Laboratory Insecticides Screening and Field Efficacy Evaluation against Myzus persicae on Broccoli Field

doi:10.6048/j.issn.1001-4330.2023.03.004

Abstract

Abstract:

【Objective】 To screen the effective insecticides against Myzus persicae on Broccoli field.【Methods】 The toxicity bioassay and field efficacy tests were carried out by dipping method and spraying. 【Results】 The laboratory toxicity test results showed that the LC₅₀ of flupyradifurone had the highest toxicity, which was 7.67 mg/L at 48 h. The LC₅₀ of ambda-cyhalothrin showed the lowest toxicity, which was 1,011.03 mg/L at 48 h. The order of the toxicity of the eighteen insecticides from high to low was as follows: flupyradifurone﹥ sulfoxaflor ﹥ abamectin ﹥ciprofloxacin﹥ thiamethoxam ﹥chlorfenapyr﹥ veratrine﹥ imidacloprid ﹥emamectinbencoate ﹥ clothianidin ﹥acetamiprid ﹥cyantraniliprole﹥ matrine ﹥spirotetramat ﹥flonicamid﹥ tolfenpyrad ﹥spinetoram﹥ ambda-cyhalothrin. Five highly toxicity insecticides were selected for field trials on this basis. The results showed that treatment of five kinds of insecticides at different concentrations had a higher control effect on Myzus persicae. The field control efficacies of five kinds of insecticides were 70.10% 90.11% after seven days of application; The field control efficacies of five kinds insecticides were 56.93% 82.55% after fourteen days of application. 【Conclusion】 Therefore, it was suggested sulfoxaflor and flupyradifurone should be used in the production to ensure the sensitivity of pests to insecticides so as to delay the resistance of pests.

Key words: broccoli; Myzus persicae; toxicity tests; field efficacy evaluation

摘要：

【目的】筛选防治西蓝花田桃蚜的有效药剂。【方法】采用浸虫浸叶法及田间喷雾法进行室内毒力及田间药效试验。【结果】17%氟吡呋喃酮SL对桃蚜最为敏感,而5%高效氯氟氰菊酯ME的敏感性最差,48 h的LC₅₀分别为7.67和1 011.03 mg/L。供试药剂毒力大小低依次为氟吡呋喃酮>氟啶虫胺腈>阿维菌素>双丙环虫酯>噻虫嗪>虫螨腈>藜芦碱>吡虫啉>甲氨基阿维菌素苯甲酸盐>噻虫胺>啶虫脒>溴氰虫酰胺>苦参碱>螺虫乙酯>氟啶虫酰胺>唑虫酰胺>乙基多杀菌素>高效氯氟氰菊酯。5种药剂不同浓度处理对西蓝花桃蚜均具有较好的防治效果。施药后7 d,各处理对西蓝花桃蚜的防效达70.10%~90.11%;药后14 d,各处理对西蓝花桃蚜防效为56.93%~82.55%。【结论】生产中可轮换使用氟啶虫胺腈和氟吡呋喃酮,以保证害虫对药剂的敏感性,减缓害虫的抗药性。

关键词: 西蓝花, 桃蚜, 室内毒力, 田间药效评价

CLC Number:

ZHAO Binrong, TIAN Xiaoxi, CHAI Junfa, JING Liangliang, ZHANG Hongyan, HONG Bo, JIA Yanxia. Laboratory Insecticides Screening and Field Efficacy Evaluation against Myzus persicae on Broccoli Field[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 60(3): 547-554.

赵斌荣, 田晓曦, 柴军发, 景亮亮, 张红艳, 洪波, 贾彦霞. 西蓝花田桃蚜的室内药剂筛选及田间药效评价[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2023, 60(3): 547-554.

