6种除草剂土壤封闭处理对板蓝根幼苗期生长的影响

doi:10.6048/j.issn.1001-4330.2022.03.023

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

【目的】研究6种除草剂土壤封闭处理对板蓝根幼苗期发芽率、株高、子叶长、子叶宽、平均胚根长等生物学指标的影响,筛选出6种除草剂中最佳药剂及其最佳浓度,为板蓝根的田间生产提供理论依据。【方法】通过室内盆栽法以及培养皿培养的方法,在板蓝根幼苗期,研究6种除草剂在不同施药浓度,在24~192 h对板蓝根的发芽率、平均胚根长的影响,在7、15和30 d 3个时间点对板蓝根株高,子叶长、宽影响。【结果】发芽率:精异丙甲草胺、乙氧氟草醚、仲丁灵、丙炔氟草胺各浓度处理之间差异不显著,不影响板蓝根出苗,药剂浓度高于80 mL/667m²的二甲戊灵对板蓝根的发芽率存在抑制作用,扑草净的浓度越高对板蓝根的发芽抑制就越明显;平均胚根长:精异丙甲草胺、仲丁灵、乙氧氟草醚、扑草净、丙炔氟草胺对胚根的生长没有影响,二甲戊灵随着浓度的升高,对胚根的生长抑制就越强;株高:精异丙甲草胺浓度高于30 mL/667m²时对板蓝根的株高起到抑制作用,二甲戊灵80~200 mL/667m²浓度处理对板蓝根株高有有明显抑制效果,仲丁灵对板蓝根株高无影响,乙氧氟草醚在40~70 mL/667m²浓度时对板蓝根株高有抑制作用,扑草净在80~200 mL/667m²浓度时对板蓝根的株高存在抑制效果,丙炔氟草胺在3~7 g/667m²浓度时对板蓝根的株高抑制效果不明显;子叶长:精异丙甲草胺、二甲戊灵、仲丁灵、乙氧氟草醚、丙炔氟草胺各浓度处理下对板蓝根子叶长没有影响,随着扑草净的施用浓度升高会对板蓝根的子叶长有抑制作用;子叶宽:精异丙甲草胺、二甲戊灵、仲丁灵、乙氧氟草醚、丙炔氟草胺5种除草剂各浓度处理下对板蓝根子叶宽没有影响,扑草净120~200 mL/667m²浓度会抑制板蓝根子叶宽。【结论】只有仲丁灵和丙炔氟草胺处理后对板蓝根幼苗株高没有显著影响;二甲戊灵与扑草净处理会影响板蓝根的发芽率;二甲戊灵处理会影响板蓝根幼苗的根长生长;扑草净处理会影响板蓝根子叶长、子叶宽的生长。室内条件下精异丙甲草胺、仲丁灵、丙炔氟草胺对板蓝根幼苗的生长胁迫较小。

关键词: 除草剂; 幼苗期; 发芽率; 生物学指标; 板蓝根; 杂草防除

Abstract:

