANG Yanqiu. Screening of drought-resistance index and drought-resistance evaluation of common vetch(Vicia sativa L.) germplasms at germination stage[J]. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers, 2020, 26(12): 2253-2263.
[47]	摆福红, 王凯彬, 马小红, 等. 不同萝卜品种种子萌发期抗旱性综合评价及抗旱指标筛选[J/OL]. 西北农林科技大学学报(自然科学版), 2024, (8). (2024-01-31)[2024-05-20].
	BAI Fuhong, WANG Kaibin, MA Xiaohong, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of drought resistance of different radish varieties at seed germination stage and screening of drought resistance indexes[J/OL]. Journal of Northwest A&F University(Natural Science Ed.), 2024, (8). (2024-01-31)[2024-05-20].

编号 ID	名称 Name	编号 ID	名称 Name	编号 ID	名称 Name	编号 ID	名称 Name	编号 ID	名称 Name
HG-001	绥农32	HG-045	黑农54	HG-089	H4	HG-133	黑河36	HG-177	PI475811A
HG-002	16487-2	HG-046	克09-95	HG-090	东农52	HG-134	吉大豆2号	HG-178	PI475811B
HG-003	黑农68	HG-047	垦丰16	HG-091	北豆31	HG-135	齐农25号	HG-179	Da Ba Dou
HG-004	黑河35	HG-048	H9	HG-092	嫩丰17	HG-136	黑河50	HG-180	Union
HG-005	齐农1号	HG-049	绥农37	HG-093	绥农10	HG-137	合农92	HG-181	K092
HG-006	圣豆44	HG-050	绥农28	HG-094	垦丰13	HG-138	吉育86	HG-182	K099
HG-007	绥农52	HG-051	嫩丰20	HG-095	中龙608	HG-139	北豆26	HG-183	K138
HG-008	合丰41	HG-052	合农91	HG-096	东生101	HG-140	东生18	HG-184	JiangJinQingPiDou
HG-009	16YJ051-2	HG-053	黑农53	HG-097	齐农32号	HG-141	16432-28	HG-185	Mi LanDouZi
HG-010	黑河48	HG-054	绥农28	HG-098	合农97	HG-142	黑农51	HG-186	BaiHuaTieJia
HG-011	花农39	HG-055	垦农32	HG-099	吉育506	HG-143	黑农50	HG-187	BaiHua
HG-012	H5	HG-056	垦豆39	HG-100	东农42C	HG-144	合农73	HG-188	Uzbekskaja-2
HG-013	合农76	HG-057	垦农33	HG-101	冀nf58	HG-145	丰收24	HG-189	PI475810
HG-014	齐农5号	HG-058	昊疆1号	HG-102	东生104	HG-146	合丰50	HG-190	No.3233
HG-015	合丰45	HG-059	合丰25	HG-103	贺丰7号	HG-147	黑河24	HG-191	455
HG-016	垦农26	HG-060	15321-2	HG-104	合丰51	HG-148	H17	HG-192	FtC019