Figures/Tables 3

References 24

[1]	彭昭之. 第二届中国(宁夏)六盘山冷凉蔬菜节开幕[J]. 农产品市场周刊, 2013,(30):9.
	PENG Zhaozhi. The second China (Ningxia) liupanshan cold vegetable festival opened[J]. Agricultural Products Market Weekly, 2013,(30): 9.
[2]	张慧慧, 陈安琪, 单提升. 等. 京郊西兰花小菜蛾的田间防治药剂筛选与评价[J]. 植物保护, 2020, 46(1):262-265.
	ZHANG Huihui, CHEN Anqi, SHAN Tisheng, et al. Screening and evaluation of the field efficacies of insecticides against Plutella xylostella on Brassica oleracea var italica insuburban of Beijng[J]. Plant Protection, 2020, 46(1): 262-265.
[3]	汤秋玲, 马康生, 高希武. 蔬菜蚜虫抗药性现状及抗性治理策略[J]. 植物保护, 2016, 42(6):11-20.
	TANG Qiuling, MA Kangsheng, GAO Xiwu. Current status and management strategies of insecticide resistance in Aphids on the vegetable crops[J]. Plant Protection, 2016, 42(6): 11-20.
[4]	管致和, 魏德忠, 柳支英. 蔬菜害虫及其防治[M]. 上海: 上海科学技术出版社, 1965.
	GUAN Zhihe, WEI Dezhong, LIU Zhiying. Vegetable pests and their control[M]. Shanghai: Shanghai Publisher of Science and Technology, 1965.
[5]	王胤, 王新凯, 李锦. 等. 4种药剂对辣椒蚜虫的防治效果[J]. 浙江农业科学, 2018, 59(12):2171-2173.
	WANG Yin, WANG Xinkai, LI Jin, et al. Field efficacy of four insecticides against Aphid on Chili[J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2018, 59(12): 2171-2173.
[6]	林星华, 胡小敏, 王云虎. 等. 捕杀特·黄板对大棚番茄桃蚜及蚜传病毒病的防治效果[J]. 西北农业学报, 2011, 20(3):199-202.
	LIN Xinghua, HU Xiaomin, WANG Yunhu, et al. Control effect of bushate yellow-board on Myzus persicae and Aphid-borne virus disease in tomato greenhouse[J]. Acta Agriculturae Boreali-occidentalis Sinica, 2011, 20(3): 199-202.
[7]	周晓静, 白素芬, 李欣. 等. 蜜露检测法在转基因棉抗蚜性指标中的应用[J]. 河南农业大学学报, 2012, 46(1):53-57.
	ZHOU Xiaojing, BAI Sufen, LI Xin, et al. Application of honeydew colormetry in determining indexes of Aphid resistance of transgenic insectresistant cottons[J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural University, 2012, 46(1): 53-57.
[8]	戴长庚, 薛明健, 李鸿波. 等. 常见杀虫剂对菜蚜室内毒力测定和田间防效试验[J]. 北方园艺, 2018,(17):55-58.
	DAI Changgeng, XUE Mingjian, LI Hongbo, et al. Toxicity and field control efficacy of common insecticides against Lipaphis erysimi[J]. Northern Horticulture, 2018,(17): 55-58.
[9]	宫亚军, 石宝才, 康总江. 等. 7种农药对瓜蚜的室内毒力测定[J]. 农药, 2012, 51(4):296-297.
	GONG Yajun, SHI Baocai, KANG Zongjiang, et al. Toxicities of seven types of pesticide to the melon aphid Aphis gossypii[J]. Agrochemicals, 2012, 51(4): 296-297.
[10]	叶萱. 新颖杀虫剂sulfoxaflor的生物特性[J]. 世界农药, 2011, 33(4):19-24.
	YE Xuan. Biological characteristics of a novel insecticide sulfoxaflo[J]. World Agrochemicals, 2011, 33(4): 19-24.
[11]	李晨雨, 臧传江, 朱少杰. 等. 新烟碱类杀虫剂氟吡呋喃酮的研究开发现状与展望[J]. 农药, 2018, 57(11):785-788.
	LI Chengyu, ZANG Chuangjiang, ZHU Shaojie, et al. Research status and prospect of flupyradifurone, a new neonicotinoid insecticide[J]. Agrochemicals, 2018, 57(11): 785-788.
[12]	Cahill M, Jarvis W, Gorman K, et al. Resolution of baseline responses and documentation of resistance to buprofezin in Bemisia tabaci (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae)[J]. Bulletin of Entomological Research, 1996, 86(2):117-122. DOI URL