【Objective】 To explore the effects of soil sealing treatments with six herbicides on the germination rate, plant height, cotyledon length, cotyledon width, average radicle length and other biological indicators of Isatis indigotica during the seedling stage, and select the best one from the six in the hope of providing a theoretical basis for its field production. 【Methods】 In the seedling stage of I indigotica, the effects of 6 herbicides on the germination rate and average radicle length of Isatis indica at 24-192 h at different application concentrations were studied by indoor pot culture and petri dish culture. 【Results】 Germination rate: the concentration of refined metolachlor, oxyfluorfen, sec-butadiene, and flumioxazin were not significantly different, and did not affect the emergence of Isatis indigotica. The concentration of the agent higher than 80 mL/667m² Pendimethalin had an inhibitory effect on the germination rate of Isatis indigotica. The higher the concentration of Promethazine, the more obvious the inhibition of the germination; the average radicle length: metolachlor, sec-butaline, oxyfluorfen, Promethazine, and flumioxazin have no effect on the growth of radicles. As the concentration of pendimethalin increased, the inhibition of radicle growth was becoming stronger; plant height: high concentration of refined metolachlor at 30 mL/667m², had an inhibitory effect on the plant height. Pendimethalin 80-200 mL/667m² treatment had a significant inhibitory effect on the plant height. F-butaline had no effect on the plant height. Ether has an inhibitory effect on the plant height at the concentration of 40-70 mL/667m². Promatoxin had an inhibitory effect on the plant height at the concentration of 80-200 mL/667m². When the concentration of flumioxazin was 3-7 g/667m², the inhibitory effect on the plant height of was not obvious; Cotyledon length: the concentration of metolachlor, pendimethalin, f-butadiene, oxyfluorfen, and flumioxazin had no effect on the cotyledon length. As the application concentration of Promatogin increased, it inhibited the cotyledon length; Cotyledon width: the 5 kinds of amine herbicides: metolachlor, pendimethalin, sec-butadiene, oxyfluorfen had no effect on the cotyledon width. Promatogin at 120-200 mL/667m² concentration would inhibit the cotyledon width. 【Conclusion】 Through the experiment of indoor pot and petri dish culture, it can be concluded that only the treatments of f-butaline and flumioxazin have no significant effect on the plant height of Isatis indigotica seedlings; the treatments of pendimethalin and promethazine will affect the growth of isatis germination rate: Pendimethalin treatment will affect the root length growth of Isatis indigotica seedlings; Promethazine treatment will affect the growth of cotyledon length and width of Isatis indigotica. Therefore, under indoor conditions, fine metolachlor, sec-butadiene and flumioxazin have less stress on the growth of Isatis indigotica seedlings.

Key words: herbicide; seedling stage; germination rate; biological index; Isatis indigotica; weed control

中图分类号:

苏攀龙, 翟羽佳, 刘新元, 杨德松. 6种除草剂土壤封闭处理对板蓝根幼苗期生长的影响[J]. 新疆农业科学, 2022, 59(3): 725-734.

SU Panlong, ZHAI Yujia, LIU Xinyuan, YANG Desong. Effects of Soil Sealing Treatments with 6 Herbicides on the Growth of Isatis indigotica Seedlings[J]. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2022, 59(3): 725-734.