HG-017	绥农35	HG-061	东农56	HG-105	绥农33	HG-149	垦鉴35	HG-193	FtC012
HG-018	东生22	HG-062	黑农48	HG-106	绥农26号	HG-150	克14-758	HG-194	FtC013
HG-019	平安豆8号	HG-063	北豆5号	HG-107	黑农52	HG-151	绥农82	HG-195	FtC033
HG-020	辽豆32	HG-064	垦农18	HG-108	黑农26	HG-152	合农67	HG-196	FtC020
HG-021	16487-12	HG-065	合农63	HG-109	黑农63	HG-153	绥农1号	HG-197	FtC026
HG-022	垦豆40	HG-066	中龙606	HG-110	吉育203	HG-154	哈13-2089	HG-198	FtC030
HG-023	长农20	HG-067	16465-10	HG-111	合丰56	HG-155	东生12	HG-199	FtC031
HG-024	合农61	HG-068	绥农53	HG-112	黑农48	HG-156	南夏-7	HG-200	FtC032
HG-025	H3	HG-069	东农55	HG-113	黑农66	HG-157	东生105	HG-201	FtC005
HG-026	东农63	HG-070	合丰52	HG-114	郑1440	HG-158	东生108	HG-202	FtC034
HG-027	16409-1	HG-071	黑农69	HG-115	佳密豆6号	HG-159	东农60	HG-203	FtC036
HG-028	绥农41	HG-072	1428	HG-116	绥农27	HG-160	佳试D	HG-204	FtC039
HG-029	16483-24	HG-073	合丰35	HG-117	16467-17	HG-161	JIM	HG-205	FtC054
HG-030	CIZ1217	HG-074	吉育93	HG-118	吉育64	HG-162	合农62	HG-206	FtC055
HG-031	吉育89	HG-075	陇中黄601	HG-119	小白豆	HG-163	吉小粒豆6号	HG-207	FtC059
HG-032	黑农46	HG-076	佳密豆6	HG-120	北丰9号	HG-164	佳试A	HG-208	FtC069
HG-033	东生23	HG-077	Flint	HG-121	登科1号	HG-165	黑农64	HG-209	FtC074
HG-034	哈12-4547	HG-078	16482-6	HG-122	绥农76	HG-166	北豆43	HG-210	FtC078
HG-035	黑农44	HG-079	绥农71	HG-123	垦丰22	HG-167	15321-13	HG-211	FtC079
HG-036	16488-2	HG-080	吉密3	HG-124	吉育303	HG-168	华疆4	HG-212	FtC081
HG-037	蒙豆36	HG-081	绥农75	HG-125	北疆1号	HG-169	1474	HG-213	FtC082
HG-038	垦豆25	HG-082	A2396	HG-126	北豆10	HG-170	吉育67	HG-214	FtC085
HG-039	黑河53	HG-083	吉育260	HG-127	北豆40	HG-171	昊疆13	HG-215	FtC089
HG-040	合农68	HG-084	吉育554	HG-128	黑河30	HG-172	花农38	HG-216	YanChengQiSiNiDou
HG-041	AsgrowA1939	HG-085	东生17	HG-129	合丰52	HG-173	东生102	HG-217	No.3226
HG-042	绥农14	HG-086	Hobbie87	HG-130	吉育508	HG-174	新大豆8号	HG-218	No.10294
HG-043	华疆17	HG-087	吉育259	HG-131	黑河27	HG-175	新大豆23号
HG-044	齐农12号	HG-088	吉育299	HG-132	黑河13	HG-176	PI475812B