[13]	庄明, 高德良, 徐娜娜. 等. 七种烟碱类杀虫剂对甘蓝蚜虫的室内毒力比较[J]. 山东化工, 2018, 47(7):39-40.
	ZHUANG Ming, GAO Deliang, XU Nana, et ai. Toxicity comparlson of seven nicotine pesticides to cabbage Aphids[J]. Shandong Chemical Industry, 2018, 47(7): 39-40.
[14]	王圆圆, 刘廷辉, 李静. 等. 5种杀虫剂对甘蓝蚜和瓢虫的选择性毒力及田间防效[J]. 农药, 2012, 51(11):829-831.
	WANG Yuanyuan, LIU Tinghui, LI Jing, et al. Selective toxicity tests and field trials of five kinds of insecticide to Brevicory brassicae and ladybeeties[J]. Agrochemicals, 2012, 51(11): 829-831.
[15]	徐广春, 孙亚萍, 徐德进. 等. 设施大棚辣椒蚜虫对烟碱类药剂的敏感性[J]. 江苏农业科学, 2016, 44(4):177-178.
	XU Guangchun, SUN Yaping, XU Dejin, et al. Sensitivity of capsicumAphidsto nicotinic agents in greenhouse[J]. Jiangsu Agricultural Sciences, 2016, 44(4): 177-178.
[16]	张新, 赵莉, 陈娟. 八种杀虫剂对桃蚜的毒力测定[J]. 北方果树, 2011,(2):10-11.
	ZHANG Xin, ZHAO Li, CHEN Juan. Toxicity of eight insecticides against Myzus persicae[J]. Northern Fruits, 2011,(2): 10-11.
[17]	何秉青, 徐宝云, 谢文. 等. 9种药剂对芹菜蚜的毒力测定及田间药效评价[J]. 中国蔬菜, 2014,(1):24-26.
	HE Bingqing, XU Baoyun, XIE Wen, et al. Toxicity and field efficacy of nine insecticides against Semiaphis heraclei[J]. China Vegetables, 2014,(1): 24-26.
[18]	王立, 崔丽, 王芹芹. 等. 氟啶虫胺腈的杀虫作用机理及亚致死剂量影响昆虫生殖的研究进展[C]. 中国植物保护学会2018年学术年会暨植保科技奖颁奖大会, 中国陕西西安, 2018.
	WANG Li, CUI Li, WANG Qinqin, et al. Research progress on insecticidal mechanism of firidifenazil and effects of sublethal dose on insect reproduction[C]. The 2018 annual Conference of Chinese Plant Protection Society and Award ceremony of Plant Protection Science and Technology Award. Xi'an City, Shanxi Province, 2018.
[19]	于福强, 黄耀师, 苏州. 等. 新颖杀虫剂氟啶虫胺腈[J]. 农药, 2013, 52(10):753-755.
	YU Fuqiang, HUANG Yaoshi, SU Zhou, et al. A novel insecticides Sulfoxaflor[J]. Agrochemicals, 2013, 52(10): 753-755
[20]	王欢欢. 九种杀虫剂对瓜蚜的毒力及协同增效药剂筛选[D]. 泰安: 山东农业大学, 2019.
	WANG Huanhuan. Toxicities and screening synergies of nine insecticides against Aphis gossypii Gliver[D]. Tai’an: Shandong Agricultural University, 2019.
[21]	尚娇, 丁建朋, 姚永生. 氟啶虫胺腈对棉田蚜虫的毒力测定及瓢虫的安全性评价[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2019, 56(3):481-488. DOI
	SAHNG Jiao, DING Jianpeng, YAO Yongsheng. The Toxicity of Sulfoxaflor to Aphids and Safety Evaluation of Ladybugs in Cotton Fields[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2019, 56(3): 481-488 DOI
[22]	宫庆涛, 武海斌, 张坤鹏. 等. 氟啶虫胺腈对苹果黄蚜室内毒力测定及田间防治效果[J]. 农药, 2014, 53(10):759-761.
	GONG Qingtao, Wu Haibin, ZHANG Kunpeng, et al. Laboratory Activity and Field Efficacy of Sulfoxaflor against Aphis citricola[J]. Agrochemicals, 2014, 53(10): 759-761.
[23]	郭晓君, 封云涛, 李娅. 等. 氟啶虫胺腈与其他药剂复配对苹果黄蚜的联合毒力及效果评价[J]. 植物保护, 2020, 46(4):243-247.
	GUO Xiaojun, FENG Yuntao, LI Ya, et al. Co-toxicities and efficacy evaluation of sulfoxaflor mixed with other insecticides on Aphis citricola[J]. Plant Protection, 2020, 46(4): 243-247.
[24]	牛雨佳. 短翅蚜小蜂防治蔬菜桃蚜的潜能评价[D]. 杨凌: 西北农林科技大学, 2015.
	NIU Yujia. The potential of aphelinus asychis walker as a biological control agent against Myzus persicae[D]. Yangling: North west Agriculture and Forestry University, 2015.