图/表 7

参考文献 17

[1]	国家药典委员会. 中国药典(2015年版一部)[M]. 北京: 中国医药科技出版社, 2015.
	National Pharmacopoeia Commission. Chinese Pharmacopoeia (2015 Ed.) [M]. Beijing: China Medical Science and Technology Press, 2015.
[2]	杜丽华, 杜晓云, 狄宝期, 等. 板蓝根的生物学特性及栽培技术[J]. 特种经济动植物, 2017, 20(10): 42-43.
	DU Lihua, DU Xiaoyun, DI Baoqi, et al. The biological characteristics and cultivation techniques of Radix Isatidis[J]. Special Economic Animals and Plants, 2017, 20(10): 42-43.
[3]	王之国. 板蓝根种植技术及效益分析[J]. 种子科技, 2019, 37(5): 101.
	WANG Zhiguo. Isatis indigotica planting technology and benefit analysis[J]. Seed Science and Technology, 2019, 37(5): 101.
[4]	张丹雁, 朱家辉, 杜沛欣. 南板蓝根病虫害调查与防治[C]. 中国中西医结合学会中药专业委员会.2007年中华中医药学会第八届中药鉴定学术研讨会、2007年中国中西医结合学会中药专业委员会全国中药学术研讨会论文集.中国中西医结合学会中药专业委员会:中国中西医结合学会, 2007:199-201.
	ZHANG Danyan, ZHU Jiahui, DU Peixin. Investigation and control of diseases and insect pests of Radix Isatidis[C]. Chinese Medicine Professional Committee of Chinese Society of Integrative Medicine. 2007 the 8th Chinese Medicine Appraisal Symposium of Chinese Society of Chinese Medicine, 2007 Chinese Society of Integrative Medicine Proceedings of the National Symposium on Chinese Materia Medica of the Chinese Medicine Professional Committee. Chinese Medicine Professional Committee of the Chinese Society of Integrative Medicine: China Society of Integrative Medicine, 2007:199-201.
[5]	高玉霞. 板蓝根的用途和栽培种植技术应用[J]. 农业与技术, 2018, 38(6): 131.
	GAO Yuxia. The use of Radix Isatidis and the application of cultivation and planting technology[J]. Agriculture and Technology, 2018, 38(6): 131.
[6]	魏敏, 夏振亮. 板蓝根的主要病害及综合防治措施[J]. 特种经济动植物, 2005,(8): 41.
	WEI Min, XIA Zhenliang. The main diseases of Isatis indigotica and comprehensive control measures[J]. Special Economic Animals and Plants, 2005,(8): 41.
[7]	姜振侠. 板蓝根主要病害的识别与防治[N]. 河北科技报, 2016-02-16(B06).
	JIANG Zhenxia. Identification and prevention of the main diseases of Isatis indigotica [N]. Hebei Science and Technology News, 2016-02-16 (B06).
[8]	板蓝根的秋季病害防治[J]. 乡村科技, 2013,(10): 23.
	Unknown. Prevention and treatment of Isatis indigotica in autumn[J]. Rural Science and Technology, 2013,(10): 23.
[9]	王静华, 赵玉新, 杨莹光, 等. 板蓝根病害与虫害及其防治措施[J]. 农业与技术, 2007,(3): 103-104.