编号 ID	名称 Name	编号 ID	名称 Name	编号 ID	名称 Name	编号 ID	名称 Name	编号 ID	名称 Name
HG-001	绥农32	HG-045	黑农54	HG-089	H4	HG-133	黑河36	HG-177	PI475811A
HG-002	16487-2	HG-046	克09-95	HG-090	东农52	HG-134	吉大豆2号	HG-178	PI475811B
HG-003	黑农68	HG-047	垦丰16	HG-091	北豆31	HG-135	齐农25号	HG-179	Da Ba Dou
HG-004	黑河35	HG-048	H9	HG-092	嫩丰17	HG-136	黑河50	HG-180	Union
HG-005	齐农1号	HG-049	绥农37	HG-093	绥农10	HG-137	合农92	HG-181	K092
HG-006	圣豆44	HG-050	绥农28	HG-094	垦丰13	HG-138	吉育86	HG-182	K099
HG-007	绥农52	HG-051	嫩丰20	HG-095	中龙608	HG-139	北豆26	HG-183	K138
HG-008	合丰41	HG-052	合农91	HG-096	东生101	HG-140	东生18	HG-184	JiangJinQingPiDou
HG-009	16YJ051-2	HG-053	黑农53	HG-097	齐农32号	HG-141	16432-28	HG-185	Mi LanDouZi
HG-010	黑河48	HG-054	绥农28	HG-098	合农97	HG-142	黑农51	HG-186	BaiHuaTieJia
HG-011	花农39	HG-055	垦农32	HG-099	吉育506	HG-143	黑农50	HG-187	BaiHua
HG-012	H5	HG-056	垦豆39	HG-100	东农42C	HG-144	合农73	HG-188	Uzbekskaja-2
HG-013	合农76	HG-057	垦农33	HG-101	冀nf58	HG-145	丰收24	HG-189	PI475810
HG-014	齐农5号	HG-058	昊疆1号	HG-102	东生104	HG-146	合丰50	HG-190	No.3233
HG-015	合丰45	HG-059	合丰25	HG-103	贺丰7号	HG-147	黑河24	HG-191	455
HG-016	垦农26	HG-060	15321-2	HG-104	合丰51	HG-148	H17	HG-192	FtC019
HG-017	绥农35	HG-061	东农56	HG-105	绥农33	HG-149	垦鉴35	HG-193	FtC012
HG-018	东生22	HG-062	黑农48	HG-106	绥农26号	HG-150	克14-758	HG-194	FtC013
HG-019	平安豆8号	HG-063	北豆5号	HG-107	黑农52	HG-151	绥农82	HG-195	FtC033
HG-020	辽豆32	HG-064	垦农18	HG-108	黑农26	HG-152	合农67	HG-196	FtC020
HG-021	16487-12	HG-065	合农63	HG-109	黑农63	HG-153	绥农1号	HG-197	FtC026
HG-022	垦豆40	HG-066	中龙606	HG-110	吉育203	HG-154	哈13-2089	HG-198	FtC030
HG-023	长农20	HG-067	16465-10	HG-111	合丰56	HG-155	东生12	HG-199	FtC031
HG-024	合农61	HG-068	绥农53	HG-112	黑农48	HG-156	南夏-7	HG-200	FtC032
HG-025	H3	HG-069	东农55	HG-113	黑农66	HG-157	东生105	HG-201	FtC005
HG-026	东农63	HG-070	合丰52	HG-114	郑1440	HG-158	东生108	HG-202	FtC034
HG-027	16409-1	HG-071	黑农69	HG-115	佳密豆6号	HG-159	东农60	HG-203	FtC036
HG-028	绥农41	HG-072	1428	HG-116	绥农27	HG-160	佳试D	HG-204	FtC039
HG-029	16483-24	HG-073	合丰35	HG-117	16467-17	HG-161	JIM	HG-205	FtC054
HG-030	CIZ1217	HG-074	吉育93	HG-118	吉育64	HG-162	合农62	HG-206	FtC055
HG-031	吉育89	HG-075	陇中黄601	HG-119	小白豆	HG-163	吉小粒豆6号	HG-207	FtC059
HG-032	黑农46	HG-076	佳密豆6	HG-120	北丰9号	HG-164	佳试A	HG-208	FtC069
HG-033	东生23	HG-077	Flint	HG-121	登科1号	HG-165	黑农64	HG-209	FtC074
HG-034	哈12-4547	HG-078	16482-6	HG-122	绥农76	HG-166	北豆43	HG-210	FtC078
HG-035	黑农44	HG-079	绥农71	HG-123	垦丰22	HG-167	15321-13	HG-211	FtC079
HG-036	16488-2	HG-080	吉密3	HG-124	吉育303	HG-168	华疆4	HG-212	FtC081
HG-037	蒙豆36	HG-081	绥农75	HG-125	北疆1号	HG-169	1474	HG-213	FtC082
HG-038	垦豆25	HG-082	A2396	HG-126	北豆10	HG-170	吉育67	HG-214	FtC085
HG-039	黑河53	HG-083	吉育260	HG-127	北豆40	HG-171	昊疆13	HG-215	FtC089
HG-040	合农68	HG-084	吉育554	HG-128	黑河30	HG-172	花农38	HG-216	YanChengQiSiNiDou
HG-041	AsgrowA1939	HG-085	东生17	HG-129	合丰52	HG-173	东生102	HG-217	No.3226
HG-042	绥农14	HG-086	Hobbie87	HG-130	吉育508	HG-174	新大豆8号	HG-218	No.10294
HG-043	华疆17	HG-087	吉育259	HG-131	黑河27	HG-175	新大豆23号
HG-044	齐农12号	HG-088	吉育299	HG-132	黑河13	HG-176	PI475812B