供试药剂 Insecticide	剂型 Dosage form	有效成分 Effective ingredient	浓度(有效成分用量) Concentration(Dosage of active ingredient)(mg/L)
噻虫嗪Thiamethoxam	WG	25%	200、100 、50 、25、12.5、6.25 、3.125
噻虫胺Clothianidin	SC	20%	100、50、25、12.5、6.25 、3.125 、1.562 5
啶虫脒Acetamiprid	ME	10%	240、120 、60、30、 15 、7.5 、3.75
吡虫啉Imidacloprid	WG	70%	168 、84 、42 、21、10.5、5.25、2.625
氟啶虫胺腈Sulfoxaflor	WG	50%	200、100、50、25、12.5、6.25、3.125
氟吡呋喃酮Flupyradifurone	SL	17%	204、102、51、25.5、12.75、6.375、3.1875
螺虫乙酯Spirotetramat	SC	22.4%	224、112、56、28、14、7、3.5
高效氯氟氰菊酯Ambda-cyhalothrin	ME	5%	320、160、80、40、20、10、5
溴氰虫酰胺Cyantraniliprole	OD	10%	160、80、40、20、10、5、2.5
虫螨腈Chlorfenapyr	SC	10%	200、100、50、25、12.5、6.25、3.125
唑虫酰胺Tolfenpyrad	SC	15%	300、150、75、37.5、18.75、9.375、4.685
双丙环虫酯Ciprofloxacin	DC	50 g/L	100、50、25、12.5、6.25、3.125
甲氨基阿维菌素苯甲酸盐 Emamectinbencoate	ME	5%	48、24、12、6、3、1.5、0.75
阿维菌素Abamectin	EC	1.8%	120、60、30、15、7.5、3.75、1.875
氟啶虫酰胺Flonicamid	WG	10%	320、160、80、40、20、10、5
苦参碱Matrine	AS	0.5%	144、72、36、18、9、4.5、2.25
藜芦碱Veratrine	SL	0.5%	104、52、26、13、6.5、3.25、1.625
乙基多杀菌素Spinetoram	SC	60 g/L	360、180、90、45、22.5、11.25、5.625