	WANG Jinghua, ZHAO Yuxin, YANG Yingguang, et al. Radix Isatidis diseases and pests and their control measures[J]. Agriculture and Technology, 2007,(3): 103-104.
[10]	张浩, 程道泉, 李良国. 板蓝根主要病虫害的发生及防治技术[J]. 北京农业, 2006,(5): 18-19.
	ZHANG Hao, CHENG Daoquan, LI Liangguo. Occurrence and control technology of main diseases and insect pests of Radix isatidis[J]. Beijing Agriculture, 2006,(5): 18-19.
[11]	贺美忠, 王瑞军, 李洪, 等. 高产高效绿色板蓝根栽培技术要点[J]. 江西农业, 2020,(8): 6-7.
	HE Meizhong, WANG Ruijun, LI Hong, et al. The key points of high-yield and high-efficiency green Isatis indigotica cultivation techniques[J]. Jiangxi Agriculture, 2020,(8): 6-7.
[12]	王灵丽, 李鑫梅. 板蓝根优质高产栽培技术操作规程[J]. 农业技术与装备, 2019,(6): 87-88.
	WANG Lingli, LI Xinmei. Operational rules for high-quality and high-yield cultivation technology of Radix Isatidis[J]. Agricultural Technology and Equipment, 2019,(6): 87-88.
[13]	袁世林, 郭凤琴, 郭庆瑞, 等. 板蓝根田大面积化学除草示范研究[J]. 山西农业科学, 2003,(4): 78-80.
	YUAN Shilin, GUO Fengqin, GUO Qingrui, et al. Demonstration study on large-scale chemical weeding in Isatis indigotica field[J]. Shanxi Agricultural Sciences, 2003,(4): 78-80.
[14]	李继英, 吕鹏秀, 邹瑜. 板蓝根田间阔叶杂草的化学防除[J]. 价值工程, 2011, 30(6): 328.
	LI Jiying, LÜ Pengxiu, ZOU Yu. Chemical control of broad-leaved weeds in Isatis indigotica field[J]. Value Engineering, 2011, 30(6): 328.
[15]	苏景, 史本栋, 于文会, 等. 复方板蓝根口服液对雏鸡白痢沙门氏菌病的防治研究[J]. 云南农业大学学报(自然科学), 2020, 35(2): 282-288.
	SU Jing, SHI Bendong, YU Wenhui, et al. Study on the prevention and treatment of Salmonella pullorum with compound Banlangen Oral Liquid[J]. Journal of Yunnan Agricultural University (Natural Science), 2020, 35(2): 282-288.
[16]	张东东, 阮德清, 李婧伊, 等. 板蓝根乙醇提取物中生物碱类化学成分研究[J]. 中华中医药杂志, 2020, 35(5): 2287-2291.
	ZHANG Dongdong, RUAN Deqing, LI Jingyi, et al. Study on the chemical constituents of alkaloids in ethanol extract of Radix Isatidis[J]. Chinese Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2020, 35(5): 2287-2291.
[17]	梁宗英, 侯继申, 孙光蕊, 等. 板蓝根多糖促进NKG2D配体表达增强NK细胞对食管癌细胞的杀伤作用及机制研究[J]. 中国免疫学杂志, 2020, 36(8): 965-970.
	LIANG Zongying, HOU Jishen, SUN Guangrui, et al. Radix Isatidis polysaccharide promotes the expression of NKG2D ligand and enhances the killing effect and mechanism of NK cells on esophageal cancer cells[J]. Chinese Journal of Immunology, 2020, 36(8): 965-970.