性状 Traits	处理 Treatments	最大值 Max.	最小值 Min.	均值 Mean	标准差 SD	变异系数 CV(%)
发芽势GP	CK	100.00%	6.00%	71.76%	0.19	26.49
	15% PEG	93.00%	2.00%	43.96%	0.21	48.21
发芽率GR	CK	100.00%	11.00%	78.97%	0.15	19.25
	15% PEG	98.00%	3.00%	63.61%	0.21	33.56
发芽指数GI	CK	127.93	5.59	78.68	26.30	33.43
	15% PEG	72.50	0.88	25.69	11.95	46.50

性状 Traits	处理 Treatments	最大值 Max.	最小值 Min.	均值 Mean	标准差 SD	变异系数 CV(%)
发芽势GP	CK	100.00%	6.00%	71.76%	0.19	26.49
	15% PEG	93.00%	2.00%	43.96%	0.21	48.21
发芽率GR	CK	100.00%	11.00%	78.97%	0.15	19.25
	15% PEG	98.00%	3.00%	63.61%	0.21	33.56
发芽指数GI	CK	127.93	5.59	78.68	26.30	33.43
	15% PEG	72.50	0.88	25.69	11.95	46.50

性状 Traits	变异来源 Source	平方和 SS	自由度df	均方 MS	F值 F value	P值 P value
相对发芽势RGP	品种	14.76	217	0.07	18.56	<0.000 1
	重复	0.00	1	0.00	0.01	0.92
相对发芽率RGR	品种	19.23	217	0.09	11.96	<0.000 1
	重复	0.01	1	0.01	0.10	0.75
相对发芽指数RGI	品种	5.52	217	0.03	15.78	<0.000 1
	重复	0.00	1	0.00	0.00	0.98
萌发耐旱指数PI	品种	136 026.45	217	626.85	29.00	<0.000 1
	重复	81.50	1	81.50	0.25	0.62
伤害率DR	品种	14.76	217	0.07	18.58	<0.000 1
	重复	0.00	1	0.00	0.01	0.92

Comprehensive evaluation of drought tolerance for soybean germplasm at germination stage

大豆萌发期耐旱性鉴定与优异种质筛选

RichHTML

PDF

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 9

References 47

Related Articles 15

Recommended Articles

Metrics

性状 Traits	最小值 Min.	最大值 Max.	均值 Mean	变异系数 CV(%)	偏度 Skew.	峰度 Kurt.	显著性 Sig.
相对发芽势RGP	0.04	1.00	0.60	35.11	0.19	-0.58	1.81E-56
相对发芽率RGR	0.41	1.00	0.81	17.44	0.38	-0.98	1.02E-81
相对发芽指数RGI	0.09	0.63	0.33	27.88	0.57	0.27	1.96E-61
萌发耐旱指数PI	0.03	1.92	0.80	44.43	-0.16	0.24	4.44E-130
伤害率DR	0.00%	58.63%	18.55%	76.57	0.38	0.98	1.25E-70