供试药剂 Insecticide	剂型 Dosage form	有效成分 Effective ingredient	浓度(有效成分用量) Concentration(Dosage of active ingredient)(mg/L)
噻虫嗪Thiamethoxam	WG	25%	200、100 、50 、25、12.5、6.25 、3.125
噻虫胺Clothianidin	SC	20%	100、50、25、12.5、6.25 、3.125 、1.562 5
啶虫脒Acetamiprid	ME	10%	240、120 、60、30、 15 、7.5 、3.75
吡虫啉Imidacloprid	WG	70%	168 、84 、42 、21、10.5、5.25、2.625
氟啶虫胺腈Sulfoxaflor	WG	50%	200、100、50、25、12.5、6.25、3.125
氟吡呋喃酮Flupyradifurone	SL	17%	204、102、51、25.5、12.75、6.375、3.1875
螺虫乙酯Spirotetramat	SC	22.4%	224、112、56、28、14、7、3.5
高效氯氟氰菊酯Ambda-cyhalothrin	ME	5%	320、160、80、40、20、10、5
溴氰虫酰胺Cyantraniliprole	OD	10%	160、80、40、20、10、5、2.5
虫螨腈Chlorfenapyr	SC	10%	200、100、50、25、12.5、6.25、3.125
唑虫酰胺Tolfenpyrad	SC	15%	300、150、75、37.5、18.75、9.375、4.685
双丙环虫酯Ciprofloxacin	DC	50 g/L	100、50、25、12.5、6.25、3.125
甲氨基阿维菌素苯甲酸盐 Emamectinbencoate	ME	5%	48、24、12、6、3、1.5、0.75
阿维菌素Abamectin	EC	1.8%	120、60、30、15、7.5、3.75、1.875
氟啶虫酰胺Flonicamid	WG	10%	320、160、80、40、20、10、5
苦参碱Matrine	AS	0.5%	144、72、36、18、9、4.5、2.25
藜芦碱Veratrine	SL	0.5%	104、52、26、13、6.5、3.25、1.625
乙基多杀菌素Spinetoram	SC	60 g/L	360、180、90、45、22.5、11.25、5.625

供试药剂 Insecticide	LC₅₀(95%置信限) LC₅₀(95% confidence interval)(mg/L)	斜率± 标准误差 Slope±SE	相关系数 Correlation coefficient	􀱽² (df=5)	P	相对毒力 Relative toxicity
5%高效氯氟氰菊酯ME Ambda-cyhalothrin 5% ME	1 011.03(238.20~448 532.58)	0.36±0.12	0.965 4	0.76	0.98	1
17%氟吡呋喃酮SL Flupyradifurone 17% SL	7.67(4.51~11.20)	0.91±0.11	0.984 3	2.01	0.85	131.82
50%氟啶虫胺腈WG Sulfoxaflor 50% WG	8.01(4.55~11.92)	0.79±0.10	0.985 7	1.65	0.90	126.22
1.8%阿维菌素EC Abamectin 1.8% EC	8.16(5.99~10.56)	1.27±0.13	0.973 3	7.21	0.21	123.90
50g/L环丙环虫酯DC Ciprofloxacin 50 g/L DC	11.99(6.32~22.35)	0.50±0.11	0.938 4	3.21	0.67	84.32
25%噻虫嗪WG Thiamethoxam 25% WG	12.66(8.33~17.30)	1.03±0.11	0.982 7	3.90	0.56	79.86
10%虫螨腈SC Chlorfenapyr 10% SC	13.48(9.70~17.73)	1.07±0.11	0.987 7	2.59	0.76	75.00
0.5%藜芦碱SL Veratrine 0.5% SL	13.88(10.55~18.36)	1.08±0.12	0.991 1	1.83	0.87	72.84
70%吡虫啉WG Imidacloprid 70% WG	15.58(9.77~23.39)	0.71±0.11	0.970 3	2.61	0.76	64.89
5%甲氨基阿维菌素苯甲酸盐ME Emamectinbencoate 5% ME	15.73(10.78~26.92)	0.91±0.13	0.959 4	5.53	0.35	64.27
20%噻虫胺SC Clothianidin 20% SC	18.50(12.39~29.89)	0.71±0.11	0.957 7	4.67	0.46	54.65
10%啶虫脒ME Acetamiprid 10% ME	24.69(19.16~31.29)	1.36±0.14	0.971 2	6.47	0.26	40.95
10%溴氰虫酰胺OD Cyantraniliprole 10% OD	28.46(17.89~49.81)	0.61±0.11	0.955 7	3.34	0.65	35.52
0.5%苦参碱AS Matrine 0.5% AS	36.88(24.72~63.24)	0.75±0.11	0.950 5	5.07	0.41	27.41
22.4%螺虫乙酯SC Spirotetramat 22.4% SC	44.66(29.11~76.18)	0.63±0.10	0.979 0	1.68	0.89	22.64
10%氟啶虫酰胺WG Flonicamid 10% WG	45.46(32.25~65.26)	0.85±0.11	0.974 3	3.62	0.61	22.24
15%唑虫酰胺SC Tolfenpyrad 15% SC	127.15(84.72~230.84)	0.82±0.11	0.994 9	0.53	0.99	7.95
60 g/L乙基多杀菌素SC Spinetoram 60 g/L SC	982.31(322.40~18113.98)	0.58±0.14	0.972 9	0.66	0.99	1.03