编辑推荐 0

Metrics

阅读次数

全文

HTML			PDF

最新录用	在线预览	正式出版	最新录用	在线预览	正式出版
0	0	19	0	0	69

来源	本网站	其他网站

次数	46	42
比例	52%	48%

摘要

906

最新录用	在线预览	正式出版

0	0	906

来源	本网站	其他网站

次数	18	888
比例	2%	98%

药剂名称 Drug name	推荐剂量 Recommended dose	生产厂家 Manufacturer
精异丙甲草胺 EC	45~55 mL/667m²	先正达(苏州)作物保护有限公司
二甲戊灵EC	110~150 mL/667m²	山东侨昌现代农业有限公司
仲丁灵EC	150~200 mL/667m²	山东胜邦绿野化学有限公司
乙氧氟草醚EC	30~50 mL/667m²	广东大丰植保科技有限公司
扑草净SC	120~150 mL/667m²	浙江省长兴第一化工有限公司
丙炔氟草胺WP	5.3~8 g/667m²	日本住友化学株式会社

药剂名称 Drug name	推荐剂量 Recommended dose	生产厂家 Manufacturer
精异丙甲草胺 EC	45~55 mL/667m²	先正达(苏州)作物保护有限公司
二甲戊灵EC	110~150 mL/667m²	山东侨昌现代农业有限公司
仲丁灵EC	150~200 mL/667m²	山东胜邦绿野化学有限公司
乙氧氟草醚EC	30~50 mL/667m²	广东大丰植保科技有限公司
扑草净SC	120~150 mL/667m²	浙江省长兴第一化工有限公司
丙炔氟草胺WP	5.3~8 g/667m²	日本住友化学株式会社