分类 Classification	数量 Number	频率 Frequency (%)	性状 Trait	最小值 Min.	最大值 Max.	均值 Mean	变异系数 CV (%)
类群ⅠGroup Ⅰ	42	19.27	RGP	0.64	1.00	0.86	9.14
			RGR	0.87	1.00	0.95	3.33
			RGI	0.32	0.86	0.45	27.52
			PI	0.69	1.92	1.25	20.52
			DR	0.00	0.13	0.05	66.97
			隶属函数值	0.72	0.92	0.78	6.29
类群ⅡGroup Ⅱ	126	57.80	RGP	0.38	0.86	0.63	16.68
			RGR	0.66	0.99	0.84	9.90
			RGI	0.23	0.53	0.34	18.52
			PI	0.25	1.31	0.81	27.48
			DR	0.01	0.34	0.16	50.50
			隶属函数值	0.49	0.71	0.61	11.04
类群ⅢGroup Ⅲ	31	14.22	RGP	0.07	0.55	0.40	28.88
			RGR	0.49	0.89	0.65	15.40
			RGI	0.17	0.33	0.25	15.75
			PI	0.05	0.80	0.48	31.90
			DR	0.11	0.51	0.35	28.31
			隶属函数值	0.34	0.48	0.43	10.74
类群ⅣGroup Ⅳ	19	8.72	RGP	0.04	0.38	0.18	60.95
			RGR	0.07	0.46	0.34	38.24
			RGI	0.02	0.23	0.13	43.59
			PI	0.03	0.42	0.25	48.36
			DR	0.54	0.93	0.66	19.76
			隶属函数值	0.01	0.31	0.19	50.51

[1]	ZHANG Tianyu, ZHENG Zipiao, WEI Xin, ZHANG Dawei, Arman Ablimet, WU Mingzhe, MA Jun, JIAO Yang, YANG Liyun, LIU Yuanyuan, MA Qingqian, CHEN Qin, XU Haijiang. Comprehensive evaluation of salt tolerance of cotton germplasm resources at germination stage [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 62(7): 1697-1708.
[2]	LIU Leilei, ZHAO Guoqin, NIE Junfang, YU Yuehua, NI Zhiyong. Cloning and subcellular localization analysis of the GmNF-YC4 gene in soybean [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 62(6): 1365-1370.
[3]	BAI Feng, LUO Chunyan, ZHANG Kai, YU Lijuan, Nazhakaiti Ainiwaner, MA Junde, Jumaheng Tayierbieke, Talihati Kemailebayi, Aminiguti Abulaizi, Maerziya Yasen, ZHOU Xirong, ZHANG Yanhua. Correlation and principal component analysis of body weight and body size in Kazakh sheep [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 62(6): 1552-1560.
[4]	LIU Xuhuan, YU Shan, LIU Yue, SHI Shubing. Comprehensive evaluation of low temperature tolerance of different varieties of spring wheat seeds during germination [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 62(4): 820-828.
[5]	LI Ming, ZHENG Huanbin, WANG Mingjing, ZHAO Beifang, ZHANG Sitong, YANG Suxin. Effect of salt stress on soybean roots and GWAS analysis in seedling stage [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 62(3): 627-643.
[6]	CHEN Hui, ZHANG Yongqiang, BI Haiyan, TANJun , CHEN Chuanxin, XU Qijiang, NIE Shihui, YU Jianxin, LU Dong, LEI Junjie. Yield formation characteristics of different spring wheat varieties in dryland farming area of Xinjiang [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 62(1): 13-20.
[7]	DU Xiaojing, HOU Tianyu, LI Dong, LYU Yuping, YUAN Jie, ZHANG Yanhong, ZHAO Zhiqiang, Buhaliqiemu Abulizi, WANG Fengbin. Identification of drought tolerance and selection of excellent varieties of rice seeds at germination stage [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 62(1): 95-102.
[8]	LIU Huijie, WANG Junhao, GONG Zhaolong, LIANG Yajun, WANG Junduo, LI Xueyuan, ZHENG Juyun, WANG Jichuan. Identification of salt tolerance of 197 upland cotton varieties at germination stage [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(7): 1574-1581.
[9]	Mahemuti Abulaiti, Muhetaer zhare, Mireguli Waili, Hadier Yishake. Correlation and regression analysis between leaf margin scorch diseases and leaf nutrient content of walnut [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(4): 945-953.
[10]	YANG Xiangbo, CHEN Liangyu, YANG Songnan, CHEN Xifeng, XING Weiming, LI Xueying, CONG Weixuan, ZANG Zhenyuan, ZANG Yuanbo, ZHANG Jun. Phenotype analysis and comprehensive evaluation of spring soybean germplasm resources from northeast China [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 61(12): 2921-2933.
[11]	SONG Bingmei, JIANG Yan, CHEN Xin, ZHANG Yu, CHENG Wannan, PAN Hongsheng. Evaluation of saline/alkali tolerance of new transgenic High-Yield cotton at germination and seedling stages [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 60(9): 2239-2247.
[12]	MAO Xiaofei, HUANG Shiping, YIN Fangliu, ZENG Youling. Prokaryotic expression of HcALDH7B4 gene enhanced salt tolerance and drought resistance [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 60(8): 2006-2012.
[13]	SHI Xiaolei, DING Sunlei, CONG Hua, ZHANG Jinbo, QU Kejia, WANG Xingzhou, HAN dai, YAN Yongliang. Gray correlation analysis of reast soybean yield correlation traits [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 60(7): 1641-1652.
[14]	YAN Yongliang, ZHANG Heng, QU Kejia, SHI Xiaolei, WANG Xingzhou, ZHANG Jinbo, CONG Hua. Comparative study on the agronomic traits and yields of different soybean varieties [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 60(7): 1653-1662.
[15]	ZHAO Lianjia, LI Gan, XU Lin, YAN Guorong, LIU Ning, WANG Fan, DENG Chaohong, Abudukeyoumu Abudurezike, WANG Cong, WANG Wei. Analysis of the main characters of soybean varieties in Xinjiang and their correlation with yield [J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 60(7): 1663-1670.