供试药剂 Insecticide	LC₅₀(95%置信限) LC₅₀(95% confidence interval)(mg/L)	斜率± 标准误差 Slope±SE	相关系数 Correlation coefficient	􀱽² (df=5)	P	相对毒力 Relative toxicity
5%高效氯氟氰菊酯ME Ambda-cyhalothrin 5% ME	1 011.03(238.20~448 532.58)	0.36±0.12	0.965 4	0.76	0.98	1
17%氟吡呋喃酮SL Flupyradifurone 17% SL	7.67(4.51~11.20)	0.91±0.11	0.984 3	2.01	0.85	131.82
50%氟啶虫胺腈WG Sulfoxaflor 50% WG	8.01(4.55~11.92)	0.79±0.10	0.985 7	1.65	0.90	126.22
1.8%阿维菌素EC Abamectin 1.8% EC	8.16(5.99~10.56)	1.27±0.13	0.973 3	7.21	0.21	123.90
50g/L环丙环虫酯DC Ciprofloxacin 50 g/L DC	11.99(6.32~22.35)	0.50±0.11	0.938 4	3.21	0.67	84.32
25%噻虫嗪WG Thiamethoxam 25% WG	12.66(8.33~17.30)	1.03±0.11	0.982 7	3.90	0.56	79.86
10%虫螨腈SC Chlorfenapyr 10% SC	13.48(9.70~17.73)	1.07±0.11	0.987 7	2.59	0.76	75.00
0.5%藜芦碱SL Veratrine 0.5% SL	13.88(10.55~18.36)	1.08±0.12	0.991 1	1.83	0.87	72.84
70%吡虫啉WG Imidacloprid 70% WG	15.58(9.77~23.39)	0.71±0.11	0.970 3	2.61	0.76	64.89
5%甲氨基阿维菌素苯甲酸盐ME Emamectinbencoate 5% ME	15.73(10.78~26.92)	0.91±0.13	0.959 4	5.53	0.35	64.27
20%噻虫胺SC Clothianidin 20% SC	18.50(12.39~29.89)	0.71±0.11	0.957 7	4.67	0.46	54.65
10%啶虫脒ME Acetamiprid 10% ME	24.69(19.16~31.29)	1.36±0.14	0.971 2	6.47	0.26	40.95
10%溴氰虫酰胺OD Cyantraniliprole 10% OD	28.46(17.89~49.81)	0.61±0.11	0.955 7	3.34	0.65	35.52
0.5%苦参碱AS Matrine 0.5% AS	36.88(24.72~63.24)	0.75±0.11	0.950 5	5.07	0.41	27.41
22.4%螺虫乙酯SC Spirotetramat 22.4% SC	44.66(29.11~76.18)	0.63±0.10	0.979 0	1.68	0.89	22.64
10%氟啶虫酰胺WG Flonicamid 10% WG	45.46(32.25~65.26)	0.85±0.11	0.974 3	3.62	0.61	22.24
15%唑虫酰胺SC Tolfenpyrad 15% SC	127.15(84.72~230.84)	0.82±0.11	0.994 9	0.53	0.99	7.95
60 g/L乙基多杀菌素SC Spinetoram 60 g/L SC	982.31(322.40~18113.98)	0.58±0.14	0.972 9	0.66	0.99	1.03