药剂处理 Pharmaceutical treatment		时间 Time (h)
药剂处理 Pharmaceutical treatment		24	48	72	96	120	144	168	192
精异丙甲草胺 EC	10	0.0±0.0^a	26.0±2.0^a	49.0±5.8^a	52±2.4^a	58±4.0^a	53.0±2.4^ab	73.0±10.5^a	72.0±11.2^a
	30	0.0±0.0^a	33.0±8.7^a	49.0±2.4^a	50±6.3^a	58±11.2^a	66.0±6.8^a	86.0±13.0^a	67.0±11.2^a
	50	0.0±0.0^a	27.0±10.3^a	33.0±12.4^a	52±8.1^a	59±3.7^a	61.0±3.7^ab	69.0±2.4^a	67.0±2.4^a
	70	0.0±0.0^a	31.0±8.4^a	48.0±11.4^a	56±5.8^a	69±8.0^a	71.0±5.8^a	72.0±2.4^a	68.0±4.0^a
	90	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±5.8^a	50.0±4.0^a	50±3.2^a	58±11.7^a	85.0±5.8^b	86.0±4.9^a	67.0±15.7^a
二甲戊灵 EC	40	0.0±0.0^a	33.0±6.8^a	45.0±5.5^ab	52.0±8.1^a	68.0±5.1^a	75.0±3.2^ab	78.0±8.1^a	80.0±5.5^a
	80	0.0±0.0^a	32.0±6.8^a	56.0±10.2^a	60.0±11.4^a	63.0±9.3^ab	77.0±9.3^a	77.0±8.7^ab	77.0±8.7^a
	120	0.0±0.0^a	32.0±10.3^a	39.0±3.7^b	48.0±6.8^a	55.0±5.5^b	53.0±6.8^d	59.0±4.9^c	61.0±6.6^b
	160	0.0±0.0^a	23.0±13.6^a	34.0±8.6^b	46.0±8.6^a	55.0±5.5^b	58.0±7.5^cd	59.0±7.3^c	61.0±5.8^b
	200	0.0±0.0^a	24.0±5.8^a	45.0±8.4^ab	52.0±8.1^a	60.0±11.4^ab	65.0±8.9^bc	65.0±11.0^bc	67.0±2.4^b
仲丁灵 EC	80	0.0±0.0^a	26.0±3.7^a	49.0±3.7^a	49.0±6.6^c	52.0±6.8^b	53.0±2.4^c	73.0±2.4^b	74.0±8.0^b
	120	0.0±0.0^a	33.0±5.1^a	49.0±3.7^a	54.0±3.7^bc	62.0±7.5^ab	66.0±6.6^b	86.0±5.8^a	88.0±5.1^a
	160	0.0±0.0^a	27.0±2.4^a	33.0±14.7^b	49.0±5.8^c	54.0±9.7^b	61.0±11.1^bc	69.0±11.6^b	69.0±8.0^b
	200	0.0±0.0^a	31.0±2.0^a	48.0±2.4^a	62.0±2.4^ab	69.0±3.7^a	71.0±7.3^b	72.0±11.2^b	75.0±5.5^b
	240	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±12.1^a	50.0±7.7^a	68.0±11.7^a	71.0±7.3^a	85.0±5.5^a	86.0±3.7^a	89.0±3.7^a
乙氧氟草醚 EC	10	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±4.0^a	50.0±7.7^a	53.0±8.7^a	56.0±5.8^a	62.0±2.4^ab	63.0±9.3^a	66.0±7.3^ab
	25	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±4.0^a	45.0±7.1^a	50.0±11.0^a	52.0±7.5^ab	59.0±6.6^ab	66.0±11.6^a	71.0±4.9^ab
	40	0.0±0.0^a	29.0±3.7^a	46.0±4.9^a	51.0±4.9^a	51.0±5.8^ab	56.0±3.7^b	60.0±5.5^a	61.0±5.8^b
	55	0.0±0.0^a	27.0±4.0^a	45.0±12.2^a	45.0±12.2^a	45.0±4.5^b	60.0±5.5^ab	63.0±5.1^a	69.0±10.2^ab
	70	0.0±0.0^a	23.0±2.4^a	44.0±8.6^a	56.0±2.0^a	57.0±9.3^a	66.0±2.0^a	65.0±8.4^a	73.0±2.4^a
药剂处理 Pharmaceutical treatment		时间 Time (h)
药剂处理 Pharmaceutical treatment		24	48	72	96	120	144	168	192
扑草净 SC	40	0.0±0.0^a	30.0±11.4^a	61.0±4.9^a	72.0±5.1^a	75±12.2^a	76.0±9.7^a	80.0±11.4^a	91.0±2.0^a
	80	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±8.7^a	37.0±10.3^b	45.0±3.2^b	46±6.6^b	56.0±14.6^bc	68.0±10.3^b	75.0±7.7^b
	120	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±2.4^a	43.0±6.8^b	49.0±11.6^b	51±8.6^b	60.0±5.5^b	64.0±3.7^bc	69±2.0^bc
	160	0.0±0.0^a	26.0±11.6^a	46.0±5.8^b	45.0±5.5^b	54±9.7^b	56.0±11.6^bc	55.0±6.3^c	65.0±7.7^c
	200	0.0±0.0^a	20.0±7.1^a	36.0±4.9^b	39.0±3.7^b	41±2.0^b	42.0±4.0^c	42.0±4.0^d	48.0±5.1^d
丙炔氟草胺 WP	3	0.0±0.0^a	26.0±5.8^ab	49±3.7^a	51±8.0^b	60±4.5^ab	60±9.5^a	65.0±5.5^b	69.0±3.25^a
	7	0.0±0.0^a	30.0±8.4^ab	47±11.2^a	47±9.3^b	53±5.1^b	54±8.6^a	62.0±8.1^b	70.0±2.57^a
	11	0.0±0.0^a	33.0±2.4^a	48±9.3^a	68±9.3^a	72±7.5^a	70±12.6^a	82.0±8.1^a	84.0±2.29^a
	15	0.0±0.0^a	29.0±3.7^ab	49±2.0^a	58±9.3^ab	63±2.4^ab	66±8.0^a	69.0±2.0^b	72.0±1.59^a
	19	0.0±0.0^a	21.0±6.6^b	33±8.7^b	49±4.9^b	52±16.0^b	64±12.4^a	67.0±12.1^b	72.0±2.68^a