品种 Varieties	相对发芽势 RGP	相对发芽率 RGR	相对发芽指数 RGI	萌发耐旱指数 PI	伤害率 DR	隶属函数值 Membership function	分类 Classification	来源 Source
No.10294	0.88	0.95	0.86	1.66	0.05	0.92	I	日本
东农60	0.93	0.95	0.58	1.92	0.05	0.90	I	中国黑龙江
PI475810	0.95	0.98	0.55	1.79	0.02	0.89	I	日本
No.3226	0.83	0.91	0.80	1.37	0.09	0.86	I	日本
FtC039	0.92	0.97	0.56	1.44	0.03	0.85	I	日本
JiangJinQingPiDou	0.94	0.94	0.47	1.48	0.06	0.82	I	日本
FtC005	0.93	0.99	0.39	1.45	0.01	0.82	I	日本
Uzbekskaja-2	0.94	0.99	0.36	1.49	0.01	0.82	I	日本
Union	0.94	0.99	0.38	1.43	0.01	0.81	I	日本
FtC054	0.96	0.99	0.36	1.41	0.01	0.81	I	日本

品种 Varieties	相对发芽势 RGP	相对发芽率 RGR	相对发芽指数 RGI	萌发耐旱指数 PI	伤害率 DR	隶属函数值 Membership function	分类 Classification	来源 Source
No.10294	0.88	0.95	0.86	1.66	0.05	0.92	I	日本
东农60	0.93	0.95	0.58	1.92	0.05	0.90	I	中国黑龙江
PI475810	0.95	0.98	0.55	1.79	0.02	0.89	I	日本
No.3226	0.83	0.91	0.80	1.37	0.09	0.86	I	日本
FtC039	0.92	0.97	0.56	1.44	0.03	0.85	I	日本
JiangJinQingPiDou	0.94	0.94	0.47	1.48	0.06	0.82	I	日本
FtC005	0.93	0.99	0.39	1.45	0.01	0.82	I	日本
Uzbekskaja-2	0.94	0.99	0.36	1.49	0.01	0.82	I	日本
Union	0.94	0.99	0.38	1.43	0.01	0.81	I	日本
FtC054	0.96	0.99	0.36	1.41	0.01	0.81	I	日本