供试药剂 Insecticide	浓度设置 Concentration (mg/L)	药前虫口数 Population size before application	药后1 d 1th day after treatment		药后3 d 3th day after treatment		药后5 d 5th day after treatment		药后7 d 7th day after treatment		药后10 d 10th day after treatment		药后14 d 14th day after treatment
供试药剂 Insecticide	浓度设置 Concentration (mg/L)	药前虫口数 Population size before application	虫口减退率 Reducing rate of insects(%)	防效 Control efficacy (%)	虫口减退率 Reducing rate of insects(%)	防效 Control efficacy (%)	虫口减退率 Reducing rate of insects(%)	防效 Control efficacy (%)	虫口减退率 Reducing rate of insects(%)	防效 Control efficacy (%)	虫口减退率 Reducing rate of insects(%)	防效 Control efficacy (%)	虫口减退率 Reducing rate of insects(%)	防效 Control efficacy (%)
氟啶虫胺腈 Sulfoxaflor	50	590	51.69	71.25^a	59.15	79.12^a	65.76	85.42^a	87.46	89.43^a	58.98	83.80^a	14.24	80.69^a
	40	642	45.79	67.74^a	51.09	75.00^a	58.41	82.29^ab	83.33	85.95^b	51.40	80.81^ab	-10.75	75.06^a
	30	708	38.28	63.27^a	49.44	74.15^a	50.99	79.14^b	80.23	83.33^b	36.58	74.96^b	-23.31	72.24^a
虫螨腈 Chlorfenapyr	134	720	33.33	60.33^a	50.97	74.93^a	43.06	75.76^a	71.81	76.23^a	35.83	74.66^a	-48.06	66.66^a
	100	742	22.37	53.80^a	38.41	68.51^a	38.41	73.78^a	70.75	75.35^a	19.54	68.23^a	-73.05	61.04^a
	66	810	18.89	51.73^a	35.31	66.93^a	34.57	72.14^a	68.89	73.77^a	7.41	63.43^a	-75.31	60.53^a
甲氨基阿维菌素苯甲酸盐 Emamectinbencoate	6	708	31.36	59.15^a	48.45	73.64^a	39.12	74.08^a	70.90	75.47^a	24.72	70.27^a	-53.25	65.50^a
	4.5	756	17.46	50.88^a	30.29	64.36^ab	30.03	70.21^a	68.25	73.24^a	20.50	68.61^a	-73.15	61.01^a
	3	688	11.05	47.06^a	22.09	60.17^b	27.03	68.94^a	64.53	70.10^a	4.80	62.40^a	-91.28	56.93^a
氟吡呋喃酮 Flupyradifurone	136	622	54.34	72.83^a	65.59	82.41^a	69.29	86.93^a	88.26	90.11^a	66.24	86.67^a	22.51	82.55^a
	119	614	48.37	69.28^a	64.50	81.85^a	61.89	83.78^a	84.69	87.09^a	57.33	83.15^a	13.68	80.56^a
	102	634	40.06	64.33^a	55.36	77.18^a	55.99	81.27^a	81.07	84.04^a	54.89	82.19^a	-11.99	74.79^a
噻虫嗪 Thiamethoxam	40	662	36.71	62.33^a	51.51	75.21^a	47.28	77.56^a	75.53	79.37^a	40.63	76.56^a	-27.34	71.33^a
	30	626	30.35	58.55^a	39.14	68.88^ab	44.25	76.27^a	72.84	77.11^a	31.31	72.87^ab	-46.49	67.02^a
	20	622	26.21	56.08^a	35.53	67.04^b	35.37	72.49^a	69.29	74.11^a	15.76	66.73^b	-74.44	60.72^a
清水对照 CK		682	-68.04	-	-95.60	-	-134.90	-	-18.62	-	-153.23	-	-344.13	-