药剂处理 Pharmaceutical treatment		时间 Time (h)
药剂处理 Pharmaceutical treatment		24	48	72	96	120	144	168	192
精异丙甲草胺 EC	10	0.0±0.0^a	26.0±2.0^a	49.0±5.8^a	52±2.4^a	58±4.0^a	53.0±2.4^ab	73.0±10.5^a	72.0±11.2^a
	30	0.0±0.0^a	33.0±8.7^a	49.0±2.4^a	50±6.3^a	58±11.2^a	66.0±6.8^a	86.0±13.0^a	67.0±11.2^a
	50	0.0±0.0^a	27.0±10.3^a	33.0±12.4^a	52±8.1^a	59±3.7^a	61.0±3.7^ab	69.0±2.4^a	67.0±2.4^a
	70	0.0±0.0^a	31.0±8.4^a	48.0±11.4^a	56±5.8^a	69±8.0^a	71.0±5.8^a	72.0±2.4^a	68.0±4.0^a
	90	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±5.8^a	50.0±4.0^a	50±3.2^a	58±11.7^a	85.0±5.8^b	86.0±4.9^a	67.0±15.7^a
二甲戊灵 EC	40	0.0±0.0^a	33.0±6.8^a	45.0±5.5^ab	52.0±8.1^a	68.0±5.1^a	75.0±3.2^ab	78.0±8.1^a	80.0±5.5^a
	80	0.0±0.0^a	32.0±6.8^a	56.0±10.2^a	60.0±11.4^a	63.0±9.3^ab	77.0±9.3^a	77.0±8.7^ab	77.0±8.7^a
	120	0.0±0.0^a	32.0±10.3^a	39.0±3.7^b	48.0±6.8^a	55.0±5.5^b	53.0±6.8^d	59.0±4.9^c	61.0±6.6^b
	160	0.0±0.0^a	23.0±13.6^a	34.0±8.6^b	46.0±8.6^a	55.0±5.5^b	58.0±7.5^cd	59.0±7.3^c	61.0±5.8^b
	200	0.0±0.0^a	24.0±5.8^a	45.0±8.4^ab	52.0±8.1^a	60.0±11.4^ab	65.0±8.9^bc	65.0±11.0^bc	67.0±2.4^b
仲丁灵 EC	80	0.0±0.0^a	26.0±3.7^a	49.0±3.7^a	49.0±6.6^c	52.0±6.8^b	53.0±2.4^c	73.0±2.4^b	74.0±8.0^b
	120	0.0±0.0^a	33.0±5.1^a	49.0±3.7^a	54.0±3.7^bc	62.0±7.5^ab	66.0±6.6^b	86.0±5.8^a	88.0±5.1^a
	160	0.0±0.0^a	27.0±2.4^a	33.0±14.7^b	49.0±5.8^c	54.0±9.7^b	61.0±11.1^bc	69.0±11.6^b	69.0±8.0^b
	200	0.0±0.0^a	31.0±2.0^a	48.0±2.4^a	62.0±2.4^ab	69.0±3.7^a	71.0±7.3^b	72.0±11.2^b	75.0±5.5^b
	240	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±12.1^a	50.0±7.7^a	68.0±11.7^a	71.0±7.3^a	85.0±5.5^a	86.0±3.7^a	89.0±3.7^a
乙氧氟草醚 EC	10	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±4.0^a	50.0±7.7^a	53.0±8.7^a	56.0±5.8^a	62.0±2.4^ab	63.0±9.3^a	66.0±7.3^ab
	25	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±4.0^a	45.0±7.1^a	50.0±11.0^a	52.0±7.5^ab	59.0±6.6^ab	66.0±11.6^a	71.0±4.9^ab
	40	0.0±0.0^a	29.0±3.7^a	46.0±4.9^a	51.0±4.9^a	51.0±5.8^ab	56.0±3.7^b	60.0±5.5^a	61.0±5.8^b
	55	0.0±0.0^a	27.0±4.0^a	45.0±12.2^a	45.0±12.2^a	45.0±4.5^b	60.0±5.5^ab	63.0±5.1^a	69.0±10.2^ab
	70	0.0±0.0^a	23.0±2.4^a	44.0±8.6^a	56.0±2.0^a	57.0±9.3^a	66.0±2.0^a	65.0±8.4^a	73.0±2.4^a
药剂处理 Pharmaceutical treatment		时间 Time (h)
药剂处理 Pharmaceutical treatment		24	48	72	96	120	144	168	192
扑草净 SC	40	0.0±0.0^a	30.0±11.4^a	61.0±4.9^a	72.0±5.1^a	75±12.2^a	76.0±9.7^a	80.0±11.4^a	91.0±2.0^a
	80	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±8.7^a	37.0±10.3^b	45.0±3.2^b	46±6.6^b	56.0±14.6^bc	68.0±10.3^b	75.0±7.7^b
	120	0.0±0.0^a	28.0±2.4^a	43.0±6.8^b	49.0±11.6^b	51±8.6^b	60.0±5.5^b	64.0±3.7^bc	69±2.0^bc
	160	0.0±0.0^a	26.0±11.6^a	46.0±5.8^b	45.0±5.5^b	54±9.7^b	56.0±11.6^bc	55.0±6.3^c	65.0±7.7^c
	200	0.0±0.0^a	20.0±7.1^a	36.0±4.9^b	39.0±3.7^b	41±2.0^b	42.0±4.0^c	42.0±4.0^d	48.0±5.1^d
丙炔氟草胺 WP	3	0.0±0.0^a	26.0±5.8^ab	49±3.7^a	51±8.0^b	60±4.5^ab	60±9.5^a	65.0±5.5^b	69.0±3.25^a
	7	0.0±0.0^a	30.0±8.4^ab	47±11.2^a	47±9.3^b	53±5.1^b	54±8.6^a	62.0±8.1^b	70.0±2.57^a
	11	0.0±0.0^a	33.0±2.4^a	48±9.3^a	68±9.3^a	72±7.5^a	70±12.6^a	82.0±8.1^a	84.0±2.29^a
	15	0.0±0.0^a	29.0±3.7^ab	49±2.0^a	58±9.3^ab	63±2.4^ab	66±8.0^a	69.0±2.0^b	72.0±1.59^a
	19	0.0±0.0^a	21.0±6.6^b	33±8.7^b	49±4.9^b	52±16.0^b	64±12.4^a	67.0±12.1^b	72.0±2.68^a