品种编号 ID	原始值 Primary	回归值 Regression	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy(%)	品种编号 ID	原始值 Primary	回归值 Regression	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy(%)
HG-218	0.92	0.92	100.00	HG-005	0.77	0.77	99.98
HG-159	0.90	0.90	99.99	HG-076	0.76	0.76	99.98
HG-189	0.89	0.89	100.00	HG-077	0.76	0.76	99.99
HG-217	0.86	0.86	99.99	HG-022	0.76	0.76	99.99
HG-204	0.85	0.85	99.99	HG-052	0.75	0.75	99.98
HG-184	0.82	0.82	99.99	HG-176	0.75	0.75	99.99
HG-201	0.82	0.82	99.99	HG-119	0.75	0.75	99.97
HG-188	0.82	0.82	99.99	HG-187	0.75	0.75	99.98
HG-180	0.81	0.81	99.99	HG-163	0.75	0.75	99.98
HG-205	0.81	0.81	99.99	HG-088	0.74	0.74	99.95
HG-175	0.80	0.80	99.99	HG-216	0.74	0.74	99.97
HG-169	0.80	0.80	99.99	HG-147	0.74	0.74	99.97
HG-111	0.79	0.79	99.99	HG-144	0.74	0.74	99.98
HG-108	0.79	0.79	99.98	HG-197	0.74	0.74	99.98
HG-200	0.79	0.79	99.98	HG-179	0.74	0.74	99.98
HG-214	0.79	0.79	99.99	HG-008	0.73	0.73	99.98
HG-177	0.78	0.78	99.99	HG-148	0.73	0.73	99.98
HG-150	0.78	0.78	99.98	HG-211	0.73	0.73	99.98
HG-208	0.77	0.77	99.99	HG-023	0.73	0.73	99.95
HG-115	0.77	0.77	99.99	HG-038	0.73	0.73	99.98
HG-185	0.77	0.77	99.99	HG-103	0.72	0.72	99.99

品种编号 ID	原始值 Primary	回归值 Regression	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy(%)	品种编号 ID	原始值 Primary	回归值 Regression	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy(%)
HG-218	0.92	0.92	100.00	HG-005	0.77	0.77	99.98
HG-159	0.90	0.90	99.99	HG-076	0.76	0.76	99.98
HG-189	0.89	0.89	100.00	HG-077	0.76	0.76	99.99
HG-217	0.86	0.86	99.99	HG-022	0.76	0.76	99.99
HG-204	0.85	0.85	99.99	HG-052	0.75	0.75	99.98
HG-184	0.82	0.82	99.99	HG-176	0.75	0.75	99.99
HG-201	0.82	0.82	99.99	HG-119	0.75	0.75	99.97
HG-188	0.82	0.82	99.99	HG-187	0.75	0.75	99.98
HG-180	0.81	0.81	99.99	HG-163	0.75	0.75	99.98
HG-205	0.81	0.81	99.99	HG-088	0.74	0.74	99.95
HG-175	0.80	0.80	99.99	HG-216	0.74	0.74	99.97
HG-169	0.80	0.80	99.99	HG-147	0.74	0.74	99.97
HG-111	0.79	0.79	99.99	HG-144	0.74	0.74	99.98
HG-108	0.79	0.79	99.98	HG-197	0.74	0.74	99.98
HG-200	0.79	0.79	99.98	HG-179	0.74	0.74	99.98
HG-214	0.79	0.79	99.99	HG-008	0.73	0.73	99.98
HG-177	0.78	0.78	99.99	HG-148	0.73	0.73	99.98
HG-150	0.78	0.78	99.98	HG-211	0.73	0.73	99.98
HG-208	0.77	0.77	99.99	HG-023	0.73	0.73	99.95
HG-115	0.77	0.77	99.99	HG-038	0.73	0.73	99.98
HG-185	0.77	0.77	99.99	HG-103	0.72	0.72	99.99