药剂处理 Pharmaceutical treatment		时间 Time (h)
药剂处理 Pharmaceutical treatment		24	48	72	96	120	144	168	192
精异丙甲草胺	10	0.0±0.0^a	4.48±2.43^a	6.38±1.80^a	7.00±2.30^a	7.44±2.86^a	10.03±2.92^a	9.52±2.37^a	10.55±2.99^a
	30	0.0±0.0^a	4.38±1.74^a	5.38±1.09^b	6.63±1.06^a	7.29±1.30^a	7.27±1.67^b	8.42±1.87^a	10.34±2.39^a
	50	0.0±0.0^a	3.82±1.15^a	4.71±1.12^b	5.53±1.35^b	6.72±1.12^ab	7.17±1.39^b	8.81±1.80^a	9.65±1.33^a
	70	0.0±0.0^a	4.38±1.82^a	5.38±1.66^b	5.71±1.70^b	7.02±1.62^ab	7.39±1.70^b	8.68±1.63^a	10.04±2.20^a
	90	0.0±0.0^a	4.02±1.39^a	5.15±1.50^b	5.72±1.33^b	6.25±1.46^b	7.46±1.92^b	8.57±1.57^a	9.68±1.67^a
二甲戊灵	40	0.0±0.0^a	5.58±1.61^a	6.4±1.67^a	5.77±1.22^b	7.12±1.75^a	9.13±2.49^a	8.53±1.95^a	9.14±1.72^a
	80	0.0±0.0^a	5.30±1.47^a	5.81±0.97^b	6.71±1.56^a	7.21±1.10^a	8.90±1.54^a	8.32±0.92^ab	9.02±1.75^a
	120	0.0±0.0^a	3.98±1.07^b	5.41±0.83^bc	5.68±0.84^b	6.37±0.85^b	7.71±1.89^b	7.74±1.52^b	8.06±1.10^b
	160	0.0±0.0^a	4.40±0.93^b	5.23±1.11^bc	5.83±1.01^b	6.34±1.39^b	6.47±1.00^c	6.96±1.23^c	7.23±1.44^c
	200	0.0±0.0^a	4.56±1.05^b	4.90±0.8^c	5.7±0.75^b	6.24±0.87^b	6.62±1.11^c	6.90±1.39^c	7.27±1.20^c
仲丁灵	80	0.0±0.0^a	4.17±1.38^a	6.31±1.60^a	7.80±1.74^ab	9.95±2.14^b	10.82±3.65^b	12.02±4.25^b	15.16±4.49^b
	120	0.0±0.0^a	4.95±2.12^ab	7.57±2.16^a	7.20±1.25^b	11.10±3.38^ab	12.43±4.68^ab	14.10±5.38^ab	18.17±8.59^ab
	160	0.0±0.0^a	5.37±2.30^bc	7.07±3.12^a	8.81±3.24^a	11.07±5.38^ab	13.67±6.50^a	16.14±7.66^a	20.92±8.13^a
	200	0.0±0.0^a	6.12±2.07^bc	7.03±2.83^a	9.06±3.23^a	12.84±4.80^a	13.65±4.37^a	16.40±5.05^a	19.02±6.35^a
	240	0.0±0.0^a	4.56±1.50^c	6.30±1.99^a	6.63±1.38^b	11.57±3.58^ab	13.69±4.17^a	15.20±5.75^a	19.93±5.91^a
乙氧氟草醚	10	0.0±0.0^a	4.89±2.11^b	8.93±1.88^ab	8.04±1.88^b	8.68±2.71^b	8.89±2.14^c	9.35±2.70^b	9.87±3.19^b
	25	0.0±0.0^a	6.32±2.03^a	9.5±3.34^a	10.5±3.06^a	10.85±3.71^a	11.24±4.02^ab	12.28±5.69^b	11.72±6.00^ab
	40	0.0±0.0^a	5.91±1.80^ab	9.11±1.84^ab	9.91±3.56^a	8.38±1.80^b	9.72±2.69^bc	11.67±3.30^b	11.15±3.20^ab
	55	0.0±0.0^a	5.57±2.33^ab	9.68±2.93^a	10.87±3.68^a	10.04±3.78^ab	11.61±5.37^ab	15.51±8.91^a	13.23±5.86^a
	70	0.0±0.0^a	5.22±1.68^ab	7.98±1.63^b	9.98±3.19^a	9.57±2.84^ab	12.09±3.80^a	12.30±3.39^b	9.88±3.08^b
扑草净	40	0.0±0.0^a	5.83±1.94^ab	8.27±1.81^bc	10.75±3.05^a	10.71±2.62^b	14.35±4.90^a	15.37±4.52^a	16.13±4.57^a
	80	0.0±0.0^a	6.21±1.43^a	9.67±1.71^a	10.20±2.68^a	12.21±2.75^a	13.73±2.39^a	15.19±4.13^a	15.53±2.75^a
	120	0.0±0.0^a	5.61±1.19^ab	8.42±1.55^b	11.12±3.70^a	9.91±3.59^bc	13.42±5.12^a	15.36±5.61^a	15.48±4.58^a
	160	0.0±0.0^a	5.14±1.00^b	7.91±1.47^bc	8.29±2.02^b	8.06±1.81^d	11.10±2.29^b	14.70±6.34^a	15.10±3.04^a
	200	0.0±0.0^a	5.09±1.43^b	7.37±1.77^c	7.53±2.96^b	8.55±3.25^cd	11.14±3.74^b	14.74±5.39^a	15.12±5.07^a
丙炔氟草胺	3	0.0±0.0^a	5.00±1.24^bc	6.39±1.12^c	6.22±1.77^b	7.69±1.95^ab	8.90±2.68^ab	9.71±3.02^a	10.01±3.25^a
	7	0.0±0.0^a	5.04±2.04^abc	7.04±1.16^bc	6.95±1.81^ab	7.25±1.14^ab	7.73±2.11^b	8.76±1.98^a	8.95±2.57^a
	11	0.0±0.0^a	5.83±1.35^a	7.85±1.64^a	7.53±1.81^a	8.14±2.13^a	9.23±2.13^a	9.31±2.27^a	9.65±2.29^a
	15	0.0±0.0^a	5.28±1.09^ab	7.28±1.21^ab	7.77±1.88^a	7.73±1.39^ab	9.49±2.34^a	9.22±2.20^a	9.48±1.69^a
	19	0.0±0.0^a	4.39±1.36^c	6.61±1.64^bc	6.13±0.93^b	6.97±1.04^b	8.72±2.00^ab	9.16±3.11^a	9.53±2.65^a